Re:Bonchat - client-side encrypted web chat for the truly pa...
by nickbw on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @03:28AM
(#1416442)
Thank you for the insightful comments, and for taking the time to read the code! I really appreciate it.
I've added a pseudo-random component to the nonce, and a MAC to the messages.
I certainly agree that you can't rely on code from untrusted servers, but I think doing the encryption in the client with code that is publicly viewable, even if it can be compromised at any time by a malicious server, is the best we can do for web apps unless/until major browser vendors incorporate client-to-client encryption. Right now there is no reliable protection against a compromised server, but I would like to at least see web apps strive to be more accountable.
You are incorrect on your statement that the corrupted server needs both the plain and encrypted versions of a message to send bogus messages. Without authentication, the server can flip arbitrary bits of a CTR message. This opens up several types of attacks. You should apply a MAC to the ciphertext.
I think that the encryption needs to happen entirely in the client and you can't rely on code downloaded from an untrusted server.