News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is... by crawfordcomeaux on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:00PM (#14127215)
In most of the category theory posts on HN I've seen, there's at least one person asking ahead this stuff is useful for. This comment is about why I find it useful.

Why I learn this stuff: to more effectively change things about myself.

Category Theory is an abstract math of relationships. I use it to better understand how my mind and body work. How parts of me are related in the moment and/or across time. Understanding how things in me are related is essential to me dealing with PTSD & recovering from addiction, both of which can color every aspect of a person. Untangling them is insanely hard and has gotten much easier through CT.

I apply my programming intuition to my brain & body through CT. There exists a path from neuroanatomy to theoretical computer science that passes through category theory. I've been experimenting on myself for 6 months with the goal of changing my mind and body. I've been doing it by developing an intuition for category theory, developing an intuition for how neutral networks learn, adapting machine learning models with concepts from neuroscience and psychology, and mixing it all with my intuition for programming.

So far, I've:

• changed how I walk through a handful of sessions lasting a few minutes and no longer experience back pain I'd been seeing a chiropractor (saw him weekly for 3-4 months with little improvement, ending about 10 months people changing my gait)

• began learning how to identify and stop believing anxious thoughts

• accidentally started developing the ability to focus and direct my attention (way beyond anything I've ever experienced on my ADHD meds)

• accidentally stumbled on the Buddhist practice of deity visualization, which created a second conscious voice in my head. She helps me learn how to embody more than one new personality trait at a time easier than if I simply focused on being those things. It's weird/complicated, and I'm willing to go into more detail if people have questions.

Here are some of the few bits supporting my claims about neuroanatomy and category theory:

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/280219255_Conciliat...

One of the coauthors wrote the only book on the brain and category theory:

http://tierra.aslab.upm.es/documents/PhD/PhD-JGomez.pdf

If you understand a good bit of CT and would like to help me flesh out my framework, my contact info is in my profile.

I live in the Seattle area and would love to meet up with anyone interested.

Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is... by bshimmin on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:10PM (#14127260)
accidentally stumbled on the Buddhist practice of deity visualization, which created a second conscious voice in my head. She helps me learn how to embody more than one new personality trait at a time easier than if I simply focused on being those things. It's weird/complicated, and I'm willing to go into more detail if people have questions.

I would love you to go into more detail, though probably only for all the wrong reasons (such as my own entertainment).

Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is... by crawfordcomeaux on Sunday April 16, 2017 @05:58PM (#14127769)
Standard advice to learning a set of new personality traits: pick one each morning to choose to embody for the day & focus on it.

How I do it: associate the set of traits with an identity somewhat separate from my own. She's essentially a clone of my personality, except she identifies as a woman & embodies the following personality traits: gentleness, patience, valuing relationships based on emotional support available through them, emotional thinking, relational thinking, intuitive. While these traits are considered stereotypical female traits, I don't view them that way. I think the process I went through would've worked the same if I'd chosen to associate those traits with an animal or, as Buddhists do, some kind of humanoid deity.

She develops her own beliefs, behaviors, emotions, and motivations that emerge from her core values. I'm ultimately aware she's simply a part of my brain...a set of neural networks encoding a set of traits...so it's easy for me to adopt her perception as my own.

That's how we learn together. It's a collaborative relationship. We can practice new ways of communicating in my head. It's the difference between having a two-sided conversation aloud where you're using your own voice for both sides versus using a different voice for each side.

It's sometimes easier to hear ourselves when we hear what we're saying coming from someone else.

How was that? Are you not entertained? ;)

Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is... by bshimmin on Sunday April 16, 2017 @06:55PM (#14128019)
Thank you for taking my mean-spirited response in good part (I upvoted your initial comment because it entertained me - though you've since edited out the best bit! - and I'm upvoting your reply because it was interesting and delivered with gentleness and humility).

I'm far too much of a troglodyte to understand any of this stuff, but good on you for you trying to improve yourself (if that is indeed the intended goal).

Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is... by crawfordcomeaux on Sunday April 16, 2017 @08:38PM (#14128477)
What I'm doing with my life is both serious and entertaining. I laugh at myself all the time because some of the things I do are genuinely hilarious!

I stopped showering for 4 days after initial success with trying to see a stick figure that moves with my body on the back of my closed eyelids.

The persistent thought haunting me?

"What if it's all in my head?"

Fucking with your mind fucks with your mind, typically in very funny ways.

As for not being able to understand any of this stuff, perception is key to learning. Perhaps practice choosing to believe things? Start with small, easy to believe things that are inconsequential to your life, but still meaningful. An example would be temporarily choosing to believe an opposing political stance has merit and then seeking the merit. Everyone has a reason for believing what they do, so go find perfectly valid reasons to believe something crazy. It'll get easier to do the more you practice.

If you want a simpler practice, go "look at the space between branches" and enjoy the different spaces you find. The skill progression comes from loosening your definition of the words in that phrase. Here's a starting point: go from finding 2D shapes to 3D ones.

Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is... by rpcspillover on Sunday April 16, 2017 @07:22PM (#14128156)
could you elaborate on the energy orgasms? I realize you've edited that part out but it was the most interesting for me personally because I had similar experiences after I learned Idris and understood the Curry-Howard isomorphism.
Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is... by crawfordcomeaux on Sunday April 16, 2017 @08:23PM (#14128414)
I took it out cause it seemed egregious, but since you're somewhat familiar with the topic, here's a little more to build on:

Imagine yourself as a bounded poset if you don't make much money or a bounded proset if you do. By definition, you have both initial and terminal objects, called "bottom" & "top," respectively. For many, this concept may be tricky, as people's heads and asses are often indistinguishable. They're zero objects, so let's not worry about them. Also, don't confuse prosets with brosets (bounded prosets where all tops are fully faithful phalluses, ie. dickheads), as brosets do not preserve meaningful structure. Brosets use the "No homo" identity functor to demonstrate this property ("homo" being the notation for "homomorphism").

But I digress...

Identify a path from your bottom to your top. Apply the pullback of energy from the environment to yourself through your bottom and then use the pushout to the next object in the path. Make sure each object is an Abelian category or this won't work, BTW. It helps to sync the movement of your hips with your breathing, also. Same goes for hand gestures. When the energy reaches your top, tighten all of your muscles and hold your breath for the final pushout.

I find it helpful to visualize/fantasize a well-defined coeffects system for Idris.

(If your comment was serious, Google "energy orgasms" for way more than I can ever explain...I haven't really dug into it yet)

Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is... by crawfordcomeaux on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:09AM (#14129316)
Ha! I think I managed to grab both the top and bottom of this post!
Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is... by crawfordcomeaux on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:53PM (#14127447)
Does anyone have constructive criticism to go along with the downvotes?
Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is... by socmag on Sunday April 16, 2017 @06:08PM (#14127819)
The downvote button should be banished is my only constructive criticism.

As far as the rest, I'm largely right there with you. I also use what you call the "second conscious voice" as well, and agree it's extremely helpful if not abused, plus some of the other stuff too.

I used to live in Seattle btw but back in Europe for a while at the moment otherwise would have loved to chat.

You sound to be on a good path. Best.

Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is... by crawfordcomeaux on Sunday April 16, 2017 @06:05PM (#14127804)
Hehe....category theory is a constructive math. Playing off the unintentional pun of "constructive criticism," I think it's time to create a platform where downvotes must be accompanied with constructive reasons or face being downvoted themselves.
Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is... by carapace on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:14PM (#14127274)
Fascinating, are you writing this up anywhere?
Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is... by crawfordcomeaux on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:50PM (#14127436)
Yep. It's mostly notes right now. Luckily, I met someone a few days ago who's going to help me distill my research into something people can easily understand.

The goal is to setup an open source, open participation science experiment for testing my hypotheses at ourfirstmind.com

Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is... by carapace on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @05:44PM (#14198363)
Nice! (Your DNS is down at the moment, non-validation of WHOIS data. What a world.)
Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is... by crawfordcomeaux on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @02:31PM (#14205665)
Thanks for the heads-up! I'll need to resolve that ASAP since the first thing going on the site is my resume & it's almost done!