Re:David Lynch’s Dune – A sci-fi film by a director without ...
by narag on Thursday April 20, 2017 @02:22PM
(#14159336)
the "everything has to be explained" crowd
Thank you for that expression.
I also watched the movie before... actually I still haven't read the books. I guess they must be superb and that's why readers are spoiled and dislike the movie.
The scene with the emperor and the navigator is best thing I've ever seen in sci-fi, both visually and for meaning.
Re:David Lynch’s Dune – A sci-fi film by a director without ...
by TheGrassyKnoll on Thursday April 20, 2017 @03:33PM
(#14160026)
> a CGI-clad sudoku
That might be kinda cool too...
This unexplainedness by the way also keeps the mind engaged without dropping into the game of trying to mentally map out every little detail as a plot explanation mechanism. This mode of watching besets me when I see a movie that caters to the "everything has to be explained" crowd, but it should be exclusive to the murder mystery genre. Attempts to transplant that into other types of movies tend to either be painfully obvious or pointlessly complicated, to avoid the former. And somehow, they often manage to be both at once. I want immersion, not a CGI-clad sudoku.