News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SES-10 Mission by hayd on Thursday March 30, 2017 @07:25PM (#13999838)
> I can't help thinking that those people who get excited > about building a city on mars are completely delusional.

That's what they once said about walking on the moon.

Re:SES-10 Mission by grondilu on Thursday March 30, 2017 @07:35PM (#13999899)
Well, there is probably a reason why nobody thought it was worth doing it again ever since.

More seriously though, just because many projects were wrongly considered foolish in the past, does not mean one can not point at a new one and call it foolish. History tends to remember those who turned out to be brilliant, and forget all those who genuinely were foolish.

The example I like is Franz Reichelt [1]. People around him were watching as he prepared to meet his death. Nobody said "don't do that, you'll kill yourself". Why? I guess because they were not sure, and they did not want to be the person who dissed someone who might be remembered as say the Wright brothers were.

I guess I'm not comfortable being the guy who says nothing as he watches people being foolish or delusional.

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FBN3xfGrx_U

Re:SES-10 Mission by sqeaky on Thursday March 30, 2017 @09:16PM (#14000491)
Was he really foolish or just ahead of his time and willing to brave the risks?

OK, that one guy was foolish he should have started small and worked his way up. Perhaps a death defying leap onto a mattress, would have been better. But there are plenty of others who were close to a variety of successes and them not succeeding doesn't mean they were foolish.

There must have been hundreds or thousands of potential aviators, but we remember the brothers at Kittyhawk because of their success. This doesn't make the others fools, likely they were successful in some of their other plans or iterated on designs more like the flyer afterwards. From all of their perspectives as long as they minimized danger, unlike Franz, they would live to see another day and keep attempting High risk High reward situations.

This is much the same with startups today. Plenty made their fortunes in tech startups and while history might call all but a few failures, many are relaxing with their millions or even just comfortable enjoying their backup plan of a high tech job and settling down with a family.

EDIT - Grammar, wording and spelling.

Re:SES-10 Mission by platypii on Thursday March 30, 2017 @09:20PM (#14000511)
Franz Reichelt clearly failed in his approach, but his idea was not crazy -- today we have wingsuits that can fly.
Re:SES-10 Mission by grondilu on Thursday March 30, 2017 @09:32PM (#14000557)
Yet as of today nobody has ever landed with just a wingsuit. You need a parachute.
Re:SES-10 Mission by an_cap on Thursday March 30, 2017 @09:47PM (#14000632)
Re:SES-10 Mission by grondilu on Thursday March 30, 2017 @10:01PM (#14000673)
That's an argument of semantics. I mean people can jump onto giant airbags without either parachute or jumpsuit from very high heights. I wouldn't call that landing, and in any case that's not what Franz Reichet was attempting.