With a deal with an airline, the company doesn't have to do the 1-2% cashback, instead they give 0 to the customer. The airline company will give them miles though. Now the airline company can say to the credit card company: "look these thousands of customers you have them only thanks to me, so let's split your profits from the merchant 50/50 (or at least give me that 1% cashback you don't have to pay the customer), plus at some point I'll have to actually offer a plane ticket to those customers who earn enough miles"
What a customer gets usually is something like 7 miles per dollar. Consumer website estimate[1] that in the best of case, a mile is equal to ~$0.01, so they're also saving money there. (Plus the money the credit card company give them is today, whereas the plane ticket might be in one year or more, so the present discounted value of that ticket is even less)
[1] https://thepointsguy.com/2017/04/april-2017-monthly-valuatio...
Your math is way off. If it's 7 miles per dollar spent on the card, that is 7% back by your math, compared to 1-2% cashback, this conflicts with "they're also saving money there."
With that math, you're saying that it's a great deal for the consumer. Perhaps the other things you mentioned still add up to being in the airlines favor, but whats really going on?
This is likely because they presume most of the readers reading a Bloomberg article about whether or not airlines are undervalued due to the revenue stream of their loyalty programs are passingly familiar with many of the core concepts.
Can you give a source for this? I've definitely gotten much better value out of my miles than this (though not always). And I'm talking about normal coach fare, not wasting miles on first class tickets that only seems like a good deal because the list price is so exorbitant.
What value you personally actually get out of miles is individualized and taking a valuation from a rando blogger at face value is incredibly stupid. Especially from bloggers like The Points Guy (which was linked), because they get kickback when you use their referral links to sign up for credit cards.
If you offered me the choice between 10 AA miles and 1,000 Delta miles, I'd choose 10 AA miles, no matter what bloggers say. I'll always use AA miles and I would have trouble doing anything with Delta miles.
For instance, I fly over 100,000 miles per year with one airline alliance which puts me in the highest earning category for earning award points. Essentially they give you a an 11x multiplayer of award miles for every actual mile (domestic, overseas is more complicated). At lower levels it may be be 9x or 7x, etc. That means the difficulty of earning miles scales significantly with frequency, which if course changes the value.
Now, rather then trying to figure out the price of a ticket and comparing it to #of miles spent, which is difficult because of black out dates, variable pricing, destination/date premiums, and a ton of other factors, I found out you can just buy gift cards.
Specifically, you can buy Amazon gift cards at about 15,000 points per $100 gift card. While not as fungible as USD, given my spending habits and Amazon's large selection, it becomes a pretty good stand in. That means for me, a mile is always worth around 0.006 cents at a minimum. At around 250,000 award miles a year that's around 1,600 dollars per year which isn't that bad. At the very least it's better then some random blogger picking a number based on ticket prices.
I also don't know where you're getting that 7 miles/dollar number from.
- more customers
- buying more useless stuff (to collect miles) that they would otherwise won't buy.
- making outrageous travel plans (using those miles) that they otherwise won't make (e.g., fly to europe over the weekend if you're feeling bored; or world tour for honeymoon).
on top of the usual:
- annual fee
- interest on credit card (missed monthly payments and/or lower-than-full payments)
No, the money comes from merchants.
When you charge something at a merchant (the seller) with a rewards card, the merchant pays a higher percentage fee to the card issuer for that transaction.
So when you sell things, and you accept credit cards, there is actually a fairly large variance in cost between different cards that your buyers might use ... it might be quite cheap for you if your buyer used a plain old visa card with no rewards ... and it might be 3-4x that fee if they use some crazy cash rewards super bonus miles card ...
That is where the money comes from.
I guess a lot of people pay the same price for a product or service and don't use every aspect of it.
What I think it's getting at is: airlines are increasingly selling their services (i.e. seats on planes) indirectly, via loyalty programs instead of directly, via ticket sales.
Selling via the loyalty programs has benefits probably because consumers over-value the miles they receive, because (a) some portion of the miles will expire or never be redeemed, and consumers don't internalize that fact, (b) the airline collects from from the bank as soon as the issue the miles, but they don't have to pay for the seats until some point in the future, and (c) they can take advantage of some psychological factors/gamification by encouraging people to earn "gold" or "platinum" status, etc.
If you have a Delta credit card and you never redeem the miles, the rational thing for you to do would be to switch to a credit card with a different rewards program.
The reason you'd keep using your Delta credit card is because you anticipate that you will redeem the miles for air travel later. The value of the miles still ultimately derives from their "flying business".
> ultimately the "miles"
> they sell are for the very
> same "seats"
No figure to support the following claim, but I'd expect 50% of miles to expire without being redeemed.But also: I recently stayed at the Conrad Rangali "for free" having accumulated enough points. Food, a small upgrade, transfer to the island, etc conspired to add an extra $5,000 of spend on a five night stay. Don't underestimate the upsell!
I've used points for five-night stays at the Conrads in Seoul and Tokyo without having a single dime on my invoice at checkout.
But in an urban setting? What is there to spend money on at the hotel that isn't better off-property? Especially at Hilton properties where anyone with enough points for a redemption at least has gold status and gets free breakfast and likely lounge access.
One of the ways to look at it is that banks pay to attract stable, low-risk customers. They're losing money on each individual cards, but they gain money in the long run buy attracting high-income people who will continue to spend during an economic downturn.
Most of the modern economic system is not about making money out of thin air, but about managing risk.
Same way banks make money off the rest of it's cardholders.
In the UK they also market you for $. They ain't sending you that exclusive "loyal VIP customer" introduction/bonus offer for virgin wine, or some fitness club, or breakdown out the goodness of their heart..Which is probably another nice earner on top of everything else
There are still some [1] with introductory cashback, or very limited cashback, but nothing like the 2-3% ones that used to exist.
I'm not sorry to see them go -- charging all customers an extra 1.5% (or whatever) in order to give a savvy few cashback isn't fair.
[1] http://www.moneysavingexpert.com/credit-cards/cashback-credi...
Credit card partners!
So if you get your favorite sports team's credit card, they get a cut.
http://www.doctorofcredit.com/everything-you-ever-wanted-to-...
There's even a Linux credit card (not kidding) https://www.linuxfoundation.org/offerings/linux-credit-card
> Standard Interchange Reimbursement Fee, All Other Products [besides Visa Signature Preferred / Visa Infinite]: 2.70%
Most of the stores I work with average around 0.83% to 0.85% of credit card/debit card volume going to transaction fees, with processor pricing hovering between $0.10 a trans and 10 basis points to 25 basis points.
Are you well versed in interchange? Have you seen there merchant processing statement? What was their average ticket, Visa/MC/Amex/DC breakdown, total volume, and pricing (basis points, trans fee, plus hidden fees)?
If your a restaurant, you are going to take many more premium cards. My example is from grocery, where debit cards are common, and the retailers are extremely aggressive and sue companies like Visa on a quarterly basis.
>Do you know if data about industry-wide averages rather than the folks you work with?
Lololololol, that is a good one! No, this is an extremely fractured industry with literally hundreds of players, operating using pyramid scheme brainwashing tactics, and in ACN's and CDS's cases, as actual pyramid schemes (the latter pushed via a church).
Industry players don't share, and there are contracts & regulations preventing First Data, Tsys & Elavon from aggregating and distributing that type of info about their ISOs portfolios. Akin to the firewall in Investment Banking between analysts and bankers, it isn't about to come tumbling down.
What I can tell you is running a bit below 1% cost is fairly common in the supermarket vertical. Restaurants and other retail trend higher, due to their poor lobbying power, but still you should be well within 2.5% if not 2% if your clientèle aren't all exclusively using top tier cards and you aren't processing through some racket like Card Data Services where your fellow parishioner sold you payment processing that is 150 basis points over interchange.
Anyways, you were still borrowing money they just had you put up collateral first. You were still in debt to the bank, the fact they were holding collateral for the debt is irrelevant.
It's like if I had a fedora collection worth $30,000 and I go to the pawn shop and they give me a $10,000 loan and hold my Fedora collection as collateral for that loan.
(I'm from .au, where secured credit cards apparently don't exist, but I've read about the concept on the internet in the American context)
So if you have no history of paying back loans the bank doesn't want to loan you money unless you put up collateral. You use it to build up a credit history without risk of default to the bank - if you default they keep your collateral.
Secured cards aren't intended to be used long term. They are only for when you don't have a history (or poor history) of paying back debts. Many (most?) secured cards automatically convert to a non secured cards after a while, like six months or so.
I suspect that there are probably regulatory or other systematic differences that make them not worth offering; while they are sold here as ways to build credit they don't seem to actually be necessary to that purpose. Even without credit cards, most people seem to be able to build a history of having and paying financial obligations that will result in sufficient credit to qualify for regular (if low-limit) credit cards in a reasonable period of time without secured cards.
If you weren't actually borrowing money then it wouldn't effect your credit score, full stop.
For example, read the terms for Discover's secured card:
https://www.discovercard.com/application/securedApplicantTer...
>If you are in default under the Cardmember Agreement or the Account is closed for any reason, you authorize us at any time(s) to withdraw all or any portion of the Funds from the Security Deposit Account and apply them to reduce your Obligations. Any such application of Funds will not constitute any part of the Minimum Payment Due under the Cardmember Agreement. You will continue to be responsible for making payments as required under the Cardmember Agreement and for repaying any outstanding Obligations.
That wasn't an attempt at pedantry (ironically, it was actually abbreviated to avoid pointless pedantry; the original draft had "of conventional credit cards who have not paid on the account in advance of spending" after the "cardholders".)
> In this case, I have at least one credit card where I've put down a deposit of twice the spending limit of the card.
As a sibling comment and it's descendants point out, using such a secured card is still borrowing money in the same way that using an unsecured card is, and still subject to interest charges on the debt if not paid within a specified time just like unsecured cards. That you are putting up collateral to limit the banks default risk (and typically getting a better interest rate on any carried balance than anyone without excellent credit would get on an unsecured card because of that) doesn't alter that fact.
> At no time am I in debt to the bank, or borrowing money to them.
Yes you are; the bank just has possession of some of your property and a right to seize ownership of that property, as well as the possession it already holds, in the event of default on the debt. This is similar to what happens when you borrow money against property at a pawn shop.
airlines sell a mile at an average of 1 cent, banks charge merchants 3.5 cents for every dollar.
consumers can win if they pay their credit card off on time. many of them are able to churn by putting business travel from their employer on their credit card and getting it reimbursed in time.
banks can win double and triple if consumers don't pay their credit card balance completely one time, just once.
since the credit card aspect was already there whether there were good loyalty programs in existence or not, its actually a decent ecosystem!
I mean money has to come from somewhere, I assume the tens of millions of credit card holders. But credit card holders do their usual spending, and in fact save between 1% and 3% on their monthly bills instead of paying more.
Unless.
- They increase their air travel frequency.
- They get addicted to collecting airline miles, because it gives them the feeling of free air travel.
- And as a result they increase their average spending (so no longer the 'usual' spending), and buy useless stuff, just so they can collect more and more miles.
Is that the real story or something more/different?