News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:H.R. 4213 - Payroll Tax for S-Corp Dividends by tptacek on Saturday June 05, 2010 @02:56PM (#1407263)
You have in reality no such benefit. From my cursory research, taxpayers have consistently lost every case in which they attempted to hide wages as distros. Courts have held that "wages" is a term that describes all remuneration for services rendered in any form. Even loans from the company to shareholders can, under the tax code, be reclassified by the IRS as FICA-eligible wages.

The only benefit S-Corp shareholders have under the present system is that they can force the IRS to audit to recover this money, which is a game that entrepreneurs often win because very few people really get audited anyways.

So, two things. First, the loophole doesn't really simplify your life. For many years after filing one of these bogus returns, you can still be levied for the hidden wages, plus penalties (including a huge extra negligence penalty). Second, there's nothing fair or sensible about the exemption S-Corp shareholders are taking; people with exactly the same skin in the economy have to pay FICA, so why shouldn't S-Corp owners?

Re:H.R. 4213 - Payroll Tax for S-Corp Dividends by credo on Saturday June 05, 2010 @03:22PM (#1407299)
You're making the assumption that all S-corp distributions amount to "hiding wages". Most accountants will tell you that IRS regulations disagree with you on that point.

I see that you didn't respond to the reverse-loophole point on FUTA taxes. Why should a company pay unemployment insurance taxes for founder-employees when these employees can never claim unemployment allowances ?

Re:H.R. 4213 - Payroll Tax for S-Corp Dividends by tptacek on Saturday June 05, 2010 @03:35PM (#1407323)
The general line of argument would be that FUTA payments fund a broad social safety net, and that no "insurance" payment we make to the government has implied 1:1 benefits for the payers.

But we don't have to bother with that argument because I agree with you on that point.

The general logic of the tax code and the IRS' enforcement of it seems to be that as an employee of a company --- which you are unless there's some patently obvious reason why you would be performing services for the company otherwise --- then your role has a fair market value. If you make at least that amount of money in any way, you owe payroll taxes on it. Over that amount, you don't.

The reality of the software business is, if you're a principal, founder, officer, director, or lead at a company that can afford to distribute tens of thousands of dollars to its employees, your fair market value is probably greater than the FICA cap, and the notion of what "is" or "isn't" a distribution is academic.

Are there scenarios where people are legitimately taking profit sharing distros that are not, under the spirit of the tax code, wages? I'm sure there are. Do those scenarios really account for a significant fraction of the cases where people take a "wage/distro split"? I really doubt it. My casual sense of it is, people that take a "wage/distro split" feel entitled to pay lower taxes simply because they've finagled themselves into an S-Corp.