News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Guy uploads, downloads, then re-uploads the same video to... by philwelch on Sunday June 06, 2010 @04:05AM (#1408227)
"My original point, long ago, was that ... it's absurd to "look down on" the artist"

Fine, granted. In the general case, judging personalities is boring. That's not the point I've been arguing.

"As for the critiquing of art, I don't say that nobody should say their thoughts on it. But your thoughts are not the final word on anything. If you say 'that is horrible' and I say 'it moves me', then it has value to me and none to you. For one of us it is bad art, for the other it is important."

So you think it's impossible to make objective judgments of art. I disagree.

"As such, I don't say that all art is "good art", even though you dishonestly put those words into my mouth."

Like art, your comments are difficult to correctly interpret. Sorry for the misunderstanding.

There are no comments on this comment yet.