Re:The de Havilland Comet changed aviation for good
by WalterBright on Sunday April 09, 2017 @08:42PM
(#14075170)
> Avro Tudor
Curiously, this did not extend to the cockpit windows:
http://smg.photobucket.com/user/Coridano/media/TB01.jpg.html
suggesting that stress cracking was not the reason they did it. (There are other reasons for round windows - such as portholes on ships which are easier to make a seal.)
The 707 shows a more radiused corner for the cockpit windows.
Re:The de Havilland Comet changed aviation for good
by WalterBright on Sunday April 09, 2017 @04:52PM
(#14074299)
Fatigue failure was poorly understood at the time. It still is incompletely understood, but much better models have been constructed to predict it. Fatigue damage goes up as the cube of the load, and the Comet was pressurized at 35,000 feet rather than 20,000 for the Stratoliner, meaning much more load.
Re:The de Havilland Comet changed aviation for good
by RugnirViking on Monday April 10, 2017 @10:56AM
(#14078986)
I assume I am wrong on this, but surely if it pressurized to 35000 feet, then that would be less load? As they pressurized it to that it would be closer to the air at its altitude?
Re:The de Havilland Comet changed aviation for good
by WalterBright on Monday April 10, 2017 @01:43PM
(#14080816)
The cabin pressure inside is 10,000 feet, the air pressure outside is 35,000 feet, making for more of a pressure differential than at 20,000 feet altitude.
Boeing was by no means the first to use radiused windows in pressurised airliners; the Avro Tudor was doing so in 1946 and there may well have been earlier examples.
Conversely the Boeing Stratoliner was flying with square windows in the early 1940s and didn't suffer fatigue failures, nor did the later DC-6. Corner stresses were understood at the time.
What really undid the Comet was that the fuselage skin gauge was insufficient to accommodate the increased rate of change of pressure differential that was introduced with jet flight. Whereas the preceding piston-engined airliners were lucky to hit 1000 feet per minute climbing to 20,000 ft, the Comet climbed at three times that rate to 35,000 ft +.
The Comet had skin reinforced to 20 swg along the window belt, whereas the succeeding Comet IV had 18 swg with 16 swg framing.