Re:Silicon Valley Is a Big Fat Lie (2015)
by ralusek on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @09:28PM
(#14094064)
Silicon Valley is not a meritocracy because ~75% of those in leadership positions are white males?
19% of engineering and 18% of CS BA were for women in 2014. For African Americans, 4% of BA were for engineering.
Regardless of whether or not there is an institutional/societal reason for this, it is absolutely moronic to blame the place where engineers WORK for not having a perfectly balanced distribution of engineers when the pool available is so clearly not perfectly balanced.
The judgement of a meritocracy should be on whether or not a qualified individual can succeed in that environment purely on their own merits. Judging that based off of the racial distribution and gender distribution of the resulting pool is completely nonsensical.
I put 1 red jelly bean into a jar for every 5 blue jelly beans. I set the jar out and let people eat. If 1 red jelly bean was eaten for every 5 blue jelly beans, does it make sense to say people like the blue ones 5x more? Would it only be even if people ate the exact same amount of each?
19% of engineering and 18% of CS BA were for women in 2014. For African Americans, 4% of BA were for engineering.
Regardless of whether or not there is an institutional/societal reason for this, it is absolutely moronic to blame the place where engineers WORK for not having a perfectly balanced distribution of engineers when the pool available is so clearly not perfectly balanced.
The judgement of a meritocracy should be on whether or not a qualified individual can succeed in that environment purely on their own merits. Judging that based off of the racial distribution and gender distribution of the resulting pool is completely nonsensical.
I put 1 red jelly bean into a jar for every 5 blue jelly beans. I set the jar out and let people eat. If 1 red jelly bean was eaten for every 5 blue jelly beans, does it make sense to say people like the blue ones 5x more? Would it only be even if people ate the exact same amount of each?