News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Matter Conscious? by SomeStupidPoint on Saturday April 08, 2017 @02:25PM (#14068229)
Nothing about our understanding of intelligence or self-awareness explains why we're not philosophical zombies.

Your explanation only addresses the form of perception, not why there's perception at all. It doesn't even address it, just implicitly assumes there must be such!

Your comment isn't even wrong: it fails to address the topic at all.

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by lend000 on Saturday April 08, 2017 @03:36PM (#14068577)
> Your comment isn't even wrong: it fails to address the topic at all.

It always surprises me when people make seemingly innocuous discussions political. The pros and cons of a pseudo-anonymous Internet. Regardless, I'm not sure what point you're talking about or how this article is not the perfect place to discuss consciousness.

> Nothing about our understanding of intelligence or self-awareness explains why we're not philosophical zombies.

As I posted on another comment, I think this could also be phrased conversely (that a philosophical zombie makes no sense), depending on your definition of a zombie.

> Your explanation only addresses the form of perception, not why there's perception at all.

Not sure what you mean here, but it sounds like you're still viewing consciousness as something 'greater' than what is necessary to process signals and generate outputs. And then calling it perception.

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by abiox on Saturday April 08, 2017 @02:48PM (#14068329)
> Nothing about our understanding of intelligence or self-awareness explains why we're not philosophical zombies.

perhaps we really are zombies.

> why there's perception at all

why do atoms interact at all? why do fields interact at all?

perhaps "there's perception" because fields and matter can interact.

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by praxulus on Saturday April 08, 2017 @03:04PM (#14068421)
>perhaps we really are zombies

Maybe you are, but I'm definitely conscious. I find it hard to believe that I'm unique in that respect.

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by lend000 on Saturday April 08, 2017 @03:11PM (#14068466)
> Maybe you are, but I'm definitely conscious.

I think the real takeaway is that a philosophical zombie cannot exist, because all of the intelligent, aware, normal things that a philosophical zombie is supposed to be able to do require some sort of consciousness to integrate the mechanical signals. That's all consciousness is -- data compression, signal processing. You wouldn't work if you weren't conscious.

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by visarga on Sunday April 09, 2017 @12:57AM (#14070557)
Put it in another way, consciousness is selecting actions that lead are associated with maximal predicted rewards. So it's a system that has perception and ranks possible actions. Its role is to make us more adaptive to external states.
Re:Is Matter Conscious? by SomeStupidPoint on Saturday April 08, 2017 @02:51PM (#14068347)
Well, that would agree with the article and disagree with the person I was replying to.

So I think you're responding to the wrong person.