No it isn't. What it implies is what people want: persistent logs, signing in from their phone logging them into the same session as signing in from their desktop, etc.
>Is that what Slack does? Whatever they do, I think it's what people want. Indeed it is not an experience offered by IRC, perhaps because "most IRC servers don't want" to, sure.
Slack has a much higher barrier to entry than IRC and most people using it are private companies.
IRC servers are publicly accessible and publicly accessed. They have existed for much longer. If Freenode stored every message ever sent on Freenode that would be a nightmare.
Only if you're a nerd. Took me 5 minutes to get started with Slack for our company and managing it is a piece of cake.
Mind you, I haven't used IRC for a decade, maybe it's become a whole lot easier since then...
In fact, if you can't work out IRC then you're almost certainly too silly to be a programmer.
I was more thinking about it from the context where Slack provides so many more features over IRC, not just real-time chat.
Slack requires you to make an account on their website, a new account for every Slack group. IRC you can just join - pick a nickname and type the server's address and you're in.
IRC is completely trivially easy to use, Slack is not.
Besides which, on most IRC servers, you're going to be using NickServ anyway, which is more complex a flow than setting up a user on Slack.
Okay, to me that is the same thing as 'persistent sessions', but without belaboring the point... can IRC do those things? Right, it depends on the server and client. What servers and clients can? I think it's pretty rare, if it exists.
If your answer is "well, IRC _could_ do that, if only more reosurces were invested in it to make it so", okay, but so what?
Maybe actually read the thread next time? So don't "so what?" me. This isn't about whether IRC can do those things.
> No, nobody wants this
Are you serious? I think lots of people do. I think it's one of the draws of Slack.
> The thing is, most IRC servers don't want to buffer messages indefinitely for everyone that makes an account then never logs in again.
Is that what Slack does? Whatever they do, I think it's what people want. Indeed it is not an experience offered by IRC, perhaps because "most IRC servers don't want" to, sure.