Re:The Seductive Appeal of the “Nazi Exception”
by krapp on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @06:24AM
(#14146724)
>Why on earth should we bother to entertain clearly bad ideas?
The problem is not entertaining the bad ideas, but failing to continue to defend the good ones, once the bad ideas have been forced out of the realm of public debate. You entertain bad ideas for the same reason the body entertains disease and inoculation - to build up and maintain immunity.
>If you're espousing white nationalism or transphobia or something, I don't want you speaking anywhere near anyone you might convince. End of story.
And guess what? While you feel safe and secure that white nationalists and transphobes can't speak openly, they'll not only continue to speak covertly, and continue to convince people of their beliefs, but will do so where you cannot see them and despite your refusal to publicly rebuke them. And the fact that the "system" denies them the freedom to express their beliefs only convinces them that those beliefs are true, and gives them a common bond and identity, and turns them into a culture.
We fought an entire war against Nazis and white supremacists - literally threw millions of bullets at them and burned their cities to the ground. It stopped the Nazi armies and the Nazi state, but the Nazi ideas came back after a few generations, if one can even say they ever left.
Society can't assume that subsequent generations will hold the axioms of the past to be true - they must be reproved, over and over.
The problem is not entertaining the bad ideas, but failing to continue to defend the good ones, once the bad ideas have been forced out of the realm of public debate. You entertain bad ideas for the same reason the body entertains disease and inoculation - to build up and maintain immunity.
>If you're espousing white nationalism or transphobia or something, I don't want you speaking anywhere near anyone you might convince. End of story.
And guess what? While you feel safe and secure that white nationalists and transphobes can't speak openly, they'll not only continue to speak covertly, and continue to convince people of their beliefs, but will do so where you cannot see them and despite your refusal to publicly rebuke them. And the fact that the "system" denies them the freedom to express their beliefs only convinces them that those beliefs are true, and gives them a common bond and identity, and turns them into a culture.
We fought an entire war against Nazis and white supremacists - literally threw millions of bullets at them and burned their cities to the ground. It stopped the Nazi armies and the Nazi state, but the Nazi ideas came back after a few generations, if one can even say they ever left.
Society can't assume that subsequent generations will hold the axioms of the past to be true - they must be reproved, over and over.