For phones, it's an easy product decision, thinner/lighter is always better. You give the most benefit to the most users, and those who really need more battery life can get a battery case and pay the weight/thickness costs alone.
For a Macbook, it's a closer decision, but I think in this case they still reached the same battery life as the older laptops made the decision reasonable. Remember that it wasn't that long ago that a 7 hour laptop battery life was extraordinary, 10 hours should be plenty for most users. And there are also battery packs you can get if it isn't'.
I heard that Apple wasn't able to get a custom fitted 85 watt-hour battery ready in time for the release, and I expect they will refresh the MBP lineup with it when it's ready, giving an 11-12 hour battery life.
Then I build some C++ under Xcode and battery life is not so good...
Probably great for web browsing and casual use as used by 98% of users though.
Just because that's what you want, did not mean it's what everyone wants. I, for one, would love a solid inch thick brick of a phone with a replaceable battery, and a 2-inch thick laptop with sturdy replaceable parts.
Hmm, where'd the downvote button go?
In 2015 the macbook pro had a 99.5 watt-hour battery (100 watts is the limit to take on airplanes). Now it has 76 watt hours.
So you could get approximately 30% more battery life had they not prioritized thin and light.
Source: https://www.cnet.com/news/macbook-pro-october-2016-battery-l...