News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Illegal to record an on-duty officer? by jrockway on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @02:38PM (#1398907)
It will be interesting to watch the outcomes of the appeals.

The dangerous underlying issue is applying statutes to situations that they were not written to cover. If the government wants to make it illegal to videotape police officers, the law should say "it is a class 1 felony to videotape police officers". If the intentions of what a law prohibits is not made clear, how can people be expected to comply? When the law can be shaped to cover whatever a prosecutor dislikes about a particular person, then law becomes a tool of oppression, not a way to ensure an orderly society. How can I not violate the law if I don't know what the law is!?

The second dangerous underlying issue is that it is not clearly illegal to pass such a law.

People tend to misuse the expression "police state", but if these convictions stick, that is exactly what this is. When you are legally unable to prepare evidence in your own defense, there might as well not be a criminal justice system at all.

I propose that we pass a law, perhaps with a clever name like the "PROTECT CHILDREN act" (you make the backronym), that makes it a Class I felony for any police officer or other government official acting in an official capacity to interfere with any video recording of events that would otherwise occur in the plain view of the recorder. (You can't go into someone's home and videotape the police, but you can videotape the police when they come to arrest you.)

This will never happen, though. Oh well, at least everyone has McDonalds and a big-screen TV...

Re:Illegal to record an on-duty officer? by dnsworks on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @11:16PM (#1400283)
Anti-Flag described the problem best in http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XEtEG2Q7zCk