I for one would totally bash something like AirBnB: who would lease a bedroom in his house to a complete stranger from the internet, are you crazy?
People were doing that before AirBnB, though, so there was real evidence that people were willing to.
They're a direct descendant of that ecosystem, which is designed --at least in part-- to take advantage of youngster's naivete. How many times has SV told us that ideas don't matter, that you need to hustle? These hackathons find those willing to put in the most work for little gain, besides "industry stature".
That said, on an individual level, I quite enjoy the scene.
From dictionary.com and merriam-webster.com:
Hack
verb: - to write computer programs for enjoyment
noun: - a usually creative solution to a computer hardware or programming problem or limitation - a piece of code that modifies a computer program in a skillful or clever way
The goal was to code for fun. Then corporations got involved and the goal became to code for a job. Now that money is involved, a goal is to code for money.
Where is the engineering rigor? Where is the quality assurance? Are all the edge cases handled? Security review / penetration testing? What is the performance when you serve 10K users simultaneously? Can one actually build a business out of the "product" of a hackathon, or does it basically need to be thrown away and re-architected properly? Is it even a goal to build something viable, or is it the whole event simply a way to spend corporate marketing money on buzz?