Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name...
by jsjohnst on Thursday April 13, 2017 @03:11AM
(#14104793)
Eridius answered the first part, so I'll tackle the second part. What you should do depends on many factors. First and foremost, is the access you are doing strictly forbidden? You'd be surprised how often it's not. Next you'd need to assess the intent of the access. Is it for a legitimate fair use reason (even if forbidden, aka it's a judgment call if you feel you could legitimately make a case it shouldn't be forbidden)? Ultimately the above two don't matter, it all comes down to a decision of "is keeping your job" more important than "doing what is ethical/legal/whatever"?
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name...
by eridius on Thursday April 13, 2017 @03:09AM
(#14104779)
If you're using a competitor's API in a way the API was intended to be used, it's probably OK, even if your motivation is to gain intelligence. But when you're breaking the ToS or otherwise doing things it wasn't intended to do, that's a problem.
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name...
by sillysaurus3 on Thursday April 13, 2017 @03:14AM
(#14104809)
Hmm, I see. Is it possible to think of a single example where you could use a competitor's API in a way they intend, but also at a scale large enough to be useful from an intelligence perspective?
If there isn't one, it seems like the argument again reduces down to "It's never okay for a competitor to use an API," which could be problematic.
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name...
by jsjohnst on Thursday April 13, 2017 @03:17AM
(#14104822)
IANAL, but using Lyft's API to see pricing and availability (to model your pricing and/or where drivers are in abundance) seems at minimum in a grey area. Using it to de-anonymize drivers and try to poach them, feels like crossing the line to me.
Assuming it's unethical, if you were asked at your company to build a script that accesses a competitor's API, what should you do?
Isn't it difficult to claim in general that collecting data using a competitor's services is inherently unethical?