Burned discs rarely last longer than 5 years, a decade max.
Variables include the quality of manufacturing, and storage environment.
There are some other technologies that seem like they'll last a long time (MDISC), but I'm not really sure if they're worth their cost... or if I should just go for a Hard Drive at that point.
Blow the controll board in some way and your sunk. Blow the mechanics and your sunk.
with optical media at least you have this passive disc that just sits there.
Not to rain on your parade, but there are several data recovery and forensics services that will pull the data off of such disks.
If you have a clean room, you can even do it yourself: all you need is an identical model drive, and to just transfer the physical platters from the broken disk, to the good disk. Think of it like swapping the engine in a car instead of buying a new car.
Of course, with the new Helium-filled hard drives coming out these days, that's going to be a lot tougher ...
All information storage media degrade over time, it ultimately comes down to differences in durability. Stone tablets outlast SSDs, but for both, the clock is ticking.
As long as it is easier to send the data round trip to a datacentre in Kansas and back than it is to send it within my own lan, physical media will always be "a thing of the present"
Seriously, though, if the computers are (or can be) on the same network, then there are dozens of ways to achieve this. The easiest is probably shared network directories, but there's also NFS, rsync, scp, FTP, etc. IF the machines are on different networks it can be a little more work, but still not hard.
If the laptop and desktop are connected to a network, then there's no reason to use physical media, in fact the medium can only be an additional failure mode. Try this instead:
$ rsync -av (source path) (destination machine name):(destination path)
On your LAN, use Zeroconf (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-configuration_networking) to resolve local machine names to IPs.
> As long as it is easier to send the data round trip to a datacentre in Kansas and back than it is to send it within my own lan ...
Yes, but the premise isn't correct, and it only adds to the list of possible failure modes.
Run sshd on your desktop (assuming your behind a NAT there are nearly 0 security issues with this), when you want to transfer files
`rsync username@desktops_ip:remote_file local_file`.
Alternatively use something like syncthing.
I recently copied 2TB from one hard drive to another on the same computer and it took half a day. Trying to rsync that amount of data over the internet would take far longer than FedEx-ing a hard drive.
Even locally, it can be faster to copy data to a thumb drive, move it to the other machine, and copy it back than to send it over the network.
4x1Gib/s or 10Gib/s are more and more popular and in general local network latency is lower than HDD latency (surprising, isn't it).
Sending over 1Gib/s network will be for sure faster than copying it on flash drive. Even if flash drive is able to do 128MiB/s speed, you have to first write it, swap machine, read it. Via network you do the write and read at the same time.
With the advent of type-C USB, I expect things will become even simpler as long as at least one of the devices can expose itself as a mass-storage or MTP device.
s/is/are/
If I expressed a preference for blondes over brunettes, would you describe that as wrong also?
Obviously thinking of "physical media" as a plural is a matter of opinion, as well as being consistent with widespread usage.
If I say there are an infinity of primes, I've stated a fact, and one would be free to label it right or wrong. If instead I try to produce a concise, general definition of infinity, the result can only ever be an opinion, a judgment call. No one would have the right to call it wrong -- because it's language, not mathematics.
> Physical media here is a collective noun ...
The singular form is "physical medium." The plural form is "physical media." This is not rocket science.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Media_(communication)
Quote: "Media (the singular form of which is medium)[1] is the collective communication outlets or tools that are used to store and deliver information or data."
Again, it's language, not mathematics -- it's a matter of opinion and judgment.