News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ghost in the Shell by Animats on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @09:15PM (#14038845)
Great concept art. Blurry final output. The director, for some reason, wanted the backgrounds blurred. The parent article shows the detail was there, but it's not in the final film. I saw it in 3D and XD (midway between regular and IMAX), and it was kind of painful. Avoid the 3D version.
Re:Ghost in the Shell by mrob on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @01:08AM (#14039820)
Before I was born, many directors tried to keep as much of the shot in focus as possible. Deep focus is both a technical challenge, because it requires brighter lighting, and an artistic challenge because it makes composition of the shots more difficult. You need to pay attention to the background so there's no distracting things behind the actor's heads, for example. You can't get away with shoddy sets. And it's more difficult for the actors. They can't improvise movement and let the photographer track them, they have to exactly follow their planned movements so they line up with the background correctly. I don't have any statistics for it, but it seems shallow focus is more popular now. But I think shallow focus is lazy and insulting to the audience. If your foreground action isn't compelling enough for me to watch then the solution is to make it better, not blur the background so I have nothing else to watch. Deep focus looks more realistic. In real life I can choose to look at the background details, and I want that option in film.

I want to see more use of deep focus. With the availability of high CRI LED lighting the technical challenge is much reduced now.

Re:Ghost in the Shell by mnw21cam on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @04:19AM (#14040583)
Shallow focus is (I believe) one of the main things that stops 3D working properly, and causes eye strain. The 3D part means that your eyes are expecting the focus distance to be a certain distance, but then it isn't, and when you try and look at the background and focus on it, it still stays blurred.

So yes, please no more shallow focus. And no more shaky-cam.

Re:Ghost in the Shell by white-flame on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @12:32AM (#14039664)
I haven't seen the movie, but somebody really needs to turn down the artificial film grain in the linked video here.

That's always been a completely unnecessary, distracting, and detail-killing option that I've never seen value in. Unless there's some stylization required for artificial aging or something, visuals should be as clear as the union of all sources can muster. Modern digital cinematic cameras have almost no film grain effect compared to old actual film, especially since we're usually talking about 24fps and studio lighting.

Re:Ghost in the Shell by intoverflow2 on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @09:29AM (#14041910)
>I haven't seen the movie, but somebody really needs to turn down the artificial film grain in the linked video here.

This is more likely to be render noise from pre-production tests.

Re:Ghost in the Shell by yxhuvud on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @07:36AM (#14041304)
What? It wasn't blurry for me. In fact, I'd say it was probably the best 3D variant of a film I've seen.

Well, except for the scenes that were intentionally blurry due to it being seen through the eyes of Major and shifting depending on what she focused on.