News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Survivorship Bias by frgtpsswrdlame on Friday April 21, 2017 @01:59PM (#14167744)
I disagree and typed out a bit of a longer refutation but I'm honestly more interested in where our disagreement stems from, I think this question might answer that for me:

I'm sure that you know people who have high incomes/lots of wealth and who are smart & hardworking. Do you know any older "poor" people (yearly income bottom quintile <$21,000, second quintile < $41,000) who are the same?

Re:Survivorship Bias by ctdonath on Friday April 21, 2017 @05:36PM (#14169618)
Feel like I'm walking into a trap here.

Myself being near a half-century, I've watched the development of minimum wage, wage-limited welfare, and easy credit. As such, I have to observe that older people (of whatever income) have mostly lived their earlier low-wage years without those two institutionalized traps, managing to work up their income past that $12-36/hr (inflation adjusted) gap before it appeared, and acquired most of what they're going to acquire (non-consumables) with cash or have long paid off major debts. As such, they had more natural socioeconomic mobility, and regardless of income most retired into a scenario where income can be very low while maintaining a quite comfortable existence - ergo pegging them as bottom/second quintile can be quite misleading, as contrasted with the otherwise presumed "growing family" that does desperately need income & mobility.

To wit: those elderly I know who likely have such low incomes likely own their homes etc outright, know how to live well on a frugal income, avoided/eliminated debt, and are in a position to choose to cut their own income to maximize net revenue (extreme ex.: the "millionaire on food stamps" cases, rich but currently no earned income).