Re:Why Slack is inappropriate for open source communications
by isaiahg on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @11:05AM
(#14088522)
I don't know why didn't just evolve irc. Feature wise slack doesn't really bring much new. It just has a good interface. If someone made an irc client as easy to use as slack then we'd have our answer.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why Slack is inappropriate for open source communications
by chrisseaton on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @11:10AM
(#14088584)
> It just has a good interface
But this is such a big deal. You make it sound like a good interface is trivial. It isn't, and it makes a huge difference.
Re:Why Slack is inappropriate for open source communications
by apocalyptic0n3 on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @11:23AM
(#14088756)
It really is. Slack's interface is good enough and easy enough to understand that even the least technical people can pick it up in a few minutes after you show it to them and explain the difference between public and private channels. A week or two of use is enough to master everyday Slack use. Slack may not bring much to the table in terms of new functionality, but it does make it insanely easy for the average person to easily use the system and be involved, which really cannot be overstated when working at a company with a varying level of technical abilities.
Re:Why Slack is inappropriate for open source communications
by thraway2016 on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @11:24AM
(#14088761)
irssi is a significantly better interface than any slack application.
Re:Why Slack is inappropriate for open source communications
by Eldt on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @12:06PM
(#14089402)
The technically illiterate people I know would have a much harder time using irssi than slack
Re:Why Slack is inappropriate for open source communications
by Karunamon on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @11:46AM
(#14089113)
Slack's users would disagree.
Re:Why Slack is inappropriate for open source communications
by samtho on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @11:11AM
(#14088605)
From my understanding, this is what XMPP was suppose to be. Problem is the going to be the same evolving IRC: widespread adoption.
Re:Why Slack is inappropriate for open source communications
by s73ver on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @12:31PM
(#14089700)
"Feature wise slack doesn't really bring much new. It just has a good interface."
That's a pretty huge feature. Never underestimate how making something more usable increases it's popularity.
Re:Why Slack is inappropriate for open source communications
by cat199 on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @02:04PM
(#14090739)
Really - what is sooo unusable about IRC?
Get a good GUI client, enter some parameters into a text bar, click 'ok', then chat. exactly the same process as a web browser..
The real problem is the 'endless summer' of tablet-era people who confuse the 'interweb' with the 'internet'. There used to be much more general community advocacy and understanding of promoting open communications 'baked in' to the internet culture which has been eroded by crass commercialization - this is the real problem that needs to be attacked...
Re:Why Slack is inappropriate for open source communications
by chrisseaton on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @03:19PM
(#14091465)
Can you easily share multi-line code, formatted in a proportional font and syntax highlighted, in any IRC client? That's something I want to do almost every hour I'm working.
Re:Why Slack is inappropriate for open source communications
by mburns on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @09:40PM
(#14094093)
Some clients will intercept multi-line messages and let you POST the content to a pastebin. That way, supported clients show pretty-printed code and unsupported client just see a URL.
Re:Why Slack is inappropriate for open source communications
by s73ver on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @12:43PM
(#14099362)
And how do I know that everyone in the room is using such a client? I know that everyone using Slack will see the message as I intended it to be seen.
Re:Why Slack is inappropriate for open source communications
by StavrosK on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @11:10AM
(#14088587)
Because adding a feature to a standard means you have to get everyone on board. Slack as an IRC client would basically be Slack as it is now, and the server protocol would be an implementation detail.