News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Social media's effect on journalism is greater than shift... by acdha on Monday April 03, 2017 @08:56AM (#14022386)
It wasn't perfect in the past but it feels like you're arguing against a straw man more than anything else. Nobody seriously claims that news was ever pure objectivity but in the past newspapers had far more money to support investigative journalism and, with so many more of them, that meant local issues which are increasingly ignored. Sure, every outlet had a bias but there was a key difference: a newspaper is an easily sued entity - no question of identity, local presence, etc. – and far more importantly the need to maintain subscribers in the general community placed a limit on how extreme any mainstream journal could get, especially in the news coverage as opposed to editorials. The WSJ might have been reliably Republican in its editorial endorsements but most liberals respected its business reporting, the NYT was roughly the same, especially on foreign coverage, from the center-left instead of center-right, etc. because they would check sources, print names and verifiable facts, etc. even if it was no more nobly intended than defense against a libel suit. Again, not perfect but there were multiple levels where there was a check on bad behavior for any major player. There were scandals like Jayson Blair but they were scandalous because they were rare and lead to people being fired.

In contrast the modern web of news sites are all chasing the same ad dollars and the barriers to entry are orders of magnitude lower. They get paid by the page view and don't need to be in a specific area, so the old check of needing to keep subscribers is gone and there's even a profit motive for running more outlandish claims. If someone were motivated to sue, it'd be an expensive and often international slog and the likely outcome even if successful is that a nearly asset-free company would fold before inevitably being replaced.

Re:Social media's effect on journalism is greater than shift... by matt4077 on Monday April 03, 2017 @09:32AM (#14022595)
I think you're making a good argument for the rise of fringe publications like infowars or (to keep the balance) motherjones.com.

But what I was trying to dispel was the myth that previously well-regarded institutions like the WSJ and NYT changed for the worse.

I'm pretty sure the Blair scandal (someone completely making up interviews etc.) would play out very much the same today as it did in 2003. I also cannot agree with the idea that these specific institutions are "publishing outlandish claims" any more than they previously did.

Note that these newspapers' finances are still very much structured as they ever were. The NYT makes 70% of its income from subscriptions ( https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/02/business/media/new-york-t...) and the number is probably higher for the WSJ, which started its paywall much earlier and is more stringent in its application. Digital advertisement makes up only 10% of its income.

Re:Social media's effect on journalism is greater than shift... by metaphorm on Monday April 03, 2017 @10:53AM (#14023143)
motherjones is a long-running progressive/political literary magazine. it started as an old media, printed on paper publication in 1976 and completely precedes the trend of internet based conspiracy peddlers like infowars. the fact that you're conflating the two "for balance" (as you say) is a serious error and it undermines your credibility.
Re:Social media's effect on journalism is greater than shift... by 3131s on Monday April 03, 2017 @11:10AM (#14023291)
Yes, comparing Mother Jones to Infowars is not fair. Mother Jones has some high quality investigative journalists like Shane Bauer.

http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2016/06/cca-private-pris...

Infowars is amusing though. I wouldn't have necessarily predicted their alignment with Trump 10 years or so ago when I first became aware of Alex Jones. The old Alex Jones even had some liberal tendencies, at times.

Re:Social media's effect on journalism is greater than shift... by matt4077 on Monday April 03, 2017 @02:44PM (#14025781)
Indeed–sorry. I've rarely ever gone to either of these places and seemed to remember some hyperbolic headlines from the campaign.

I'm pretty sure I've seen some cringe-worthy publications on the left as well, but it's certainly more common on the right.

Re:Social media's effect on journalism is greater than shift... by metaphorm on Monday April 03, 2017 @04:43PM (#14026961)
there are cringe worthy publications on the left. Huffington Post, The Young Turks, Jezebel, etc. They are hyper-partisan, screechy, shrill, unreasonable, gossipy, (nearly) empty spectacles in their own right but I don't know of a single one of them that is even halfway as far off the deep end of "motherfuckin lizard people aliens are running satanic child sex slave rings out of a pizza restaurant" that the infowars style conspiracy stuff gets into.

and Mother Jones is nowhere even on that axis. it's a higher quality publication with a deliberate (and publicly announced) editorial bias.

Re:Social media's effect on journalism is greater than shift... by Ygg2 on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @05:51AM (#14030935)

    >I don't know of a single one of them that is even halfway as far off the deep end of "motherfuckin lizard 
Give them like three years. I'm sure we'll see something like "Trump is secretly a Russian child smuggler".