News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Some Tips to Improve the Civility on Hacker News by msuster on Thursday June 03, 2010 @10:33AM (#1401409)
I wrote the first post. The title was too extreme. I acknowledged that and apologized for it. I agree that many of the comments were fair and said so in this post. This isn't my first post to get FU's. I can live with that. I still wonder whether my suggestions may help?
Re:Some Tips to Improve the Civility on Hacker News by thaumaturgy on Thursday June 03, 2010 @11:21AM (#1401544)
Well, for most of the folks that are regulars here, HN is still considered to have a pretty decent tone overall. There are tons and tons of counterexamples to your examples of "meanness" -- and, by the way, some of your examples of meanness seem to be conflated with angriness, and anger seems to be generally acceptable here.

The rest of your post comes off as licking your wounds over the response to your last article. That, or, more cynically, attempting to get the greatest possible mileage out of your job hoppers post.

And ... don't you think maybe that blogging about HN is the silliest waste of time? Out of all the possible subjects out there, and all of the possible insights to be discovered ... blogging about some forum somewhere is it?

Huh.

Re:Some Tips to Improve the Civility on Hacker News by shadowsun7 on Thursday June 03, 2010 @11:20AM (#1401538)
Your first six sentences tell us that you were mistaken, that the problem isn't as big as you realized, and that you are partly to blame. That is: you admit that you have grossly exaggerated the problem of incivility on HN.

How, I ask, are your suggestions to help when there is no problem to solve?

Re:Some Tips to Improve the Civility on Hacker News by philk on Thursday June 03, 2010 @11:17AM (#1401528)
I don't really see that there's a problem with incivility on HN.

Of your suggestions I only take issue with the first; if I had to post with my full name I'd leave. I've already got Facebook/Twitter/blogging if I want to publish something on the web with my real name.

I'm also not sure how easy it would be to enforce.

On a side note I usually really enjoy your blog. So, you know, thanks in general.

Re:Some Tips to Improve the Civility on Hacker News by earl on Thursday June 03, 2010 @03:40PM (#1402282)
It's funny -- I was reaching for a phrase to describe your post, remembered reading the phrase grinfucker on a blog post linked here, searched, and it's your blog! Small world. It's not quite the phrase I need, but I'd like to repurpose it.

So Mark, the deal is simple -- your post was about grinfucking employees, trying to convince us that a behaving in a way almost exclusively in employers' interests is actually in employees' interests. So, you know, say whatever you want to whoever you want, it's your reputation. But when you get called on it, even in language with naughty words, sack up. And frankly, I responded exactly the way I would in person -- I don't like it when people try to sell me a line.