News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:David Lynch’s Dune – A sci-fi film by a director without ... by cafebabbe on Thursday April 20, 2017 @11:34AM (#14157584)
I'm not saying Dune is idiomatic Sci-fi ... but your definition fits almost perfectly Dune :)

> The stories often represent philosophical thought experiments presented in entertaining ways

Like acquired omniscience, for instance ? Or the idea of a galatical economy based on travel fuel ?

> Protagonists typically “think” rather than “shoot” their way out of problems,

About half of the story are analytical inner monologues...

> SF is putting characters into far psychological extremes and thought experiments.

Yeah well that's the TL;DR of the Atreides arc...

Re:David Lynch’s Dune – A sci-fi film by a director without ... by the_af on Thursday April 20, 2017 @01:20PM (#14158720)
Indeed. There is very little action in Dune. Almost all of it is politicking and inner monologues. Dune is definitely NOT a space opera like Star Wars.
Re:David Lynch’s Dune – A sci-fi film by a director without ... by Keyframe on Thursday April 20, 2017 @12:16PM (#14158048)
It's debatable, as I've said. It certainly can be viewed as an SF. However, main story vehicle is that of 'the chosen one' and of 'the legend / prophecy' which is usually main driving vehicle in fantasy. So, maybe an SF Fantasy? :) Matrix trilogy dwells into that space as well.

I love Lynch's Dune adaptation very much though.

Re:David Lynch’s Dune – A sci-fi film by a director without ... by fao_ on Thursday April 20, 2017 @08:52PM (#14162218)
The Lion of Commare follows "the chosen one" arc, yet nobody doubts that it is science fiction.