News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by hristov on Monday April 10, 2017 @03:35AM (#14076700)
Wow the public relations sock-puppetry on HN is getting very clever and sophisticated. I really love the green account - nice touch. It really helps your authenticity to pretend like you are afraid of retribution from John Deere when you are totally kissing their asses.

Let me ask you this -- why in the world do the lines of software you write prevent a qualified mechanic from changing a transmission? You know people used to do that all the time when tractors had zero lines of software in them.

After all you are trying to very cleverly change the subject here. You are doing it very deftly, as you should, because you are not a software developer, you are a PR drone and it is your job to deftly change the subject.

The question here is not about the quality of the John Deere software, so it does not really matter how many engineers worked on it or how hard they worked on it. The problem is that the John Deere software takes away an essential right of property ownership that people take for granted.

No one is accusing the JD software of being faulty, i.e., incapable of serving it's intended purpose. People are accusing the software of having nefarious purposes and serving them all too well.

Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by ehsankia on Monday April 10, 2017 @04:53AM (#14076962)
Not on either side here, but I feel like you're missing the point there. Let's say someone does modify the code, then the machine messes up and ends up killing someone. Who would be the culprit there? I guess they could have something that detects when the software is modified, but even if they did, I bet it would still be poor publicity for them (similar to when people misuse Tesla's assist and getting in accidents).

Also, honest question here about changing transmission. You make it sound as if it's completely unrelated with the code, but is it? The code may very well be tuned for the hardware as it is, and changing any of it could also lead to unexpected results.

Of course there's much better ways of going about it, but from a lawsuit protection perspective, I think you're simplifying an issue which is much more complex than it may seem at the surface.

Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by DanielBMarkham on Monday April 10, 2017 @07:56AM (#14077720)
Both the OP and the reply seem a bit over-the-top, but it's a fair call to say that the goal was changing the subject from "who owns the tractor" to "think of the children!"

People repair stuff they own all the time, and if they do a bad job of it, they are liable for any damages caused. All that's really needed here is some clear way to indicate that this factory-issued X has been modified by the owner to be an X1 model. End of story.

We can't continue down this path of people developing software and somehow in the process picking up vast quantities of physical goods that buyers think they actually own. Not only is it evil, it's nonsensical from the viewpoint of the average informed person. The only reason it's worked as long as it has is that most people aren't informed enough about it. Tractors might be the straw that breaks the camel's back on this issue. People don't think much about the inner workings of their phones, but Joe Farmer fixing his tractor is a concept most folks don't have difficulty getting their head around.

Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by bartl on Monday April 10, 2017 @06:56AM (#14077402)
>Let's say someone does modify the code.

Let's not. These farmers don't want to change the software. They only want to fix their hardware.

And because of the close tightness with the software, they can't.

Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by bigtimeidiot on Monday April 10, 2017 @07:03AM (#14077427)
Do you think I can pull the electric motor from my Model S to replace it?

When John Deere does this, HN is up in arms. When Tesla does it, it's part of an "innovative business model".

Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by jinzo on Monday April 10, 2017 @07:47AM (#14077666)
As someone in the car repair industry I can assure you that Teslas hostility regarding non-authorised-repair is a big issue and will only blow up when Teslas become more common. At least here in Europe, this won't fly.
Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by georgyo on Monday April 10, 2017 @07:43AM (#14077643)
I think if you had the part and replaced it, your car would turn on without a Tesla engineer recertifying it.
Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by bigtimeidiot on Monday April 10, 2017 @08:51AM (#14078036)
>your car would turn on without a Tesla engineer recertifying it

I think you're going to be disappointed.

Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by ProblemFactory on Monday April 10, 2017 @09:09AM (#14078165)
> Let's say someone does modify the code, then the machine messes up and ends up killing someone. Who would be the culprit there?

People repair and modify their cars every day - and these are driven on public roads among other drivers and pedestrians. Farm equipment is operated on private property and among workers who are mostly aware of the risks. In the end, if the vehicle is unsafe, the driver is responsible.

Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by rdslw on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:58AM (#14077186)
No.

JD is a knife manufacturer who puts countermeasures to prohibit knives owners from sharpening second side of the blade (among others things). Because it can be dangerous.

Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by koolba on Monday April 10, 2017 @07:14AM (#14077477)
It sounds like you can't sharpen the first side either. Or more aptly, replace the handle of the knife when it gets worn.
[dead]
Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by barking on Monday April 10, 2017 @04:51AM (#14076955)
I can understand MS but John Deere? Hard to credit that they'd be monitoring HN. I mean how many farmers read HN?
Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by lithos on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:54AM (#14077174)
John deer is willing to spend millions to protect their IP, all the way to the color green.
Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by barking on Monday April 10, 2017 @06:24AM (#14077287)
They're pretty good at it then
Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by tomlong on Monday April 10, 2017 @05:02AM (#14076986)
I'm sceptical as well but I imagine people there search Twitter and Google and such to see what is being said by them.
Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by jsnathan on Monday April 10, 2017 @06:45AM (#14077377)
There are services that have the specific purpose of identifying discussions about brands in real time [1].

Whether that's good or bad depends on how it's used I guess.

[1]: https://mention.com/en/

Re:Farmers look for ways to circumvent tractor software locks by barking on Monday April 10, 2017 @06:24AM (#14077292)
I didn't think of that!