News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by bogomipz on Monday April 17, 2017 @12:41PM (#14132307)
I had question about the following statement:

>"With the hub-and-spoke system used to defend airlines’ pricing power, there are fewer nonstops"

I hadn't considered the hub and spoke system as a means of defending pricing power before. Is the idea that since there are more flights by that airline into its hub region they can offer better fares to passengers? Is that right? But don't passengers generally try to avoid flights with lay overs? The logic is escaping me.

Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by bluGill on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:55PM (#14132976)
Let me give you an example that will make the problem clear: I live in Des Moines. I have family in El Paso. A regular daily flight from Des Moines to El Paso would average about 2 passengers each flight - but some days the plane would be empty, others it would have 5. Depending of course on when various people/families in either city decides to visit the other.

With the hub and spoke model instead they fly 60 people from Des Moines to a hub, and then 4 transfer to the plane to El Paso, 2 to the flight to (pick a random tiny city). On the return trip they collect all those people again.

Of course if you live in New York city this doesn't matter to you: New York is large enough to have a direct flight to nearly every small city, and could fill them even without being a hub (though as a hub they can fill larger, more efficient planes). To those of us to live in tiny cities we cannot get to other tiny cities because the flights just don't exist. The downside is we pay about twice as much for our tickets as we are paying for two tickets, but we can still get there.

Any time an airline notices a lot of people trying to get from one city to another they will add direct flights. Computers are good at figuring out where the demand is and airlines know a nearly full direct flight will capture the a lot of tickets that otherwise might go to competition. Big vacation destinations thus do not have to be a hub to get regular direct flights.

Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by lhopki01 on Monday April 17, 2017 @04:33PM (#14134173)
I'm not sure this argument holds up. Ryanair in the EU flys so many point to point flights from little airports to other little airports. Why does the point to point model work so well within the EU but not in the US? Ryanair has actually said that they don't really do market research for routes but rely on the fact that opening up the route increases demand.
Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by niftich on Monday April 17, 2017 @04:42PM (#14134247)
Europe tends to have public transport and long-distance car hire services that make an outlying airport capable of being used to visit a "nearby" much larger city. In the US, outlying airports are those of third- and fourth-tier cities that don't generate a lot of traffic on their own, and are located distant from points of interest. In the US, a tourist flying to such a place has little options besides renting a personal car.

In the past, I've hypothesized [1] that the sole reason low-cost airlines like RyanAir can even fly to such outlying European airports is because there's significant competition among lesser airports desperate for business and the (supposed) positive knock-on effects that will result. This encourages them to provide subsidies, discounts, or other perks to airlines, because losing commercial air service would be a more severe economic blow.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13438412

Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by lhopki01 on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:38AM (#14137075)
But if you're travelling via the hub and spoke model you still need to rent at the other end.

The US is not adverse to subsidising and providing large tax discounts to companies, if anything this is much more common in the US than the EU because of state aid rules in the EU. Why wouldn't US regional airports also try and attract more airlines?

I've done some research and apparently LCCs now make up 30% of travel in the US. It looks like the US is catching up to the EU now.

Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by Bagger288 on Monday April 17, 2017 @12:57PM (#14132472)
It's about supply and demand and fuel efficency. A small airport between Albany and NYC won't have enough people to fill a plane capable of flying to LAX efficiently from a fuel perspective, so they'll take a flight to NYC first then the LAX on a bigger plane that can spend less per person per mile to get there. Larger planes tend to be more fuel efficient (assuming all seats filled) than smaller ones which is why hub and spoke model makes a lot of sense. The 787 is actually abnormally fuel efficient for its size and it's opening up many direct routes that were previously not economical since it's a smaller plane that costs the same per mile per person as much larger planes.
Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by gusgordon on Monday April 17, 2017 @03:11PM (#14133594)
Larger planes aren't significantly more fuel efficient. Look at the A380 vs. the 787.

The reason airlines thought hub and spoke was more profitable was because they could basically guarantee that every flight would be full. If a flight is only half full, you're lugging an entire airplane around for no reason which is very costly.

Hub and spoke is worse than airlines thought, though — newer planes like the 787 are far more efficient, so that cost of lugging the airplane around is reduced.

Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by tarlinian on Monday April 17, 2017 @04:45PM (#14134273)
The 787 and A380 are both immense planes compared to 90% of the domestic fleet. You can count the number of domestic routes that can support widebody aircraft (787/777/A33/A350/A380) on one hand. And they are significantly more fuel efficient per passenger mile than a 737/A320 which are in turn quite a bit more fuel efficient per passenger mile than a regional jet (United Express/American Eagle, etc.)
Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by bogomipz on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:13PM (#14132607)
Sure I understand about the logistical concerns and population densities but how do these spokes allow them to "defend their pricing power"?

Is it simply that that they can charge customers in those small secondary markets a premium on fares into the hub areas? Is that the pricing leverage?

Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by Bagger288 on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:27PM (#14132746)
They can lessen competition by not building a big hub in an airport that that's already a hub for a competing airline. If they avoid stepping on each others toes with hubs there are less airlines to compete on price with. If Minneapolis is a hub for Delta, then they have a virtual monopoly for all the smaller airports in the area that need to first fly to Minneapolis before the final destination.
Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by bogomipz on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:53PM (#14132959)
Right, OK so the industry collectively defends their pricing power by tacitly accepting these rules. That makes sense.

That being said when you look at the locations of some of these hubs they are in pretty undesirable places in terms of incurring flight delays due to weather - Chicago? San Francisco? Minneapolis, Denver, New York?

Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by bluGill on Monday April 17, 2017 @02:15PM (#14133139)
A hub will always be in a fairly large city: a hub city has a lot of non-stop flights to all over. Not only does the hub capture the small cities nearby, it also captures most of the traffic to other small cities far away from the large city.

Chicago [same for New York] is large enough that it will be a hub: enough people want to get from Chicago to every other city that if you don't offer the direct flight someone else will. From there people will figure out you can get from Chicago to anywhere they will will make it a hub despite your wishes.

The other part is historical. Minneapolis was a hub for Northwest Orient Airlines because it started in Minneapolis and thus made that their home hub. Delta eventually bought Northwest and got the hub with the deal. They decided to keep Minneapolis as a hub.

I don't know what the situation is with San Francisco. I suspect historically planes needed to stop there for fuel before crossing the ocean. That is just a guess though.

Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by bogomipz on Monday April 17, 2017 @02:43PM (#14133325)
Sure, hubs are a window into air travel history in the U.S. And with consolidation comes these hubs that have a historical reason for being there. And while I certainly understand that the New Yorks and Chicagos will always need to be hubs I have trouble with airlines exposing travelers in New York or Chicago to the vagaries of weather in Denver or Minneapolis. It seems these airlines could move some of these "historical hubs" into places with more favorable weather conditions.

I am not trying to slight Denver or Minneapolis in any why I'm just using them as an example. It just seem that a strategic rebalancing of hub locations might make help with delays and rescheduling. The situation now seems to be the airline inherited the hub through consolidation and that's where it will stay because they're too cheap to move it.

Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by bluGill on Monday April 17, 2017 @04:27PM (#14134129)
it isn't just cheapness. Minneapolis has built a large airport. If delta threatens to move out Minneapolis will sell those extra gates Delta is no longer using to someone else who wants to start a hub. In the mean time where ever Delta relocates too needs to builds a lot of gates and probably runways - even though the city ultimately wants to be a hub I'm not sure the city is willing to pay for all that.
Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by bogomipz on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:28PM (#14134568)
No and I completely understand agree with you. If you look at the amount of fees and insane amount taxes US citizen pay on airfares though it seems quite reasonable that the Federal government might might use some of that for improving air travel by building smarter hubs in more strategic places.
Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by bluGill on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @10:56AM (#14139306)
I just remembered another consideration: The geographical center of North America is in North Dakota. Minneapolis is the closest large airport. As such it on average uses the least fuel to use Minneapolis as a hub.

Though why Fargo isn't a hub by this logic I don't know. Also a population weighted geographic center is probably a better consideration than just pure geographic.

Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by xapata on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:56PM (#14132986)
Yes and no. Sometimes a flight going out of one of those tiny airports and continuing from the hub is paradoxically cheaper than taking the same flight from the hub. A friend of mine will occasionally drive from Atlanta to South Carolina to save a few hundred dollars on a flight leaving Atlanta.

It's more that airports are only so big. It's expensive to build a new terminal, so if one airline takes over most of an airport, the others can't turn it into a hub. If you don't mind a layover, that's not a big deal. If you want nonstop from your nearest airport, the airline that made it a hub will be able to charge you more. But that's only fair, because they invested the capital in making that airport a hub. If they over-invested, that's a lot of capital lost.

Re:How the Airlines Became Cartels by kevin_thibedeau on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:23PM (#14132717)
It can be hard to get nonstop flights out of Newark if United doesn't want to bother providing the service. The rest of the airlines there all want you to go through their hubs first. Not exactly a small potatoes airport.