Re:Countering the Perception That the iPhone OS Is Too Closed
by bruceboughton on Friday June 04, 2010 @09:07AM
(#1404168)
It is still the case that cars under warranty need to be serviced at manufacturer-approved centres, isn't it? (In the UK at least...)
Re:Countering the Perception That the iPhone OS Is Too Closed
by elblanco on Friday June 04, 2010 @09:43PM
(#1406157)
Nope. I could take my brand new car to Jimbo's house of BBQ and Transmission repair if I wanted.
Re:Countering the Perception That the iPhone OS Is Too Closed
by RyanMcGreal on Friday June 04, 2010 @09:56AM
(#1404278)
Not in Canada or the USA. I don't know about the UK.
Where Meyer's analogy breaks down is in the fact that when you're trying to get apps for your iPhone/iPod/iPad, you're only allowed to shop at one store.
He tries to blow this off by pointing out that the Apple platform isn't the only mobile platform in town, but that misses the point.
The Big Automakers once tried to demand that people who bought cars were required to take those cars back to the dealer for servicing and add-ons. The automakers argued that this was the only way they could guarantee a quality driving experience.
It required legal challenges and government intervention to ensure the car owner's right to decide where and by whom to service and customize their own vehicle.