Re:Improving on Tor .onion Address Usability
by apeace on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @07:39AM
(#14041324)
> It's similar to what ideas 2.1 and 2.2 are in the blog post - a local directory that is maintained and authenticated centrally and then distributed to browsers that perform a central lookup. The downsides are that it is too centralized...
It is only centralized for users with the default install, who never go into their address book.
I think the real achievement of I2P's name system is that _they have made it easy for users to understand_, and the tight integration in the UX is the main differentiator I see between I2P's approach and any of the approaches in this blog post.
While I think Namecoin sounds cool and all, I really hope Tor considers a simpler approach. I think it's a mistake for us to make this into a technical problem, when it's a UX problem. We're never going to get 100% secure names in a trustless environment, so why not focus on making the default pretty secure, and making the system understandable and useable?
It is only centralized for users with the default install, who never go into their address book.
I think the real achievement of I2P's name system is that _they have made it easy for users to understand_, and the tight integration in the UX is the main differentiator I see between I2P's approach and any of the approaches in this blog post.
While I think Namecoin sounds cool and all, I really hope Tor considers a simpler approach. I think it's a mistake for us to make this into a technical problem, when it's a UX problem. We're never going to get 100% secure names in a trustless environment, so why not focus on making the default pretty secure, and making the system understandable and useable?