News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I was wrong, reflecting on the .NET design choices by buzzybee on Friday April 21, 2017 @05:38PM (#14169627)
Garbage collection is troublesome for real-time processing(including game engines) because it doesn't allow you to plan around hitting a latency deadline. When the collector triggers, it consumes a lot of time, which can add up to missing a deadline even in very relaxed situations.

Historically, many game engines have a "never allocate" policy: Everything is done with static buffers and arenas of temporary data. The broad strokes of this policy are mostly achievable in a GC language that allows value type collections(fewer managed references = less to trace = cheaper garbage). The problem typically comes in little bits of algorithmic code that need their own allocation: Because the language is garbage collected, all your algorithms are using the GC by default. And if you want to reclaim it, you have to fight a very uphill battle.

IME, though, most of the problem is resolvable if you have enough introspection into GC configuration. If a game can tell the collector that it needs a cheap scratch buffer to process an update loop and then get thrown out, that covers a lot of the problem. The last bit of it is fine detail over memory size and alignment, which some GC languages do give you introspection into already.

Edit: Also, I should note that the relative value of GC changes a lot when your process is long-lived and unbounded in scale(servers) or involves a lot of "compiler-like" behaviors(transformations over a large, complex data graph). The advantage of doing without it in a game engine has a lot to do with the game being able to be tuned around simple processing of previously authored data, with limited bounds in all directions.

There are no comments on this comment yet.