Re:The Utter Uselessness of Job Interviews
by ScottBurson on Sunday April 09, 2017 @04:06PM
(#14074100)
> For this use case only precision matters. Extremely low recall is fine.
Only if you have arbitrarily large amounts of time you can spend interviewing. Most of us don't.
Here's how I think it works. Skilled interviewers are biased toward rejecting candidates based on any negative impression. Structured interviewing has the same effect. It's the precision versus recall tradeoff. For this use case only precision matters. Extremely low recall is fine.
Also, in the GPA prediction example, the interviewer is penalized for predicting a low GPA for a person who performed well. But in hiring, there is no penalty for failing to hire someone who would have performed adequately.
(Yes, I understand there is an implicit assumption in my argument that candidates are not in short supply, but that's usually true, certainly at Google)