News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scalable, Lie-Detecting Timeserving with Roughtime by packetized on Friday April 21, 2017 @11:32AM (#14166434)
httpstime is interesting, but roughtime seems to have a few additional features:

* stateless operation (via UDP)

* no reliance on SSL/TLS or PKI

* ability to catch incorrect servers (assuming no collusion)

I think it's a very interesting take on time services, without being something quite as heavy as PTP/IEEE1588. The stated goals of fixing wildly incorrect clocks over ultraprecise timing [0], preventing clock-source tampering, and keeping largely in-line with the original design concepts of ntp (while solving a number of security shortcomings) seems to be targeted squarely at user devices, and much less so at service providers or operators that require precision timing for log stamping and the like.

Additionally, if you need a roughly-correct clock for validating HTTPS certificates, and you have to connect to an HTTPS server to update your time to be roughly correct, how do you trust the server? Sure, you can simply connect to something with a self-signed cert, but then you're putting the trust squarely back in the hands of that single server, without any method of verifiability. Turtles all the way down.

[0]: "The Roughtime creators state that 25% of Chrome’s certificate errors are caused by incorrect local clocks (off by days or more). A local clock within a few seconds of reference time is good enough."

Re:Scalable, Lie-Detecting Timeserving with Roughtime by int08h on Friday April 21, 2017 @11:46AM (#14166583)
I was typing up a response, but yours is great. You nailed it.

The only thing to add is that a tlsdate-like approach will not work consistently with TLS 1.3 as the standard makes time in the handshake OPTIONAL.

Re:Scalable, Lie-Detecting Timeserving with Roughtime by packetized on Friday April 21, 2017 @11:53AM (#14166638)
It's been a couple of years since I was really immersed in the operational aspects of NTP/PTP - glad to know I can still mostly follow along.

Nice theme on the blog.

Re:Scalable, Lie-Detecting Timeserving with Roughtime by int08h on Friday April 21, 2017 @11:58AM (#14166701)
Thank you.