I would agree. I don't think such a general statement is valid.
> Even money is an invention of the state.
This I highly disagree with. I think the evidence is quite clear that money was independently arrived at both by state and by trade. It depends a bit on how you define it, but I think no other conclusion is possible.
> It's the idea that markets know what is better for us what many reject.
I don't understand who is making that argument.The hole point of Hayek is that you can follow your own goals and as long as you are in a market structure you will be helped in doing so.
If with 'us' you mean a state by democratic rule then the matter gets more complicated because its not at all clear that the outcome of the democratic process is a better 'aggregation of wills' then a market process.
Money as debt, that I would argue is the modern conception of money, as opposite to an asset (like cigarettes in a prisoners camp or gold), comes from the state.
For examples of this I would recommend the book "Making Money: Coin, Currency, and the Coming of Capitalism" by Christine Desan.
Also, accounting (and maybe even numbers and writing!) were invented initially as a way as registering debt in Mesopotamia by what today we would call 'the state'
>> It's the idea that markets know what is better for us what many reject. >"I don't understand who is making that argument."
I don't understand what you say here. Maybe I misunderstand, but it's not the whole point that markets deliver better solutions for everybody that any kind of central planning?
I'm not sure how what I mean for 'us' is difficult to grasp. Human societies?
You can also keep accounts in your head. The concept stays the same if you write it down or not.
If the notes you are circulation are IOUs for that good then that does not change the underlying concept.
> Maybe I misunderstand, but it's not the whole point that markets deliver better solutions for everybody that any kind of central planning?
Markets come about as soon as you have property rights. Property rights come about in many ways (I have other comments in this thread making this point).
When you of course go impose a property rights solution on a society then that is of course a form of central planning.
So I would say again, you can have both, you can central plan a market, but not all markets are centrally planed.
And apparently the notion of debt exited long before the notion of money. And even afterwards money was something used between individuals that didn't know each other (different tribes effectively).
It may or may not increase the status of the borrower at the same time. As long as the lender's status and standing are increased, either outcome is acceptable.
But if the status of the borrower increases while the status of the lender is decreased - because of a "default", or some other outcome that damages the lender - the transaction is considered morally offensive.
Banks are simply professional lenders. If the transaction were purely numeric and not political they'd be peripheral to the economy instead of central to it.
This is question begging to say the least. Political obligation [0] is "the moral duty to obey the law". Debt is money owed to someone [1]. Is that a political obligation? Yes, if the laws concern themselves with debts. But what if the law didn't concern itself with debts do you cease to owe money to someone? Not if they are able to enforce the contract of the debt in some other manner.
> Banks are simply professional lenders. If the transaction were purely numeric and not political they'd be peripheral to the economy instead of central to it.
Yes, state intervention in money markets is of monumental importance in achieving the system we have now. But it wasn't always like this and those systems were far from peripheral [2]. Free banks put themselves in debt every time they issued currency and the state was absent from the interactions.
To clarify, I'm not advocating against the state's importance in defending debt money. The free banking days of multiple competing notes was one of volatility and disastrous crashes. What we have now is strictly better than before. But to say that fiat currency "comes from the state" as OP did is simply not a historical fact. Period.
0: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/political-obligation/ 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debt 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_banking
I think the idea they're getting at is that collective preference isn't always well defined / well-define-able.
You're aware of Condorcet's paradox, right?
(Generally, one expects a person's preferences to be transitive, I.e. , if you prefer a to b, and you prefer b to c, then it is generally expected that you will prefer a to c. However, if you have a collection of people, all of whom satisfy that property, and have the group vote on what the "group preference" is between each pair of options, the "preferences of the group" will not always satisfy the property.)
This, along with a number of similar things, seem to suggest that maybe, at least sometimes, there is no "group preference". That the group cannot be treated as if it is an individual with coherent preferences.
So, if "we" can't always be treated as an individual who has coherent preferences, then maybe there's no coherent way in which "we" prefer something else to what the lawnmower does, in some cases.
Now, maybe in many practical cases, this isn't an issue. Idk. I mean, it certainly seems like humanity would "collectively prefer" not to be destroyed by nuclear war, or tortured to death, or whatever. Maybe even for most important things. I think the question would then be "in which cases are societies 'collective preferences' well defined, such that there is an achievable outcome which is 'collectively preferred' to what the market outcome would be?". This seems like an important question to me.
Another thing I find relevant is the VCG mechanism for social choice.
This is actually a kinda fundamental thing. I think one big (if not the biggest) reason people often talk past each other on such topics is that the concept of a society as an entity that is endowed with agency and preferences seems natural to some people and absurd to others, and it rarely explicitly comes up precisely because both beliefs are so fundamental.
Also, few people literally hold that markets provide "better solutions for everybody that any kind of central planning", at least in the short run. Trivially, a central planner who imposes a 1% tax on all incomes and keeps all proceeds for himself is going to be much better off with central planning :)
The existence of money precedes sovereign governments. The only prerequisite for "money" is consumption decoupled from the instantaneous moment of the trade (aka not direct barter) and human memories to keep track of them. That form of "money" has been happening for thousands of years. The prerequisite for "currency" is any item (coins, cigarettes, hotel loyalty points, scrips, etc) that's frequently used as an intermediate store of value to obtain other items.
However, a fiat currency requires a modern state to convince citizens to put faith into authorized pieces of paper instead of cattle/tobacco/yams/gold/diamonds/etc. If the citizens lose faith in government-printed money (e.g. Zimbabwe, Germany Weimar Republic), people will fall back on underground "organic money".
I would argue that money is an IOU, a promise of something that can be used generally, not only between the two initial parties (that would be a contract).
What would be the point of calling 'money' to cattle?
"That form of "money" has been happening for thousands of years. "
Can you give me some examples? because I have read about it and it seems that it's not the case. At least, not in very relevant contexts.
'[..] people will fall back on underground "organic money".'
Actually they start using currency of other states.
And it's not a "faith" thing, it's related to a real loss of value of the currency caused, in the cases that you mention, for supply shocks in the country (see http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?p=3773 ).
If people exchange goods for cattle just because they want some meat, than it's not money.
> Can you give me some examples?
Nick Szabo has a great history of money paper, "Shelling Out: The Origins of Money" with some examples.
Printing money is not by itself "evil" except in the eyes of several internet libertarians, and there is a reason it has been so popular: it is the easiest way to raise some money fast. It will always result in inflation, that's how it is paid. If the sovereign is sensible, that could also be how it ends.
Hyperinflation is quite another matter though: it is destructive to everyone, it is always a result of bad policy (that is, pushing segniorage beyond its' limits), and when and how it kicks in depends exactly on faith.
If it is used as a unit of account and a medium of exchange, then those things (as much as gold and silver coins) are certainly money.
What makes it a coin is that someone measured its purity, and stamped it with their mark to underwrite said purity.
The IOU, if not attached to a specific name, is just as good and exchange medium as that coin. Even better perhaps because the value is not in the material itself, but in what it can be exchanged for.
Frankly gold is nothing magical, it is just a material that is very corrosion resistant. Thus making weights out of gold would allow them to stay accurate longer while being transported around.
The coin form is just for exchange, gold itself is the base money.
> The IOU, if not attached to a specific name, is just as good and exchange medium as that coin.
This is where you are wrong. Exchanging a IOU of a third party increases the trust relationship to a third party. That is useful to do, and that's why banking exists, but it is not inherent or required.
> Even better perhaps because the value is not in the material itself, but in what it can be exchanged for.
Yes. But again. It is still bound to the base money. Look into how historical note issuing banking system work, there are great resources on this. The banks exchange the gold when they get other notes. Then they further abstract and establish clearing houses that do multiparty exchange.
Note here that the relationship always grow complex and more trust is involved, but it is all based on the soundness of the underlying base system.
The IOUs, banking and all are simple not required for something to be money.
Fernand Braudel has some wonderful books on this subject -- the second and third volumes of Civilization and Capitalism (the storied Structures of Everyday Life is the first), plus his book on the Mediterranean in the age of Philip II.
This is correct, but I think it is also useful to add that a system with very wide use of money would probably also require wage labour to some extent and from that the commodification of labour. Money becomes more useful the more things are commodified.
This makes me think how
exchange is deeply engraved
in human nature.
Or maybe the inmates had all been socialised in exchange based systems, and understood that the advantages of exchange remain important even in other circumstances?[1] http://icm.clsbe.lisboa.ucp.pt/docentes/url/jcn/ie2/0POWCamp...
It's not like they served different courses for various tastes there...
I suggest reading the R. A. Radford paper that I linked in another answer, it's really fascinating.
If I got your message correctly, you grew up in a communist country. Yes, those are horrible. But unregulated capitalism isn't any good either.
The problem for the early revolutionaries is that they either ignored or mistook these preconditions, and relied on authoritarianism to try and "hasten history." This obviously didn't work.
We could argue that in the palaeolithic the social organization had little to do with markets. We could argue that in the neolithic, the social organization was, in most cases, hierarchical and top-down."
~~~~~~~~~~~
you've made a bold statement but somehow eluded an argument.
how is exchange (i.e., trade) not a fundamental human activity? two people meet, one has something other wants, and vice versa. what do they do? ignore the situation? scheme about how to steal from the other? fight?
or do they trade? even in a hierarchical, pre-historic society, do the two just stare each other down, groping for a way to get what they covet without harm to themselves?
i might be wrong here, but might you be mistaking exchange (trade) for markets, and markets for capitalism, in an effort to strike at the underpinnings of capitalistic markets? or am i missing the crux of a valid but hidden argument?
Edit: Clarified what is being sold.
When trying to convince people who are of a differing ideology of something, I think it is often useful to use the terminology they are familiar with, and to use their shiboleths. Speaking to people in the language of their group probably often makes them more willing to take your ideas seriously.
Like, you use the term "labor-time", which probably makes perfect sense to the people who already agree with the ideology you are promoting, but for people who don't already agree (who are the people you are presumably talking to), they likely don't already have "labor-time" as a clearly understood concept that they recognize as important. If you want them to recognize the idea of "labor-time", you might have to convince them that it is an important concept.
>Markets in the capitalist sense, with people having to sell labour-time for wage in order to survive to a market of bourgeoisie is also a recent invention, a little over 200 years old. There's no reason to think it's the 'natural state' of humanity as some people have said.
Who are the bourgeoisie? The bourgeoisie are a class of people, the necessary prerequesites are roughly that they firstly own the means of production (i.e capital and land; machinery is of course also included in this), everything required to make commodities aside from the key component of human labour (unless embodied in 'dead labour', as machinery). The second requisite is that they pay for labour time in order to add value to the products that are made. The bourgeoisie are actually a minority, as the majority of people do not employ others nor own capital (they may do one of these two, but their conjunction, which is necessary to be considered bourgeois, is rare). Those who own stock however do not count as bourgeois, as this is 'fictitious capital'; they do not exploit others, though they do benefit from the exploitation.
What is labour-time? Labour-time is what a worker has available to sell. It is not labour itself, but rather the capacity to perform labour. For example, a capitalist (i.e a memeber of the bourgeoisie) would purchase a certain amount of sugar. Sugar is measured by the kilogram. In the same way, in order to produce a commodity, say candy for example, he will purchase some labour-time. Labour-time is measured by the hour. He will pay for a certain number of hours. Of course the amount he pays for is also related to the quality. Just as he may pay for poor or good quality sugar, he will pay for poor or good quality labour-time.
What are wages? Marx defines them in Wage Labour and Capital as follows: "The exchange value of a commodity estimated in money is called its price. Wages therefore are only a special name for the price of labour-time, and are usually called the price of labour; it is the special name for the price of this peculiar commodity, which has no other repository than human flesh and blood."
Workers, the majority of whom must sell their labour-time for a wage (by paying the wage, the capitalist has provided the labourer with a certain amount of meat, of water, of rent etc.) are referred to as the proletariat. They often have very little else to sell other than their productive capacity. Self-employed people may, depending on the situation, be counted as bourgeoisie or proletarians, though there is roughly a 'middle' class of those artisans or self-employed workers who are viewed as bourgeois-in-potential, petit-bourgeoisie. These are not very common, especially in the world where corporations employing economies of scale with many employees (proletarians) can quickly outpace the individual labourer or group of people in an equal partnership (e.g a co-operative).
I contend that this division of society is an example of class conflict, initially developed out of violence and coercion. It may be compared to a serf/peasant and a landlord in feudal times. Or even a slave and master in ancient times. It is within the interests of the proletariat to overthrow this system.
Why do I refer to a capitalist as 'exploiting' the worker in the exchange of labur-time for wage? For this, look no further than the profit after goods have been sold. If things are traded at equal [exchange] value, the capitalist will end up with some amount of profit. This is the amount left over after accounting for: parts to fix wear and tear of machinery, the object of labour (e.g land and material) and worker's wages. I contend that this profit originates by result of surplus labour. That is, extra labour which is performed on the job by the worker. The worker is not paid for the amount of value he creatos or imbues a product with, he is paid simply by the hour. The value of a product does not become apparent until the very act of exchange, it can only be predicted.
In short, I am trying to say that the wages which are given to the worker have no relation whatsoever to the value of the products being made (this value arising out of labour). The amount the worker is paid is only the bare minimum required for the worker to keep working. Too little and the worker stops. Too much and the worker will start to invest and buy his own capital, moving into the class of bourgeoisie. The value which the worker creates is therefore not returned to him in the form of wages. The worker, like a machine or amount of sugar, is used up, exploited. Exploitation isn't a bad term, it refers to using something up for what it is useful for.
At the risk of this being an insufficient explanation, I would like to recommend two resources: firstly, "Exploitation of Labour"[0], a chapter written by Itsurou Sakisaka as an introduction to Marx's masterpiece Capital. The second is An Introduction to the Three Volumes of Marx's Capital by Michael Heinrich.
For a more general idea, Marx has provided materials in pamphlet form. Wage Labour and Capital is one such document. It can be found at the marxists.org website.
I hope this helped clear my opinion up so that others can understand it.
[0] https://www.marxists.org/subject/japan/sakisaka/exploitation...
I'm sorry that your comment has been downvoted more than upvoted, when you were answering a question that I asked.
While I don't really agree with the conclusions, I do think this very much helped clear up your point of view, and also what you mean by those terms, and I thank you for it (and also upvoted you).
thanks
PS: it is nice to see an actual Marxist! :) Even though I disagree with them on most things (really just LTV, but you can't really take that one out, can you), they deserve my respect for having an actual theory, and for having genuinely progressive goals. Too much of the left wing is occupied these days by people with muddled, vaguely regressive ideas who have obviously never heard of historical materialism.
Marx wasn't a proponent of the LTV, he critiqued previous formulations of it and then made his own contributions to the theory that some aspect of the value of a commodity is determined by the amount of socially-necessary labour time applied to create it. Although I'm still learning myself, I haven't rejected it outright.
If I recall correctly, some work conducted by Cockshott showed validity of the LTV as a good indicator for the prices about which changes in supply and demand cause fluctuations of the UK market. I can't find it at the moment though unfortunately.
I think it's a real shame that sometimes points I make are downvoted without explanation. I try to be civil, though many people feel the need to downvote and not explain. I'm not going to refer to specific comments I've made, but I'm noticing that even bringing up the theory of exploitation or alienation is enough to gather downvotes.
Is HN a libertarian forum? I didn't think so.
And yes labor input determines cost, and in equilibrium cost and value are the same, and would be correlated in the data -- but reasoning from cost imo amounts to putting the carriage before the horse, and leads to all kinds of shenanigans with the "socially necessary" component...
It's significantly older than that; "capitalism" was described and named by socialists over 250 years ago, but labor markets of the type you describe are much older (the transition from feudal to capitalist economies began several hundred years before "capitalism" was named by its critics.)
We know that exchange is just one more activity that humans do, but, historically, in the thousand of years context, it was not fundamental.
We could argue that in the palaeolithic the social organization had little to do with markets. We could argue that in the neolithic, the social organization was, in most cases, hierarchical and top-down.
So, the implicit assumption of markets as the 'natural state' of human organization has not real basis. Even money is an invention of the state.
The idea that markets are powerful tools don't need to be defended. It's the idea that markets know what is better for us what many reject.
It's like saying that we should just start the lawnmower and leave it to decide what to cut. Then, when we don't like the garden, we have to accept it's for the best, because if a better garden was possible is what we would have.