News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Safari 5 by ThomPete on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @07:38AM (#1413589)
Newspapers are dying because they are staffed to heavily, not because people don't pay.

Now look at smaller publications such as Gawker, hyper local news. They are doing just fine.

Wired sold almost as many iPad versions (75.000 at 5USD a pop) as they did paper version since they launched it. Thats excluding advertising.

Clearly there is a market for news. It's just not going to be of the NYT kind.

Re:Safari 5 by markkanof on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @08:58AM (#1413755)
Your comment makes it sound like gawker is some kind of lightweight, nimble organization that provides all the hard news that say the NYT or the Washington Post do but at a fraction of the cost. Gawker is a tabloid. While there are some entertaining stories it in no way replaces a more serious news organization.

I don't mean to be overly critical. I just think that society needs the kind of information that the large papers provide. They definitely are having trouble coming up with a new viable business model, but it doesn't seem prudent to dismiss them by holding up gawker as a model to emulate.

Re:Safari 5 by ThomPete on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @10:49AM (#1414060)
That was not intentional.

My point is simply that there are plenty of room for news it's just that the news organizations most probably need to focus much more as they can't maintain the overhead of covering more and more at the pace news are moving today.

It's not a natural law that newspapers have to cover both local, domestic and international news. This did make sense when the news industry was very different, but insisting that reality somehow seem to conform to their needs is in my opinion absurd (I am not saying you said that)

In my opinion news are fundamentally gossip, until it's verified, written up and if it's found important analyzed further.

The access to the actual news (plane went down in Hudson) is almost ever present which means that you don't have to staff up around the world just to be sure to catch what is going on.

There are so many areas that newspapers still seem to insist on keeping that it makes it impossible for them to get lean enough to make proper profit. And let's not forget that so many much smaller news sites are eating into their profit.

I like you enjoy well written articles, geopolitics and in depth analysis, but we are not the norm.

To most people what is going on around the corner is more important than what's going on in Iraq or Philadelphia.

That doesn't mean there isn't room for serious journalism. Just that it has to change it's scope.

Just my five cents of course.

Re:Safari 5 by dhotson on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @08:27AM (#1413677)
Yeah, good journalism costs money.

To have a staff of correspondents reporting around the world isn't cheap. But I think it's worth it.

I think in order for newspapers to survive, people have to learn that they need to pay. Advertising alone isn't going to pay the bills.

I personally think that charging people money for things on the internet isn't such a crazy idea. ;-)

Re:Safari 5 by ThomPete on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @08:58AM (#1413754)
I don't think it's good journalism that cost money but the infrastructure to maintain so many journalists being situated around the world. The question is if this is really necessary. My guess is more and more, no it isn't

Obviously you don't really need a journalist for every newspaper being situated in different parts of the world. I understand why they do it, but the problem is that they are often forced to compete with local citizens with cellphones, twitter, citizen journalism etc.

Most people don't really read news for the good journalism, they read it for the value of reading news.

How well this news is being written is in my mind secondary from that point of view.

But obviously it's not so simple. I just don't buy the argument about good journalism.

Re:Safari 5 by dhotson on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @09:27AM (#1413816)
I agree that twitter and citizen journalism have shown themselves to be quite capable of disseminating information and news.

It's still not quite the same as reading a well written, unbiased, in-depth analysis of a story in The Economist or The New York Times (or even Al Jazeera).

Sure, there's a large market for "news-tainment". But I think there's also a market for high quality journalism.

I'm also tipping that people are more likely to pay (and pay more) for the latter too.

Re:Safari 5 by ThomPete on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @09:33AM (#1413837)
I too love well written articles. But it is unlikely a big enough market to entertain that many newspapers.

I do however have quibbles with the idea of unbiased journalism.

Personally I prefer highly opinionated pieces, but that's another discussion :)

Re:Safari 5 by dhotson on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @09:42AM (#1413862)
I think you would be surprised. :-)

You're right about unbiased news though. It's a myth.

You really need to make up your own mind and read various sources to get some balance. I'm pretty sure all news has some inherent bias.

Opinion is fine, but don't try to make out like it's real news. Techcrunch is a major offender here.

Re:Safari 5 by chc on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @12:57PM (#1414499)
This is a distressingly common sentiment these days. I can't think of any good reason to prefer opinionated screeds to well-balanced factual analysis. Very often it boils down to "I don't have confidence in news stories to have a 100% optimal distribution and analysis of the facts, so I've decided it's not even worth pursuing the truth."
Re:Safari 5 by ThomPete on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @02:14PM (#1414723)
Opinionated does not mean that it's not balanced or factual.

Everything is at the end of the day interpretation. I would rather know what peoples stance are whether I agree or disagree than to read something that is stated as the truth.

Re:Safari 5 by chc on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @03:19PM (#1414927)
Something opinionated is by definition not balanced (in the sense of giving everything an equal shake) or factual. "Fact" and "opinion" are antonyms. And I can't imagine what it would look like for an article to be opinionated but not explicitly favor any particular view over another.

Are we using different definitions here or do you genuinely believe somebody arguing that Steve Jobs is a worthless sonovabitch is being evenhanded?

Re:Safari 5 by ThomPete on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @04:30PM (#1415121)
We are perhaps using different definitions.
Re:Safari 5 by jimbokun on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @08:20PM (#1415701)
"I think in order for newspapers to survive, people have to learn that they need to pay."

The Wall Street Journal and the Economist successfully taught their readers this lesson.

Re:Safari 5 by ahk on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @11:05AM (#1414113)
How many news organizations have good journalists though? I can count the ones I like on my fingers and some of them are mostly just bloggers as well. The market can support a few organizations doing international stuff, most of the rest just need reprint permissions.

The field is moving to much more federated-ness very quickly. People will not pay. Newspapers will not survive. Sorry.