News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What makes a genius? by coldtea on Saturday April 22, 2017 @12:34PM (#14173279)
>I think that there is a lot of revisionism in the concept of "genius". Just look at the movie "Amadeus". It looks like Mozart genius is the envy of the mediocre Salieri. In fact, Salieri was an incredible composer himself.

That's not a "revisionism in the concept of "genius"" -- just a misrepresentation of Salieri (at best). A revisionism in the concept of genius would involve redefining what genius itself means. And in any case, nobody really thinks of Salieri as a big a genius as Mozart, movie or not.

>Then you have people like John Carmack. He is a figure in the game industry. But one of the best Doom ever has been developed without him.

So? John Carmac being a gaming genius or not doesn't preclude other geniuses, or other people being able to do equally good work (even less so since he already laid much of the groundwork for them for 2+ decades).

>The solitary genius creates an interesting narrative, but it is just a simplification of the reality. Too much get attributed to individuals once they achieve fame.

That's true.

Re:What makes a genius? by nikofeyn on Monday April 24, 2017 @02:44AM (#14182367)
i personally have never understood john carmack's "genius" role. smart guy for sure. but in many ways, i tend to think of a genius being without a peer in their direct domain, and for john carmack, that's simply not the case. the most prominent example is tim sweeney. it's just that he isn't as big into marketing himself as carmack is. tim sweeney has arguably outdone carmack in many ways.