News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Men Without Work by tomc1985 on Sunday April 02, 2017 @03:46PM (#14018667)
I just want to add that a lot of my jobless (and semi-employed), nontechnical friends would gladly jump into a good, entry-level position that would train them. What's sad is most of the entry-level work I see across most fields could be done with a minimum of training, even though employers insist on a college degree.

There's a lot of computing grunt work that I would love to pawn off on a junior, but our hiring funnel is so messed up...

Re:Men Without Work by remarkEon on Sunday April 02, 2017 @07:06PM (#14019545)
>What's sad is most of the entry-level work I see across most fields could be done with a minimum of training, even though employers insist on a college degree.

I'm in a graduate program now and I've become extremely cynical about "college" and "university". The mandatory degree("credentialing") is starting, in my opinion, to look more like institutional fraud than any honest attempt at teaching people anything.

Whoever figures that out, the credentialing part, could go a long way toward fixing that problem. Is anyone working on this?

Re:Men Without Work by intended on Monday April 03, 2017 @12:13AM (#14020563)
Your ire is focused on the symptom not the cure.

Take a look at india and china, they have this exact same problem, and it's a result of immense demand for STEM engineers, no matter what.

Marketing employees will have gone through a STEM education on a regular basis.

The way it unfolds is this -

1) If you aren't a degree holder, you aren't employable, there's millions of degree holders fighting for a job

2) you are a degree holder? Well there's 1000s fighting for your position, are you a hard degree or soft degree?

3) HArd STEM? What's your pedigree?

In short - allowing the system to take root (degree as pre requisite for jobs), sets of a vicious cycle.

This cycle only begins when you have a large group of unemployable humans.

To compete and be employed they increasingly turn to signaling. Eventually the old signal (actually interested In learning) gets overwhelmed with people who just want a job.

it's a jobs problem not an education problem.

Re:Men Without Work by brut on Sunday April 02, 2017 @09:45PM (#14020098)
One of my professors made a point about college: it's not about getting a job or not, but rather, being a button-pusher or understanding what you're doing. It's way too easy to become a "button-pusher". I am 100% confident that I could successfully perform a relatively complex cardiac surgery on a patient with about 2-3 weeks of training and some good staff. "Cut here, tie that together, done".

The thing is, there is a HUGE difference between what I described and actually understanding what one is doing, in the deepest meaning of that word. That's what you go to college for: to pass on that deep knowledge. You don't go to college to "get a job".

So the problem really is with employers: why do they insist on a college degree when they could ask for a technical school diploma, or whatever. There's nothing wrong with college per se, IMO, as I think you'll agree.

Re:Men Without Work by donw on Sunday April 02, 2017 @11:15PM (#14020380)
If the goal of universities is to pass on "deep knowledge", then I would argue that the vast majority of such institutions are utter failures at their mission.
Re:Men Without Work by brut on Sunday April 02, 2017 @11:43PM (#14020460)
We might have a definition problem, where some institutions that offer what amounts to a technical education (i.e. with almost no mandatory "theoretical" courses) call themselves "colleges".

In the workplace I definitely experience the difference between one who received a formal education, in the sense of raw theory, and one who studied how to "do" things. Both are useful, but they serve different purposes.

Re:Men Without Work by donw on Sunday April 02, 2017 @11:59PM (#14020509)
From my experience working in management over the past decade, I can say with some confidence that most computer science programs excel at pushing out people that can not, in fact, code in the real world.

Sure, they can solve ACM-style challenges and spit out Dijkstra on a whim, but I can't recall the last time I needed to deliver on a business objective that mapped to either of those things.

This is not to say that understanding computer science is bad! Having a deep understanding of the underlaying theory and technology is a requirement to attain mastery.

But being able to ship maintainable, well-factored, and properly-tested code in a collaborative environment is far more important to me than having memorized every algorithm in TAOCP.

I mean, if I can have both skillsets, I'll totally take both skillsets, but given the choice between the two, I know that a wizard-level software engineer with very weak algorithms skills will, in general, bring a lot more value to a project than a wizard-level computer scientist that can't write code that the rest of the team can maintain.

About the only time that a computer science wizard is useful to me, is if I already have a team of solid software engineers, so that they can mentor each other and lift the overall skill level of the team.

What universities really need to start doing is including a multi-year track built into their curricula whereby students build and maintain production software over the course of their studies, with quarterly rotation between teams.

Re:Men Without Work by codingmyway on Monday April 03, 2017 @09:05AM (#14022430)
Why not produce useful software needed by wider society as part of the course? Whether it's open source which will give them the github credentials or something like CodeForAmerica that fixes needed public works.

The problem is the dog eat dog narrow mindedness of seeing everything as a competition and not learning anything about collaboration and serving others. Something a lot of CS grads would benefit massively from, I know I would have.

Re:Men Without Work by donw on Monday April 03, 2017 @04:28PM (#14026821)
Also a good idea.
Re:Men Without Work by throwaway_374 on Monday April 03, 2017 @04:40AM (#14021395)
Equally to blame is the industry hiring process. ACM HackerRank and Codility challenges are often the first stage before you're put through a whiteboard. As a result, a competent programmer has no incentive to actually continue training in best practice, rather optimise for the interview process. I flat out refuse to do any interviews with this silly competitive programming hoop jumping. As a manager, what is your hiring process?
Re:Men Without Work by brut on Monday April 03, 2017 @12:19AM (#14020579)
I share your concerns, but I absolutely disagree with your last proposal: Universities should stay universities. There's a reason why civil engineers aren't pouring concrete and installing cables etc in a new hospital, for example. There are vastly more competent people for the tasks, and they all went to technical school (electricians, etc).

I actually think Universities do a disservice to their students if they promise them a curriculum that "leads to a job". You should go to University if you want to continue your formal education, not "to get a job". If you just want to get a piece of paper that lets you get a job, mentor with someone, go to a technical college, learn to "do" something. But Universities should teach how to think, that's about it, IMO. If you can find a job after should have no impact on the curriculum.

Re:Men Without Work by speeder on Monday April 03, 2017 @03:59AM (#14021249)
I am from Brazil, here people demanded that I should go to university to get a degree to get a job.

I can say now that trusting the adults was stupid idea, I ended getting student loans, got a degree, but no job. I am 29 now and my government job registry is still empty.

Re:Men Without Work by donw on Monday April 03, 2017 @12:57AM (#14020681)
Then we need to build an entirely separate practical education track in the United States, similar to how things work in Germany. We could base it in community colleges to leverage existing mindshare and infrastructure.

I would actually love to see this, but haven't yet thought through in-depth how it would work in the US.

Because right now, nothing like this exists, and until it does, the primary focus of most university students is to indeed "get a job".

Re:Men Without Work by thehardsphere on Monday April 03, 2017 @06:58AM (#14021871)
You mean like trade school? I'm not familiar with the German system, but the description of "practical education track" sounds a lot like trade school. Of which there are many in the US but are considered undesireable in comparison to college.
Re:Men Without Work by mtaksrud on Monday April 03, 2017 @01:42AM (#14020815)
This.
Re:Men Without Work by lawpoop on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @10:38PM (#14039215)
There really needs to be a division in American universities between Computer Science and Software Engineering, the same like you would find between Physics and Mechanical Engineering.
Re:Men Without Work by andrei_says_ on Monday April 03, 2017 @02:00PM (#14025319)
Or clearly defined apprenticeship programs. Which may not be part of universities.
Re:Men Without Work by andrei_says_ on Monday April 03, 2017 @01:58PM (#14025289)
A part of which is the difference between information and experience.

Schools attempt to cram as much information as possible in as little time in the overworked and overwhelmed minds of the students. The result is low retention and studying for the tests.

Knowledge and deep understanding come with time and experience in the presence of awareness.

The experiential parts of medical training for example are closer to hazing than anything else. We have enough research to know that the brain needs rest to process learning. Having people work for 24-36h straight does not do anyone a favor, is not sustainable and presents significant dangers to everyone involved.

Re:Men Without Work by remarkEon on Monday April 03, 2017 @01:41AM (#14020808)
>There's nothing wrong with college per se, IMO, as I think you'll agree.

Yep, I'd absolutely agree. I suppose my problem here is cultural, in a way. I didn't mean to say that I don't think young people (am I old? Maybe I am) shouldn't have to take history classes that are exogenous to whatever they end up doing later in life. I think what I'm trying to say is that there's a lot of room to make specific skills that employers look for separate from the horribly expensive University system. This has to be possible, but maybe I'm wrong.

Re:Men Without Work by reneherse on Sunday April 02, 2017 @10:37PM (#14020241)
Unfortunately, IME, neither is "deep knowledge" gained by an average student during an average undergraduate education, despite practitioners' best intentions.
Re:Men Without Work by brut on Sunday April 02, 2017 @10:58PM (#14020331)
You are right. It is also my experience that some graduates from technical schools are much more knowledgeable than some graduates from college. But the point stands, the two types of schools are serving different needs. We need both.
Re:Men Without Work by bdavisx on Monday April 03, 2017 @10:09AM (#14022837)
>I am 100% confident that I could successfully perform a relatively complex cardiac surgery on a patient with about 2-3 weeks of training and some good staff. "Cut here, tie that together, done".

And what if something goes wrong?

Re:Men Without Work by thesagan on Sunday April 02, 2017 @07:34PM (#14019665)
I really wish someone would. I know too many folks who've been laid off after an otherwise very successful run, and will not be interviewed by new companies because they fall sort in the credential category. It's enraging, frankly, because they meet and usually exceed all other requirements and yet the credential is what stops the hire.

I hear theories that cite insurance (that power company case) and other reasons, and I think they all kind of stink. It's as if higher education is more of a gatekeeper than mobilizer. (In some industries.)

Re:Men Without Work by remarkEon on Sunday April 02, 2017 @07:53PM (#14019750)
It would probably be quite difficult to hammer together some "agreed upon standard" for "levels" of proficiency in X_language.

That said, it's been done before...with spoken languages for the Military. Taking the DLPT will give you a rating on your proficiency, and then you get both the credentialing and then additional pay (Once upon a time I took it for Arabic and scored some 0+s). It'd be hard, but I don't think it would be impossible to do it for some kind of development credential.

http://www.dliflc.edu/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Generic-Fam... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defense_Language_Proficiency_T...

Re:Men Without Work by flukus on Sunday April 02, 2017 @08:28PM (#14019858)
> I really wish someone would. I know too many folks who've been laid off after an otherwise very successful run, and will not be interviewed by new companies because they fall sort in the credential category

I wonder if that's disguised ageism. A lot more people are going to college in the last decade than in previous decades.

Re:Men Without Work by thesagan on Sunday April 02, 2017 @08:46PM (#14019906)
If ageism is hitting in our early 30s things are worse than I thought.
Re:Men Without Work by LoonyBalloony on Sunday April 02, 2017 @09:23PM (#14020023)
"The mandatory degree("credentialing") is starting, in my opinion, to look more like institutional fraud than any honest attempt at teaching people anything."

New age indentured servants.

Re:Men Without Work by seanwessmith on Sunday April 02, 2017 @07:50PM (#14019738)
There's a company thats working on getting there. https://techcrunch.com/2017/01/20/sigma/
Re:Men Without Work by remarkEon on Sunday April 02, 2017 @08:06PM (#14019793)
It looks like they're solving a different problem.

Lots of analog credentials do exist that should be digitized (the SCUBA one is a great example that I've personally encountered), but I'm talking about a replacement for traditional, outrageously expensive 4-year Universities where a fraction of what you pay for is directed toward what you'll do for work - but more importantly, folks that wish to career switch from whatever they'd doing to a more technical field but lack that 4-year "degree".

Re:Men Without Work by arjie on Sunday April 02, 2017 @05:21PM (#14019102)
Quit your job, hire your non-technical friends. Train them up and run your consultancy that can beat everyone on price and is at least as good. Riches await.

Use the fact that you have the experience to sell the consultancy. Then use your army of once non-technical friends as your code farm. You can pay them less than market (since they were otherwise making nothing) and you can charge market.

You're promising an easy market opportunity. And that always raises the question, "If it's so easy, why aren't you doing it?"

Re:Men Without Work by glangdale on Sunday April 02, 2017 @06:19PM (#14019377)
... because his "once non-technical friends", after he trains them up, will either have to be paid market rate or will eventually jump ship to someone who does? This is a bit simplified (perhaps these guys will be grateful enough to stick around for a while, and not act like Homo Economicus).

You also can't charge full market rate if you are using the equivalent of apprentices/journeymen to do the work.

It's the classic problem of training.

Re:Men Without Work by zxcmx on Sunday April 02, 2017 @07:02PM (#14019528)
So the way a company charges market rate for juniors varies by industry.

In the trades, they generally get apprentices to do work at full chargeout (with guidance) with final signoff from certified person.

In consulting (IT, law, legal) you can either have tiered rates based on seniority of resource or a mixture of experience types doing "flat rate" job.

Re:Men Without Work by taneq on Sunday April 02, 2017 @10:02PM (#14020159)
> In the trades, they generally get apprentices to do work at full chargeout (with guidance) with final signoff from certified person.

And this is why I generally do the work myself rather than getting a tradie in. If I want someone inexperienced to give it a go and probably screw up, I'll screw it up myself on a Saturday afternoon rather than paying $120/hr for someone else to screw it up. At least after that I know how to fix it next time.

Re:Men Without Work by tomc1985 on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @03:18AM (#14030259)
Because, honestly, I am not so sure one can just be trained to be a good developer. There has to be some level of self-interest to hit the kind of performance levels one needs with a small team.

A worry about a lot of the people that are just joining the technical scene; they're entering a world where computing has been abstracted so far away from the actual hardware that many of them think the only way forward is to string together plugins (not that that's a particularly new phenomenon) and cloud services.

But for sales, or stocking a warehouse, or operations, or managing a team? Hell yeah I'd hire some of these folks. If only I had a business that needed that kind of staffing...

Re:Men Without Work by phkahler on Sunday April 02, 2017 @07:31PM (#14019654)
>> Quit your job, hire your non-technical friends.

Hiring a bunch of inexperienced people is not a good idea. Having larger companies sprinkle them around the workforce is better. Also, larger companies are more likely to need enough people to have a regular training program.

Re:Men Without Work by crdoconnor on Sunday April 02, 2017 @05:45PM (#14019204)
Probably because you'll be undercut by a company that doesn't need to invest in training because they will outsource or hire an immigrant.

And most people don't have the access to capital to start a business.

Re:Men Without Work by CuriouslyC on Sunday April 02, 2017 @06:43PM (#14019465)
Not everyone is motivated by more money. I like what I do, I have great work-life balance, and I get paid enough that I don't have to think about money. I wouldn't take a stressful job that I didn't enjoy doing for anything short of an obscene salary that allowed me to "retire" in 3-4 years.
Re:Men Without Work by pascalxus on Monday April 03, 2017 @01:32PM (#14025007)
Because, having access to cheaper labor isn't a competitive advantage when it comes to software companies. There's already such a vast oversupply of labor, it doesn't help companies if they have even more labor. Unlike other industries, in software, there are much larger factors to success than access to cheaper labor.
Re:Men Without Work by manquer on Sunday April 02, 2017 @10:42PM (#14020262)
There are people trying to solve the problems. zoho is well known in the Indian startup space for successful lly doing it

https//m.rediff.com/business/report/pix-tech-zohos-success-thanks-to-college-dropouts-and-high-school-grads/20141203.htm

Re:Men Without Work by 0x445442 on Sunday April 02, 2017 @04:05PM (#14018769)
I agree with the sentiment but the notion that all the folks inclined to work with their hands just need to become knowledge workers misses the mark I think.

A bigger problem is that capitalists can easily take advantage of labor arbitrage. But laborers can't easily take advantage of cost of living arbitrage.

Re:Men Without Work by tomc1985 on Sunday April 02, 2017 @04:18PM (#14018832)
It's not that they should all become knowledge workers, but tradespeople too -- construction, plumbing, electricians, etc. From what I hear it is very hard to break into these fields without prior training, which you need to acquire on your own and with some other means of supporting yourself (which isn't always available). I would love to see a return to master-and-apprentice style workplace relationships.
Re:Men Without Work by unholythree on Sunday April 02, 2017 @05:40PM (#14019183)
Some of these trades do have apprenticeship program's in their unions and at least in my city in the licensing requirements. To be a journeyman electrician you are first an apprentice for 4 or five years, and at least in union shops your pay reflects your (theoretical) ability.

So a fifth year apprentice make something like 80% of a journeyman as they should be capable of 80% of his tasks; while a first year apprentice pulls in less than half as he likely knows little of the trade.

Re:Men Without Work by hackermailman on Sunday April 02, 2017 @07:39PM (#14019686)
Vast majority of these apprenticeship programs first require that you have a 2 yr degree from some technical institute though, and there's very few that will hire you based on high school grades and agree to pay for your education with the exception of some power companies. Seems if you're crazy enough to be a powerline tech they will pay to train you.
Re:Men Without Work by Caveman_Coder on Sunday April 02, 2017 @10:10PM (#14020177)
"Seems if you're crazy enough..."

Why is this crazy? It's a very important job that actually contributes to society. I have much respect for T-men, Linemen, and Sub Techs.

Re:Men Without Work by hackermailman on Monday April 03, 2017 @03:12AM (#14021110)
Crazy as in dangerous, many deaths and injuries here over the years of powerline techs.
Re:Men Without Work by Spooky23 on Sunday April 02, 2017 @06:04PM (#14019300)
That all gets paid for by unions, which The US is about to push out in the interest of "freedom".
Re:Men Without Work by thehardsphere on Monday April 03, 2017 @07:02AM (#14021882)
By "freedom", you mean because 90% of the country isn't a member of a union and many of those people don't want to be.
Re:Men Without Work by icantdrive55 on Sunday April 02, 2017 @06:31PM (#14019428)
These trades are not difficult to break into, except if you want to make a livable wage, and that requires a union.

I guarantee anyone of you here, if remotely physically fit, could get a non-union job in construction. Good luck making $10-15 an hour. Even being a non-union electrican is not difficult. The contractor, will many times, train you, but it just doesn't pay more than retail.

You will see a lot of Contractors. It's not that difficult to get a licence. C-6 electrical being the exception. They are checking experience lately, and elevator mechanics--forget the number.

It's difficult to get into a good union, like local 6 in San Francisco though.

Why is the pay so low in construction, even field like Electrical, and Telecommunications? Partly it's because jobs are just hard to come by. And you gave a Huge swath of people who will apply to that job.

A couple of guys just got out of prison on the 70's. "What should we do now? Most jobs like will check out backround. Yes--they could check background then too. Convicts, "Let's start a landscaping company, or work in construction?" Good idea. Many could do these labor intensive jobs, and pull themselfs back into society.

They can't do it anymore, because there is just too much competition. I won't touch that debate.

If anyone reads this, and want to get into construction, apply to a union. How do you know this? Been non-union, union, and Contractor.

If you have some training, getting your Contractor's license is not that difficult. You will have a hard time making a good living off it. Most of you will fail, but the ones that really market themselfs, and have connections will make a living. You will find most people want to pay you the least amount for your labor, and knowledge. The wealthy are the worst. You will be one of those people who pay minimum wage. I have never hired a guy off the sidewalk though--it's just something I won't do. Why will you just pay minimum wage? You can't compete paying livable wages.

United States has had a huge problem with low paying jobs for a long time.

I have known something is very wrong for a long time. I stopped listening to those employment numbers, they just don't add up to what I see, except the "able bodied workers, but gave up" number".

And as my dad said, if you fall into construction; Electrical is still the best, but it's all backbreaking work. Look into being an elevator mechanic--it's a high paying, interesting field--believe it or not. It's basically a union apprenticeship, and unions are only in big cities. A lot of guys want to get into Carpetry because they like woodworking. On most commercial job sites, you won't see much wood. It's all metal studs, and "get it done." If you do custom homes, yes--you will be able to do some woodworking.

You can teach yourself to become an Electrician. Getting licenced by the states is kinda difficult. You can even make over $100/hr. on certain markets like San Francisco. Union companies will hire you now, because the economy is so hot there. You will be called white paper though, and when the good times end--you will go right back to non-union shops, or another low paying job.

Re:Men Without Work by eru on Sunday April 02, 2017 @04:30PM (#14018886)
Not only cost-of-living arbitrage, but also productivity arbitrage. That's why we need more migration (internal and across borders), and lower restrictions on building more capacity for housing in highly productive places like San Francisco, Silicon Valley, New York, etc.
Re:Men Without Work by phkahler on Sunday April 02, 2017 @07:25PM (#14019630)
I met a guy who was highly motivated, seemed quite capable of doing work. He had lost his low level manufacturing job probably due to his own issues (he felt blamed of other peoples crappy work). This guy was desperate, had no place to stay, couldn't find a job due to a long criminal record (10 years in prison for a bunch of felonies) I swear if he got some solid mental health help, and a bit of training, he could make a solid electronics tech which we need where I work. He was totally ready to take whatever chance someone would give him, but he's essentially been discarded by society.
Re:Men Without Work by mikekchar on Sunday April 02, 2017 @10:37PM (#14020247)
Let's back up and not make it about this particular person. I don't care what job you're working in, if you were willing to hire someone who has not been able to hold a job in the field, who had a criminal record and even mental health issues, you would be inundated with applicants. If you interviewed than and selected based on motivation to work, you'd have a huge problem selecting from the people who are absolutely desperate to get a job.

But, in all honesty, can you actually provide what they need? Can you deal with alcoholism, or drug dependency? Can you deal with absenteeism? Can you deal with behaviour disorders that might even be violent?

I'm not saying a candidate will definitely have any of these problems (or others), but I am saying that I have worked with people with all of these kinds of issues before. It is crippling. It's hard enough to do a good job when you are with people who are able to hide their personal problems away for 8 hours a day and concentrate on work. If you have to deal with someone else's problems on top of your own on top of both of your jobs, can you really cope?

If the answer is yes, then please hire these people and help them. If the answer is no, then you're going to have to draw the line somewhere. Where? How much risk are you willing to take on board? How much risk can your organisation realistically deal with? The places I've worked at can barely cope with the problems they already have. Looking for more problems to solve will not actually help anyone if you can't actually solve them.

It sucks to let someone drown, but it is foolish to dive in and try to save them when you can't swim.

Re:Men Without Work by phkahler on Monday April 03, 2017 @09:44AM (#14022677)
>> But, in all honesty, can you actually provide what they need?

No. I am not a mental health professional. I did point out the need for that. It takes time and costs money and our world is not set up to provide it to the bottom rungs of society unless they are in crisis.

>> Can you deal with alcoholism, or drug dependency?

We don't need someone coming to work drunk or high. Again, people need treatment for these things.

>> Can you deal with absenteeism?

That depends. If it's once a week but I get good work 4 days it might be better than not having anyone at all. There are limits of course.

>> Can you deal with behaviour disorders that might even be violent?

Again, mental health issues. There is a pattern to your questions. I stand by my assertion that society has discarded these people. You are right that it's not my companies job to pick up the pieces when we have our own issues (and we do). But whose job is it?

>> It sucks to let someone drown, but it is foolish to dive in and try to save them when you can't swim.

Completely agree. I was pointing out a problem, not offering a solution. It may also be an opportunity if someone can figure out how to tap that pool of people for mutual benefit and not exploitation.

You're probably right about getting flooded with applicants, but I think screening would be extremely difficult with people wanting to overstate their motivation and skills just to get a job.

In the end, everyone has to find their own path. It just seems like we've made that harder than it has to be.

Re:Men Without Work by LoonyBalloony on Sunday April 02, 2017 @09:26PM (#14020032)
People don't matter, money does. The economy works for money, not the humans it was created to serve.
Re:Men Without Work by Spooky23 on Sunday April 02, 2017 @06:02PM (#14019295)
Why do that, when you can hire some body shop $90/hr to pay some poor Indian kid $18?
Re:Men Without Work by intended on Monday April 03, 2017 @12:29AM (#14020602)
Hey don't forget - that poor Indian kid is still better off for it.
Re:Men Without Work by Spooky23 on Monday April 03, 2017 @09:53AM (#14022737)
We would all be better off if our immigration system didn't create a process where some bodyshop pimp gets to skim 50-80% of the billing!

When my grandparents immigrated here, they did scutwork for low pay, but at least they got to work for their employer. There wasn't some layer of middlemen skimming the cream.

Re:Men Without Work by dukeluke on Monday April 03, 2017 @07:14AM (#14021931)
This is true, but when an entire society does this, then all it does is exploit cheap labor and leads to a race to the bottom to see who can charge the least, all while the capital owners reap the rewards.