News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Drinking While Jurying by rblatz on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @01:28PM (#14140852)
It seems like a sensible line would be, not being under the influence while in court. Additionally not being hungover in court. If you are drinking or hungover you are unable to properly focus on your tasks as a juror.

Additionally limiting discussions of the case with other jurors while drinking seems like a good idea. The Ouija board seems highly inappropriate, since I believe jurors are instructed to not use outside research or experiences in rendering a verdict.

Outside of that these are adults, and the should not lose all agency because they've been picked to serve on a jury.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by gdubs on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:06PM (#14141269)
Why moralize though? I'd rather have a brilliant, fair-minded, functioning alcoholic on a jury than a teetotaling nincompoop.

Being on a substance isn't in and of itself a good marker of whether someone is capable of holding their position.

Arguably lack of sleep might be as bad or worse as being drunk. But culturally we don't moralize about the former.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by mikeash on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:08PM (#14141894)
It's really interesting to see which attributes we consider to be a failing. Being drunk is considered much worse than being tired even at a similar level of effect.

The one that I really love is how being unintelligent is often considered to be a failing, but only to a point. When someone does something stupid and there's a bad consequence, it's often met with "that's what they deserve, what an idiot!" But there's a sharp cutoff (officially at an IQ of 69 or below) where it ceases to be a moral failing and becomes a handicap worthy of sympathy.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by gdubs on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:40PM (#14142189)
Super insightful comment. We have an imperfect system, but what I think is good about it is that jurors are evaluated on their capacity to fairly and impartially decide a case. It sidesteps the need to base the qualification on metrics like IQ, or level of intoxication, etc, and places it in the hands of the lawyers and judges. Imperfect, and there are ways that lawyers exploit it, but IMHO it's ultimately more fair.
Re:Drinking While Jurying by jdietrich on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:16PM (#14141362)
>But culturally we don't moralize about the former.

That's starting to change. My country has nearly eliminated drink-driving, so driving while tired has become the big target. Medicine is starting to take the issue of sleep deprivation amongst practitioners seriously, with a lot of very frank discussions about the impacts of shift work and on-call rotas.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by hueving on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:35PM (#14141546)
There's a difference between moralizing and restricting a few particular tasks.
Re:Drinking While Jurying by tertius on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:14PM (#14141342)
Agreed about sleeping. That can be a major problem.

Addiction is a really psychological issue though.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by bdamm on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:18PM (#14141381)
PTSD is a psychological issue as well. So?
Re:Drinking While Jurying by pavel_lishin on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:10PM (#14141912)
There is a part of the jury selection process where you are asked if there is any reason you think you cannot serve, and you're welcome to speak freely. Of course, it's up to the judge (and to a certain degree, the lawyers) as to whether you'll be released from service.

I was up for jury duty recently, and one of the potential jury members flat out said that she couldn't be unbiased in the trial, since she'd been assaulted by a black man not too long before, and the defendant in the case was black as well. The judge released her back to the jury pool.

I would assume that stating that you have PTSD (and having documentation to that effect) and explaining how it would prevent you from being able to serve would be a pretty good reason to not serve. (No idea about claiming alcoholism, and I'd wager that most people wouldn't want to announce to fifty people that they have a drinking problem.)

Re:Drinking While Jurying by mbrookes on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:56PM (#14141769)
> The Ouija board seems highly inappropriate, since I believe jurors are instructed to not use outside research

Outside research? Do you genuinely believe they consulted the spirit world?

At most this this would surface their collective belief in the guilt of the accused. An unconventional means to arrive at a consensus, but no more outside research than each of them writing a verdict on a piece of paper.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by mikeash on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:09PM (#14141902)
A Ouija board wouldn't constitute outside research, but if they believed in it then it would mean they thought they were conducting outside research, which they were not supposed to do. How do you handle that?
Re:Drinking While Jurying by pavel_lishin on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:12PM (#14141936)
If I consulted what I believed to be a reputable website for information, not being aware that it contained nothing but plausible but randomly generated information, I think I would still be considered to be conducting outside research. I'd imagine that intent here matters.
Re:Drinking While Jurying by mikeash on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @04:22PM (#14142534)
Intent definitely matters, but I think there has to be the possibility of achieving your goal too. For example, if I cast a spell that's said to make your heart explode, I won't get done for attempted murder even though my intent was to kill you.
Re:Drinking While Jurying by hamandcheese on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:10PM (#14141917)
Suppose one juror in particular was influencing the Ouija board, and the rest actually believed they were communicating with the supernatural. That one juror now has an outsized impact on the trial, which is a problem.
Re:Drinking While Jurying by sqeaky on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:50PM (#14142266)
Clever people taking advantage of dumb people has always been a problem.
Re:Drinking While Jurying by mbrookes on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:55PM (#14141762)
> The Ouija board seems highly inappropriate, since I believe jurors are instructed to not use outside research

Outside research? Do you genuinely believe they consulted the the spirit world?

At most this this would surface their collective belief in the guilt of the accused. An unconventional means to arrive at a consensus, but no more outside research than each of them writing a verdict on a piece of paper.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by BearGoesChirp on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:58PM (#14141799)
The validity of the research method should not be taken into account. It doesn't matter if I ask my uncle Bob about the scientific details or if I go read some peer reviewed published paper. I'm not allowed to gain knowledge.

That being said, I still find it absurd that independent research from valid sources isn't allowed.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:05PM (#14141865)
> That being said, I still find it absurd that independent research from valid sources isn't allowed.

It's not allowed, among many reasons, because validity is a disputable fact, and outside research by jurors prevents the party that would be adversely affected by taking the source as valid from contesting the validity of the source in open court, defeating the entire purpose of having a public trial, a reviewable trial record, the right to counsel, and, well, the whole of legal process.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by BearGoesChirp on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @09:02AM (#14147375)
If the court provided a meaningful alternative I might accept this argument, but given some of the poor track records of expert witnesses, and given that people will bring in their own personal knowledge regardless of what is said. This is especially true since contesting validity of a source costs money and people don't have infinite money in court.

The only conclusion is that the current legal system is so broken that the only reasonable judgment is not guilty.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by takeda on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @05:30PM (#14143109)
Ouija boards can affect outcome, for example one person can influence what others will see and if they believe it suddenly that person's opinion will matter much more than it should.

Instead of having a pointless arguments whether Ouija board can talk to dead people (see other comments), much easier is to assume it does and apply existing rules to rule it out.

I think there is no doubt that it can affect outcome.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by occultist_throw on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:34PM (#14142129)
Well, there's 3 avenues to this.

1. Divination is real, and they are consulting whatever they called. Could be the victim. Could be someone/something else. Could be a deity. Long and short, unless you're practiced in this realm, you can't know. And there's no empirical proof.

2. It's a link to their subconscious. Nothing mysterious. But it's a way they can interrogate their own ideas about a situation without personally owning said ideas. Think of this akin to a couch and therapist.

3. Someone is playing with them and controlling a weak-willed person. In other words, they're choosing what's being divined in order to exert influence over someone else. This is not only a bad situation, it's likely illegal.

The tough part, is when divination is integral to someones' religion. What's to say that your reading verses with a bible is any less than me relying on the tarot? If you're allowed your religious expression, why not I? And speaking of such, isn't it common still to "swear to tell the truth, the only truth, so help you god"? My first question to that is, "Which God?"

1 would appear protected, 2 isn't, and 3 looks illegal. Hard call.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by sqeaky on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:57PM (#14142315)
> unless you're practiced in this realm, you can't know.

I disagree, because...

> there's no empirical proof.

We have been trying very hard for centuries to contact any kind of afterlife, spirits or gods, and failed. Even if we cannot perfectly rule it out in principal we can rule out anything we have conceived and tested thus far.

That and Ouija boards are made by Parker Bros [1]. Unless you believe that a group of people with a reliable channel to the afterlife chose to keep making Scrabble and Monopoly games with their super powers, then we really should just discount it as an obvious money grab, because it is.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Parker_Brothers_games

Re:Drinking While Jurying by occultist_throw on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @04:15PM (#14142473)
> We have been trying very hard for centuries to contact any kind of afterlife, spirits or gods, and failed.

I'd suppose you haven't tried spending time with people who do practice and do this, do you?

> Even if we cannot perfectly rule it out in principal we can rule out anything we have conceived and tested thus far.

Simply put, you can't. "Absence of proof" does not equal "proof of absence".

> That and Ouija boards are made by Parker Bros [1]. Unless you believe that a group of people with a reliable channel to the afterlife chose to keep making Scrabble and Monopoly games with their super powers, then we really should just discount it as an obvious money grab, because it is.

Not at all. The Ouigi boards are just a tool. There's usually nothing in them that would be manifest to a specific entity or emotion. Not even that, but they are made by machine, so there would be very likely no emotion in contact with them.

Since you seem unlearned in this area, divination can use any sort of tools. Tarot, pendulum, sand, tea, coffee grounds, bones, compass (luao-pen), ruler, entrails, fire, water.. Any of these can be learned and used. Or some are versed in doing divination using no instruments at all - although even in the occult and esoteric areas, this is considered very difficult.

And then it comes full circle with religion. These are religious practices. If you're thinking of Miss Cleo, you're further from the truth. Those are advertisement services ; whereas what I talk of are honestly held beliefs. And when understood from the occult mindset, do give valid answers.

It's one area where I work in regularly, is divination. Sometimes, it doesn't work. In that case, I say as such. Usually, it does.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by sqeaky on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @03:53PM (#14151143)
> honestly held beliefs

Honestly held beliefs can be wrong. In this case divination of the sorts you have described fly in the face of empirical testing. Please stop presuming my level of knowledge, I am fairly certain I have more than none in this regard and would not have commented otherwise.

> Usually, it does.

Then publish a paper and pick up your Nobel prize. Or start a business and guarantee results. Or do one of a million other things people do with technologies that work do and go be successful.

Except you can't because the ranks of fortune tellers, prophets, mystics and yogis is filled with charlatans. Some honest but wrong and some liars deceiving, but it doesn't matter both are wrong or their practices would have spread as far as success took other ideas like modern agriculture, engineering or math.

You simply cannot get knowledge without working for it. These "revealed" sources don't stand up to experimentation because they are quite literally made up, and experimentation is how we work for it.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by grkvlt on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @08:08PM (#14144283)
> Usually, it does

No, honestly, it doesn't.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by grkvlt on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @10:15AM (#14147841)
I should probably have said something about Confirmation Bias which I suspect is what is at work here. Note that you say the times it doesn't work, you dismiss as being due to circumstances beyond control; when it does seem to work, due to random chance, you seize on that as proof, confirming that there is a hidden occult mechanism at work. Even a really low success rate -- maybe only 5-10% of your guesses are correct -- is still enough to generate the illusion, particularly if you are able to dismiss the failures as unimportant, so the successes stick out more.
Re:Drinking While Jurying by occultist_throw on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @10:35AM (#14147967)
> I should probably have said something about Confirmation Bias which I suspect is what is at work here.

Indeed. I know well about the confirmation bias. I've considered it early on as a likely candidate. I've ruled it out by too many extremely improbable events, many which include other people unawares about anything that I do.

(In 'unrelated' computer science, do you consider a zero knowledge proof to be 0% likely even after 100 iterations? How many iterations would you need as proof?)

> Note that you say the times it doesn't work, you dismiss as being due to circumstances beyond control; when it does seem to work, due to random chance, you seize on that as proof, confirming that there is a hidden occult mechanism at work.

You misunderstand. I do not classify them as failures, because they are not. I can tell when a divination won't work. Call it a little message in the back of my mind. Something. Doesn't happen often.

> Even a really low success rate -- maybe only 5-10% of your guesses are correct -- is still enough to generate the illusion, particularly if you are able to dismiss the failures as unimportant, so the successes stick out more.

Id say much higher than that. But you've already dismissed this as some self-inflicted mental health issue. If you've read any of my meager posting history, you'd know that I'm trying to blend both this mysticism and science, and bring it so all may use and benefit.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by cmdrfred on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @10:40AM (#14148002)
How come there has never been a person with both supernatural abilities and a want for a million dollars?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One_Million_Dollar_Paranormal_...

Re:Drinking While Jurying by grkvlt on Friday April 28, 2017 @02:30AM (#14217278)
Oh, I find your comments interesting and well thought out, just wrong... But I do think you deserve better than just my glib throwaway dismissal, so I added the follow up comment to explain more/better.
Re:Drinking While Jurying by sqeaky on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @03:55PM (#14151169)
> I know well about the confirmation bias. I've considered it early on as a likely candidate. I've ruled it out by too many extremely improbable events, many which include other people unawares about anything that I do.

Document you processes and methods and let others duplicate them. If you have a process that works it could change the world.

Until you have something I can duplicate I will disregard it with active hostile because this kind of mental has killed too many.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by random_rr on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @08:04AM (#14147107)
Please do not clutter up this board with drivel.
Re:Drinking While Jurying by Sir_Cmpwn on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:58PM (#14141793)
It's probably easier to make the "outside research" argument to the kind of person who would consult an Ouija board than it is to convince them Ouija boards are bunk.
Re:Drinking While Jurying by chillindude829 on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @01:35PM (#14140935)
How would this work in practice though? Would jurors take a breathalyzer or something before entering the courtroom?
Re:Drinking While Jurying by ZanyProgrammer on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:00PM (#14141205)
The way it works in most workplaces, if someone is obviously visibly impaired or reeks of booze.
Re:Drinking While Jurying by rblatz on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @01:39PM (#14140986)
Potentially, or if someone is visibly unable to perform their duties as a juror the judge would stop proceedings, investigate the issue with the juror and then take whatever action they find appropriate.
Re:Drinking While Jurying by michaelt on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:32PM (#14141527)
Prior to deliberation, isn't a juror's main job to sit still in silence?
Re:Drinking While Jurying by edmccard on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:45PM (#14141648)
>Prior to deliberation, isn't a juror's main job to sit still in silence

I think they're also supposed to be paying attention to the proceedings.

Re:Drinking While Jurying by cardiffspaceman on Thursday April 20, 2017 @05:31PM (#14161118)
Jurors can comment on things like apparent misconduct, to the judge via the bailiff, or ask questions of the judge via the bailiff.
Re:Drinking While Jurying by zardo on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:46PM (#14141665)
Alcoholism can interfere with that job.