News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pre-WWI Britain harbored many of the preconditions for fa... by tptacek on Saturday April 15, 2017 @12:35PM (#14121468)
Attempts to affiliate fascism with the far-left and the far-right are among the oldest tricks in the rhetorical book. Better to see fascism as what it is, sui generis: militant, centralized, starkly authoritarian governments animated by populist nationalism.

Since most of what defines fascism are points along a different axis than the distributive effects of an economy, I think it's a good idea to be suspicious of people who attempt to use fascism as an argument about economic systems.

Re:Pre-WWI Britain harbored many of the preconditions for fa... by flexie on Saturday April 15, 2017 @12:59PM (#14121592)
Communist societies had less redistribution than many modern social democratic countries and even less than the US. They distributed to the party elite, sure, and kept everybody else poor.

Forget about ideological differences. Talk is cheap. Instead look at how the societies actually played out: almost the same way.

Your list of what defines fascism describes communism as well, except maybe for nationalism. And I am not even sure about that.

Re:Pre-WWI Britain harbored many of the preconditions for fa... by tptacek on Saturday April 15, 2017 @01:01PM (#14121600)
Authoritarian nationalist governments are a feature of every culture and every economic system. "Fascism" isn't ever going to be a kill-shot in an argument about "communism" versus "capitalism".
Re:Pre-WWI Britain harbored many of the preconditions for fa... by ue_ on Saturday April 15, 2017 @01:38PM (#14121773)
>Communist societies had less redistribution than many modern social democratic countries and even less than the US.

These were not Communist societies. Arguably the existing Communist societies were those in the form of primitive Communism, existing very long ago. You seem to be taking issue with certain ideas of implementation rather than the ideal itself - that is, a stateless and moneyless society without classes.

What similarities do you think exist between the ideals of fascism and Communism?

Re:Pre-WWI Britain harbored many of the preconditions for fa... by ue_ on Saturday April 15, 2017 @01:42PM (#14121792)
>militant, centralized, starkly authoritarian governments animated by populist nationalism.

Communism may be militant or pacifistic, i.e via reformism, gradualism or via violent revolution.

Communism is stateless, all powers of the government being transferred to the people.

Nationalism is impossible with Communism, as Communism is the recognition of a global market of the bourgeoisie, which requires workers of the world to unite against it.

Communism is not centralised, at least not necessarily. Distributed economic planning and indeed no economic planning at all are possible varieties.