News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:H.R. 4213 - Payroll Tax for S-Corp Dividends by tptacek on Saturday June 05, 2010 @03:27PM (#1407310)
I think the general principal in play here is fairness. I think fairness is orthogonal to the government's use of proceeds.

If my best developer has to pay more taxes than me, simply by nature of not owning a portion of the company large enough to funnel her wages through, that situation seems prima facie unfair. The unfortunate fact is, that same unfairness is usually going to be compounded: my ownership of the company that developer works for probably means I'm not only paying relatively lower taxes, but also making more money. That's regressive. Regressive taxes are evil regardless of whether you think progressive taxes are good.

Finally, I actually don't think the use of proceeds issue makes this a harder call. Forget totalitarian states for a second, and just think about Social Security.

A rationale for not paying taxes is that they'll go to fund a sham Social Security system. But if Social Security is a sham, it's wrong that anybody should have to pay into it. Moreover, as long as most people are on the hook for it, shielding yourself (and the class of people like you) from its obligations is actually counterproductive. The more people (and the more influential the people) affected by FICA, the more pressure there will be to change that system to reflect the will of its stakeholders.

Re:H.R. 4213 - Payroll Tax for S-Corp Dividends by lionhearted on Saturday June 05, 2010 @03:35PM (#1407324)
> A rationale for not paying taxes is that they'll go to fund a sham Social Security system. But if Social Security is a sham, it's wrong that anybody should have to pay into it. Moreover, as long as most people are on the hook for it, shielding yourself (and the class of people like you) from its obligations is actually counterproductive. The more people (and the more influential the people) affected by FICA, the more pressure there will be to change that system to reflect the will of its stakeholders.

That's actually a very intelligent argument. For the record, I do pay my taxes and I'm not particularly creative or aggressive about it - but I do it with roughly the same feeling I give my wallet to a mugger if he's got a knife.

The alternative argument is, "If something is bad, less of it is always good." Like, in a place that arrests people for free speech, should every free speaking person turn themselves in? But your position also makes sense as well, seems to be thought out, and part of a coherent worldview. I disagree, but I appreciate you taking the time to respond. Cheers.

Re:H.R. 4213 - Payroll Tax for S-Corp Dividends by joelhaus on Saturday June 05, 2010 @04:37PM (#1407405)
If something is bad, less of it is always good.

The problem with this statement is that very few "things" are either all good or all bad.

P.S. You both make good points and it's encouraging to see thoughtful discussions like this on what can be very divisive issues, so thanks.