Well, it rules out a more recent hoax. I would consider a book produced in the early 15th century that deliberately contained.nothing of use to be something of a hoax. A magician's prop, for instance.
There's another question of whether, even if information was once encoded in there, it is recoverable. Either because of some sort of hash-like function applied to the data, or just because there's not enough to go on.
It's certainly intriguing.
Re:Secret Knowledge – or a Hoax?
by sbierwagen on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @04:07PM
(#14091956)
Some prominent forgeries have used both old media with old ink. Radiocarbon dating only proves the age of a substance, it doesn't prove when ink was applied to paper.
Re:Secret Knowledge – or a Hoax?
by DonaldFisk on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @04:47PM
(#14092285)
It was referred to in a letter written in 1639: http://www.voynich.nu/letters.html
The question is whether the text contains any meaningful encoded information, or is completely meaningless.