News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Matter Conscious? by visarga on Sunday April 09, 2017 @12:59AM (#14070566)
> just because these things can conceive consciousness does not make them consciousness.

I like the car example. If I have a pile of car parts, they don't make a car. They have to be put in a special way in order to function. What is "car-ness" and where does it lay? In the parts, or in the configuration, or in the whole action of driving it?

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by catshirt on Monday April 10, 2017 @03:27PM (#14081765)
great analogy. also does a good job pointing out the type of vagueness and subjectivity in meaning that makes it hard to pin down consciousness.

the vagueness- which parts can you remove from a car before you wouldn't call it a car anymore?

the subjectivity- which parts can you remove from a car before I wouldn't call it a car anymore?

bald is another funny example of emergence (though not my own). how many hairs must one grow before they are no longer bald?