News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kenneth Arrow and the golden age of economic theory by petters on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @02:52AM (#14085443)
That such a function f exists is pretty standard, right? I know we discussed it during my undergrad studies. See e.g. Counterexamples in Analysis.

Also, a point is a closed set, so you probably want non-empty interior.

Re:Kenneth Arrow and the golden age of economic theory by graycat on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @04:08AM (#14085752)
No, it's not standard. I doubt that it is in Counterexamples in Analysis, one of my favorite books.

No, don't need a non-empty interior for the closed set. The closed set can even be empty. The function is to be zero on the closed set and positive otherwise. For a single point could use just the squared distance to the point, i.e., a parabola.

For a closed set like the Mandelbrot set and for the general case, have to try harder.

For a fast version of the proof, outside the closed set is an open set. If it is empty, then just let the function f = 0. Else in that open set, pick a countable dense set. Roughly for each point in that countable dense set, solve the problem for that set, and then add all the countably many partial solutions in a convergent way.

A key is a Baby Rudin exercise of a function g: R --> R where

g(x) = 0 for x <= 0

g(x) > 0 for x > 0

and g is infinitely differentiable. Sure, g is based on an exponential.

Then for f: R^2, at each of the countably many points, spin g to make a smooth hill where the bottom of the hill just touches the closed set C. The spin, being intuitive here, also works for f: R^n. Sure, for each of the countably infinitely many points, the spin, in g(z), z is the distance to the to the point. I'm being intuitive and sloppy here to be brief and easier to understand.

Then in R^2, at the origin, for each positive rational of the form p/q in lowest terms, have a ray from the origin at angle p radians and length 1/q. That's a bizarre closed set. Then at the origin, the Zangwill and KTCQ don't agree, are independent. Here, again, I'm being brief.

Re:Kenneth Arrow and the golden age of economic theory by petters on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @09:04AM (#14087291)
Sorry, I misread the theorem earlier. Thanks!