Re:Kenneth Arrow and the golden age of economic theory
by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @03:52AM
(#14085679)
> Unmodified [Black Scholes] is BS
Black-Scholes-Merton is a theory. Analogous to Newtonian mechanics or textbook thermodynamics. They all need modification to work in the real world. That doesn't make them BS.
> [Using a fat-tailed distribution] can, however, give one a better appreciation of the risk
How does one choose a model and parameters for events which are, by definition, hard to predict? Keep in mind that most "black swans" arise from unforeseen dimensions of risk. There's the "my stock lost 90% of its value" fat tail versus "the damn exchange went bust". There's "my clearing bank is broke" and "the Russians invaded my country".
Black-Scholes-Merton is a theory. Analogous to Newtonian mechanics or textbook thermodynamics. They all need modification to work in the real world. That doesn't make them BS.
> [Using a fat-tailed distribution] can, however, give one a better appreciation of the risk
How does one choose a model and parameters for events which are, by definition, hard to predict? Keep in mind that most "black swans" arise from unforeseen dimensions of risk. There's the "my stock lost 90% of its value" fat tail versus "the damn exchange went bust". There's "my clearing bank is broke" and "the Russians invaded my country".