News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's HTML5 'standards' hype debunked by cpg on Monday June 07, 2010 @01:52PM (#1411184)
Do you know how accurate this article is, technically and otherwise?

I wonder how much of this article is actually just bashing or has merit as Apple trying to push something "open" with clear self-interest thinly veiled?

Re:Apple's HTML5 'standards' hype debunked by ROFISH on Monday June 07, 2010 @03:18PM (#1411498)
I don't see how Apple could get more "open" than what they're doing with Webkit and their HTML5 implementation. Let's take an example: CSS Animation. They have:

* Made an official spec for a CSS3 addition, labeled CSS Animation.

* Submitted the spec to be included in the overall HTML5/CSS3 document.

* Wrote a reference renderer in Webkit that properly uses a vendor tag for non-standard CSS elements (as per the CSS spec).

* Open-sourced it in Webkit.

I don't know how more "open" you can get with Apple's HTML5. Somebody has to create the bleeding edge in order to get there. How do you think CSS3 supports the features that it does now like border-radius or RGBA? Somebody made it and submitted it.

Just because Apple forces you download Safari for (presently) Safari only demos doesn't mean it's any less open. I know that Firefox is slowing working towards adding all the cool features. For example, the 3.7 alpha supports CSS transitions (the precursor to animations).

Re:Apple's HTML5 'standards' hype debunked by bradhe on Monday June 07, 2010 @06:42PM (#1412247)
> Somebody has to create the bleeding edge in order to get there.

That's not how the rules of Internet Land work, friend.

Re:Apple's HTML5 'standards' hype debunked by CoryMathews on Monday June 07, 2010 @04:05PM (#1411707)
Just because Apple forces you download Safari for (presently) Safari only demos doesn't mean it's any less open.

Yes it does. Those demos partially worked in Chrome and Opera yet they did not allow those browsers. The should have allowed you to view them in other browsers and stated that safari is the only one to 100% properly display them. Although they also should have included the -moz and -o prefixes. Till then its not open. Its a closed implementation.

Re:Apple's HTML5 'standards' hype debunked by tptacek on Monday June 07, 2010 @02:04PM (#1411232)
How is self-interest even relevant here? HTML5, even if it's being promoted in an Apple-biased way, is still far better for the industry than Flash is. The Reg can gripe all it wants, but the point of the Apple showcase is that 90% of what Flash is used for is being obsoleted, and Apple is 100% right about that.
Re:Apple's HTML5 'standards' hype debunked by papachito on Monday June 07, 2010 @03:15PM (#1411490)
Re:Apple's HTML5 'standards' hype debunked by ROFISH on Monday June 07, 2010 @03:25PM (#1411534)
HTML5 is a moving target that's changing everyday. Until the spec is 100% completed, finalized, and sealed, there's never going to be interoperability.

And interoperability is only one goal of HTML5. The other goal, in my opinion, is shiny features like Canvas, CSS Animation, and 3D Transforms. And Apple is doing quite well at those.

Re:Apple's HTML5 'standards' hype debunked by tptacek on Monday June 07, 2010 @03:29PM (#1411553)
We get it. HTML5 was an inaccurate label to apply to the techniques Apple used in the showcase. But what's your point? What is Apple demonstrating here that isn't a valid example of how HTML is going to displace Flash? HTML5 is going to do video as well as Flash. HTML5 is going to do type and layout better than Flash.
Re:Apple's HTML5 'standards' hype debunked by not_an_alien on Monday June 07, 2010 @02:22PM (#1411283)
So your point is that lying is OK as long as it goes on par with your agenda?
Re:Apple's HTML5 'standards' hype debunked by tptacek on Monday June 07, 2010 @02:27PM (#1411302)
No, that wasn't my point.