The music analogy fails, for me, because the foods they mention aren't meaningful or interesting, they're bland to the point of complete neutral inoffensiveness. It's like taking "Blitzkreig Bop" and turning it into perfectly balanced Muzak and calling that "high-amplitude."
Re:The Ketchup Conundrum (2004)
by devopsproject on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @02:59PM
(#14036059)
I think you are taking the terms used too literally.
I certainly wouldn't call coke or pepsi bland or inoffensive. They are certainly familiar since we have all had them hundreds of times. The article does a good job of explaining why the store brand sodas don't capture the same market share.
And, yes, mayo and poundcake are "bland" and "unexciting". But I've had some pretty terrible homemade mayo and poundcakes.
That... actually sounds like an amazing idea.
Re:The Ketchup Conundrum (2004)
by maxerickson on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @07:14PM
(#14038175)
I'm pretty sure that "bland to the point of complete neutral inoffensiveness" is a pop music category.
The whole point of the article was to explain why this does not work. Low amplitude foods spike in one category eg "Worlds Best" had the highest "tomato" score but failed in other areas. The reason people are not buying it in droves is because heinz has all 5 components in harmony.
The music analogy was perfect also. Take your personal favorite bands and songs and imagine their works being played by musicians in training. The results would not be as impressive.