How in the hell can this just be called analytics?
This level of data isn't anonymous. It can't be.
If another piece of software did this, Microsoft would label it spyware and Windows Defender would kill it.
Yet, they feel fine doing this with an OS that they actually sell. It's not even crap freeware. You pay to have your every move watched.
aka, what dandelion_lover said.
is there some big list of the hardware I have bought? If not, sure, they can fingerprint me but I don't see how it de-anonymizes me.
Combine that with unique combinations... and you get an increasing confidence of who the end user is.
It's why they suggest you don't "full screen" browsers when using tor... Stuff like browser sizes can identify you:
https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/102133/how-can-...
It's easy to tell that if a custom screen size can identify you... what will other unique traits do?
> To e.g. determine when you used the TOR browser, since the difference in uptime between two time points is how much it was up during that interval.
Having personally talked with Microsoft engineers who handle what this data is used for, I can tell you they take PII very seriously and per user details aren't being shared with 3rd parties (at present). Could they be misusing this? Or start selling it? Yes, but it would be an incredibly dumb idea from a brand value perspective, and I trust them to at least protect that. (I do honestly think that like most people, Microsoft employees are well-meaning individuals with good intentions)
What is this data used for? The most common use is to tell a large software developer "you have a memory leak in version 3.1.x when running on 4th gen intel CPUs with driver version 11.3" or similar. So companies with wide install bases (Oracle, IBM, other Microsoft divisions, etc) can fix issues which impact literally millions of users.
If anyone reading this has ever received this sort of Microsoft communication about your software, could you share your experiences?
Being an American company, you also have to worry about Microsoft being compelled to disclose per-user details with law enforcement or the intelligence community. They have no choice when it comes to this, so allowing them to have this data at all is dangerous.
Imagine how damaging it would be to their brand value if they put ads in the main OS interface.
Then let me disable this telemetry completely, I'm fed-up with people that know better than me what's good for me.
I'm sure they do, but that still doesn't make me trust them or feel any better about this.
While (like many here) I'm very privacy oriented, this is a situation where Occam's Razor applies.
Not that's ideal, but it seems a lot better than Windows 10 seemingly indefatigible ways and means of sneaking data out. Ignoring hosts file and DNS responses is just rude.
[0] baseband attacks are still a problem, but at that level of threat then the BIOS or management subsystem on your PC isn't trustworthy either.
Not that I think Android is on a good trajectory in terms of user control, but hopefully alternatives such as Sailfish gain traction.
Linux and WINE have made great strides over the last few years but it's still nowhere close to becoming a full replacement.
On the other hand, most mobile devices have locked bootloaders, actively work to prevent giving the owner root access, and speak directly out to the Internet using proprietary networking modules.
If you have a clean android phone I suspect there no monitoring going on. For example if you use a community built mod or build AOSP yourself.
I know Windows is a large piece of SW, but this seems "quite" big for the "Basic" level... :/
Guess what mine is saying...
So, if you don't enable at least enhanced telemetry, Microsoft does not want to hear from you, does not care about your feedback, and no Microsoft employee will respond to your query on the matter.
I've tried to engage the Windows Insider folks over a couple different mediums, as far as I can tell they're barred from talking to anyone who even mentions telemetry.
Hey, LANGUAGE!
Incorrect. Please stop spreading this misinformation.
http://winaero.com/blog/how-to-disable-telemetry-and-data-co...
You have root, so you can run third-party programs to do it. I myself use O&O's Shutup10. But this is unsupported and Microsoft overwrites those settings with every major updates such as the 1703 update coming this month. So you need to run it again.
Also, I have Admin rights on my computer because I own the computer. If somebody else owns the computer than they are welcome to set the settings however they like to. So I don't really see the problem.
> Note: even though it originally came from an acronym, Tor is not spelled "TOR". Only the first letter is capitalized. In fact, we can usually spot people who haven't read any of our website (and have instead learned everything they know about Tor from news articles) by the fact that they spell it wrong.
Note that they don't tell you which of the other levels enables Windows Update telemetry, which is apparently helpful.
That's just a single datapoint, but Shutup10 and other similar programs are very popular. If it broke updates people would be making noise about it.
This should definitely work for hard disks, which have a serial number in their SMART data but do standard USB flash drives have any kind of unique identifier? There's the vendor ID but that covers every single instance of that model of device. Or is there some kind of identifier at the filesystem level?
Fairly certain USB drives don't have serial numbers, just vendor numbers that are far from unique.
[1] http://www.usb.org/developers/docs/devclass_docs/usbmassbulk...
Included:
"Storage attributes, such as number of drives, type, and size" -- So ID numbers of all USB storage drives you've connected? Better not put sensitive data on a USB and send it to a journalist...
"the number of crashes or hangs, and application state change details, such as how much processor time and memory were used, and the total uptime for an app." -- To e.g. determine when you used the TOR browser, since the difference in uptime between two time points is how much it was up during that interval.
"App usage data. Includes how an app is used, including how long an app is used, when the app has focus, and when the app is started" -- Oh, never mind, they also explicitly state they gather which apps you have installed and how much and when you use them in the next section.
"Accessory device data. Includes a list of accessory devices, such as printers or external storage devices, that are connected to Windows PCs and whether these devices will function after upgrading to a new version of the operating system." -- Print poster and glue it to a wall -> Printer gets identified via tracking dots ( https://www.eff.org/pages/list-printers-which-do-or-do-not-d... ) -> Printer is linked back to you, even if you bought it with cash. I hope you didn't print anything your local sheriff would dislike!
Edit: This is all in the 'basic' level, which you can't disable.