News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by stass on Thursday April 13, 2017 @02:58AM (#14104740)
What's unethical about this? They were doing market research. It's not much different from stalking your competitor on google and going after the users they advertise to.
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by DrJokepu on Thursday April 13, 2017 @03:37AM (#14104919)
Intentionally accessing a protected computer system without authorization and obtaining information from it is a federal criminal offense (18 USC 1030 (a)(2)(C)).
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by nikcub on Thursday April 13, 2017 @05:37AM (#14105430)
The part of CFAA that classified breaking a EULA or Terms of Service as unauthorized access is a horrible law that is frequently abused (most famously Aaron Swartz)

It is rightfully broadly criticized, and that shouldn't change because Uber are the perpetrators here

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by foldr on Thursday April 13, 2017 @05:56AM (#14105511)
Just because you like Aaron Swartz doesn't mean that the law was 'abused'. He flagrantly violated MIT's terms of service and knew that he was doing so.
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by nikcub on Thursday April 13, 2017 @06:27AM (#14105641)
> He flagrantly violated MIT's terms of service and knew that he was doing so.

Yep and that shouldn't be a federal offense with ~20 year jail term with a lifetime criminal record

It's private companies defining federal law and dictating enforcement for their own purposes. You wouldn't let Wal-Mart define what it's own tax laws are, or have McDonalds define what RICO is - having companies define what theft or trespass are is just as absurd.

edit: the list of notable CFAA cases reads like a tragic comedy[0]

There is a case in there where someone was charged for encouraging his union members to email complaints to a company and when it crashed their mail server he was charged under the CFAA.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act#N...

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by foldr on Thursday April 13, 2017 @06:28AM (#14105646)
The sentencing is up to the judge, not the law. Swartz was never sentenced to anything. You are getting the 20 year figure from media outlets that added up the maximum possible sentences for everything he was charged with, which bears no relation to how sentencing actually works.

Also, it obviously has to be a federal offense, since wires cross state lines.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by nikcub on Thursday April 13, 2017 @06:53AM (#14105752)
> The sentencing is up to the judge

With 97% of federal cases ending in plea agreements sentencing is overwealmingly in the hands of prosecutors.

In the Swartz case she wanted him to plead guilty to every single charge and serve up to 6 years. Hence the suicide.

As leverage in negotiations they told him at trial he was facing up to 35.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by foldr on Thursday April 13, 2017 @06:58AM (#14105768)
>serve up to 6 years.

It was 6 months, not 6 years. http://archive.boston.com/metrodesk/2013/01/14/mit-hacking-c...

>As leverage in negotiations they told him at trial he was facing up to 35.

Again, this is a nonsense figure. Can you give an example of someone who has been sentenced to 35 years in jail for similar crimes?

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by nikcub on Thursday April 13, 2017 @07:10AM (#14105816)
The whole point is that they don't sentence people to 35 years - they use that as a threat to leverage them into pleading guilty. Hence the dictatorship-level 99%+ conviction rates.

Same thing happen to Aaron, they hung a 7 year sentence around his neck if he didn't please guilty to all charges and accept the deal they offered him.

Even the innocent would please guilty in those circumstances, it's the only rational thing to do.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by foldr on Thursday April 13, 2017 @07:19AM (#14105851)
>they don't sentence people to 35 years - they use that as a threat to leverage them into pleading guilty.

But you contradict this in your own post. They threatened him with a 7 year jail term, not a 35 year jail term.

The plight of the innocent in the US system is very real, but irrelevant to the case of AS, as he was very clearly and unambiguously guilty.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by nikcub on Thursday April 13, 2017 @08:45AM (#14106317)
There is no contradiction. Let me break it down again.

The original DOJ press release[0] when Schwartz was charged:

> If convicted on these charges, SWARTZ faces up to 35 years in prison

That maximum sentence is not uncommon in CFAA cases as most charges carry 10 or 5 years and layering charges together is very common (ex Mathew Keys faced 25 years on 3 charges for sharing a password)

Facing 35 years Swartz enters plea talks and is offered 6 months recommended, up to 6 years but guilty to all charges

The prosecutors tell him if he doesnt take that deal and goes to trial then they'll be seeking a 7 year minimum 35 year max

A lot has been written about the problems with not just federal sentencing and plea agreements (internationally it is a unique system) but also specific problems with CFAA and sentencing guidelines:

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/03/41-months-weev-underst...

[0] https://web-beta.archive.org/web/20110724043722/https://www....

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by foldr on Thursday April 13, 2017 @08:56AM (#14106400)
Again, 35 years is simply the figure derived by adding up all of the maximum sentences. Swartz had good legal advice. He knew he wasn't going to be sentenced to 35 years in jail.

The problems with plea agreements relate largely to innocent people being pressured into taking them because a trial is too risky. Swartz had clearly violated the law, so he would have had nothing to gain from going to trial in any jurisdiction.

See e.g. here for further analysis:

http://volokh.com/2013/01/16/the-criminal-charges-against-aa...

>... realistically, Swartz was facing anything from probation to a few years in jail if he went to trial — depending largely on how you value the loss he caused — and either a 4 months in jail or 0-6 months in jail if he pled guilty.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by nikcub on Thursday April 13, 2017 @09:30AM (#14106659)
How does that justify having a ridiculous 35 year sentence hanging over somebody for a terms of use violation? That is murder levels of sentencing

The case was far from clear cut, weev had his case overturned and the Lori Drew case was overturned specifically because the judge said terms of use violations don't apply under CFAA

I read Orin Kerr a lot, abd agree with almost all of what he says in the series he wrote on the Swartz case - I only didn't buy his justification that overprosecution is ok because all the other prosecutors also do it

Swartz's main concern was a lifetime criminal record and not being able to work, and second pleading guilty to charges that he (and many others) don't agree he was guilty to

I def agree with Kerr that the unauthorized access statutes need to be reformed tho, that would have the Swartz case irrelevant and placed it back where it belonged - in a civil court

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by foldr on Thursday April 13, 2017 @10:38AM (#14107307)
>How does that justify having a ridiculous 35 year sentence hanging over somebody for a terms of use violation?

It's arithmetic. The maximum sentences are what they are, and their sum is what it is. Justification doesn't come into it. But a 35 year sentence was never "hanging over him". He had good legal advice. He knew that he would not go to jail for 35 years.

>The case was far from clear cut,

He physically broke into one of their network closets while attempting to disguise his identity. If that doesn't count as unauthorized access, nothing does.

>Swartz's main concern was a lifetime criminal record and not being able to work

Which, as Kerr points out, makes it absolutely baffling that he did this in the first place. It's often glossed over, but it really was an enormously stupid thing to do. It's sad that he got himself into so much trouble by doing it, but I can't see how anyone else is to blame for that. Especially when he'd already had fair warning after the PACER incident.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by oye_coder on Friday April 14, 2017 @08:06AM (#14113961)
You should definitely read this: http://bit.ly/2pgTpDg
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by foldr on Friday April 14, 2017 @09:58AM (#14114453)
I have read it, but it opens with the "35 years in jail" canard and is full of nonsense. Example:

>MIT is aware of the controls they could put in place to prevent what they consider abuse, such as downloading too many PDFs from one website or utilizing too much bandwidth, but they choose not to.

MIT did impose controls on the network to prevent Aaron from downloading PDFs, and he kept deliberately circumventing them (e.g. by spoofing his MAC address). So the idea that MIT was totally cool with what he was doing is obviously false, and AS knew that at the time.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by stass on Thursday April 13, 2017 @04:01AM (#14105032)
They didn't access any Lyft systems. They ran Lyft software on their own devices and collected and analyzed the data Lyft provides. One can argue that they broke EULA, but it's not necessarily unethical, and I'm ready to bet the majority of this site users broke at least one software EULA in their lifetime.
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by pluma on Thursday April 13, 2017 @05:36AM (#14105429)
Sure, the fake accounts just violated the ToS. But they then used an enumeration attack to find existing accounts and retrieve information not intended to be available to them. That it's not technologically sophisticated doesn't mean it's not a criminal offense.

If someone doesn't lock their front door and you enter their building, you're still trespassing. Especially if it's your competitor's front door and you're repeatedly entering the building to scout the place out for financial gain.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by nikcub on Thursday April 13, 2017 @05:52AM (#14105490)
I don't use any service without having a basic understanding oh how secure and private their systems are - the CFAA makes that all illegal

"You wouldn't open an unlocked door" is the "you wouldn't download a car" of infosec. The later redefined theft as not requiring anybody to be deprived of a good while the former has the same flaw, you arent deprived of any good, you aren't harmed, you haven't been coerced or forced - i.e. It meets none of the common law definitions of trespass[0]

[0] but it does explain why ddos attacks, spam and stealing user data are trespass because they do meet those definitions

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by pluma on Thursday April 13, 2017 @06:23AM (#14105628)
FWIW, I wouldn't walk through an unlocked door I'm clearly not meant to walk through.

There's a difference between "opening an unlocked door" and opening it, walking through it, making notes of everything behind it and repeating this room for all the other unlocked doors and then doing that pretty much continuously for days, weeks, months or however long Uber did it.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by pdpi on Thursday April 13, 2017 @07:01AM (#14105783)
> FWIW, I wouldn't walk through an unlocked door I'm clearly not meant to walk through.

I would totally open an unmarked unlocked door in a public space that has locked doors clearly marked "restricted access", especially if the layout of the place I'm visiting suggests that there would be something interesting there.

That's pretty much what it boils down to, no? Just because you didn't document an endpoint doesn't necessarily mean it's restricted access. In fact, if the end point is accessible, and you have other sections of your service that require authentication, then it's very much the exception that proves the rule — the fact that you specifically forbid access to some routes reasonably means that, in general, I'm allowed access to unauthenticated endpoints.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by nikcub on Thursday April 13, 2017 @06:28AM (#14105647)
My point was that walking through an unlocked door is a terrible analogy for accessing a resource URI that isn't directly linked from a page
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by UncleMeat on Thursday April 13, 2017 @04:51PM (#14110823)
Enumeration attacks are clearly covered by CFAA based on current law. See weev for example.
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by tuyguntn on Thursday April 13, 2017 @04:18AM (#14105121)
Assuming they did like you said the main point is

> collected and analyzed the data Lyft provides

they did it without permission

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by a_imho on Thursday April 13, 2017 @06:06AM (#14105547)
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by bitexploder on Thursday April 13, 2017 @07:13AM (#14105830)
Not saying I agree with parent or not, but he asked what was unethical, not about the legality. I do not base my ethics on the law.
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by prostoalex on Friday April 14, 2017 @04:38AM (#14113307)
A protected computer system.

The Information article suggests that driver IDs were available in the clear to anyone who'd bother looking at API payloads.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by bitexploder on Thursday April 13, 2017 @07:20AM (#14105861)
Let's explore this from the information security perspective, since that is my thing. If I had performed this research against Lyft and knew about these "information disclosure" issues I would have felt they were significant enough for disclosure to see them remediated.

Why? Sweeping privacy concerns. In a world where most people have an Uber or a Lyft app installed security issues like this become spy machines. So it isn't just drivers that lose their privacy, in the long run it touches on everyone's privacy, because location data is notoriously hard to anonymize and machine learning is only getting better. So there is the first ethical argument against this behavior that pops to mind.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by jsmthrowaway on Thursday April 13, 2017 @03:03AM (#14104755)
It's completely different, so far different as to be antonyms, opposites, completely diametrically opposed ends, because you just described a passive, orthogonal, ethical activity while Uber actively fooled with Lyft's systems to get the intel they wanted (emphasis mine):

> Hell originated after Uber created fake rider accounts on Lyft and used software to trick Lyft’s system into thinking those riders were in certain locations. This allowed Uber to see the eight closest available Lyft drivers to each fake rider.

You literally just typed the equivalent of "what's wrong with using an ad unit to deliver a zero day exploit? It's not much different from advertising."

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by viraptor on Thursday April 13, 2017 @04:15AM (#14105099)
It's not an exploit. There was no privilege escalation, denial of service, theft of private data, or anything like that. You can take the technology involved and replace it with a human process: multiple people around the city open the app and report back to the HQ the locations they see. Now, would you say this process is illegal?

Simplifying it even more: If you had people on the street, looking for cars with a Lyft sticker and reporting back every one you see - would you say that is illegal?

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by geocar on Thursday April 13, 2017 @04:54AM (#14105271)
> Simplifying it even more: If you had people on the street, looking for cars with a Lyft sticker and reporting back every one you see - would you say that is illegal?

Yes, because trying to "hack" the legal system by finding things that you can argue are "technically legal" is not something that impresses me.

I get that beating someone up and throwing a paying customer off a plane, or using a firehose on civil rights marchers, is "legal" if some judge can be persuaded ($$$) to agree, but I'm not going to play that game: I don't want to live someplace where we do what is legal and don't do what is illegal; I want my neighbors to know right from wrong.

A Reasonable Person would think that Uber was doing this to wrong Lyft and indeed it turns out, was doing this to wrong Lyft.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by viraptor on Thursday April 13, 2017 @04:59AM (#14105295)
Don't get me wrong. I think they're total assholes and shouldn't be doing this even if it is legal. But at the same time I'm interested in what would happen in case of an actual lawsuit. These don't care what impresses us :-(

Also, discussing what changes on Lyft's side would make it definitely illegal is interesting if you ever have some personal data in your own service.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by morganvachon on Thursday April 13, 2017 @06:32AM (#14105661)
The thing is, it would likely be a civil tort case, not necessarily a criminal case. An action can be legal from a criminal statute point of view, and yet still open the company up to a lawsuit in civil court where the other party can try to prove they were harmed.
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by bencollier49 on Thursday April 13, 2017 @04:19AM (#14105127)
Not sure about this in the US, but I'm pretty sure that in the UK, gathering a database of intelligence on competitors' staff earnings would be a violation of the Data Protection Act.
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by viraptor on Thursday April 13, 2017 @04:50AM (#14105257)
It would be interesting if this came to a trial. DPA protects only information that identifies people. If Uber collected information on cars instead which is anonymous and then correlated it with data it already has access to, so it only deanonymises its drivers, that's... I don't know.

IANAL, but I read the DPA a few times and I think it's an edge case. If someone has better idea, I'd love to hear it.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by makomk on Saturday April 15, 2017 @05:07AM (#14120017)
The Data Prrotection Act specifically covers this:

"* “personal data” means data which relate to a living individual who can be identified (a) from those data, or (b) from those data and other information which is in the possession of, or is likely to come into the possession of, the data controller"

Sorry, but they already thought of that one.

Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by lefstathiou on Thursday April 13, 2017 @04:54AM (#14105273)
I believe it would need to be personally identifiable data. The fact that Uber can personally identify someone with location is unique to them and falls into this gray area.
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by bitexploder on Thursday April 13, 2017 @07:24AM (#14105877)
I have decided that location data is PII. It is notoriously hard to anonymize. I have conducted some experiments with customers and even with a a relatively few samples it was possibl to merge address databases and "anonymous" location with ease. Right now there is a data classification fiction in most corporations that location days is not PII because it lets them do all sorts of analytics. I predict this fiction is going to get so excited organization in trouble and not just an Uber being so blatant about it.
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by JustSomeNobody on Thursday April 13, 2017 @03:06AM (#14104766)
All of which /u/stass would have know had there been an ethics class for them to take. ;)
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by stass on Thursday April 13, 2017 @03:59AM (#14105025)
There isn't the one and only standard for ethics. Perhaps a class would teach a certain version of ethics, but not a universally applicable one. As a somewhat relevant example, a lot of ethical norms in USSR (prosecution of successful individuals, outlawing free speech, destroying dissent, banning "unethical" literature and works of art) would be considered completely unethical in the Western society and vise versa, although the admiration of former became fashionable in tech circles lately.
Re:Uber reportedly tracked Lyft drivers using a program name... by _jezell_ on Thursday April 13, 2017 @03:21AM (#14104849)
Creating fake accounts is pretty common for spiders... standard search engine tactics.