Think about the original purpose of the FCC. Some regulation is required to make the services work at all. With a completely deregulated system, your microwave would disrupt cell-phone service for blocks. Your computer power supply might do the same thing. And Verizon phones would probably intentionally interfere with AT&T phones.
Low-frequency spectrum is a public resource, full stop.
Can't agree more. Corporatist rent-seeking is the fundamental problem with our political economy and/or society. But both sides keep talking past each other (as they are incentivized to do).
Tangent, thanks. This is the phrase I was trying to conjure to mind earlier today in a discussion about the very topic of this thread. Ended up taking a long, exhaustive and context-laden road to get to my point; after which I had already lost an audience but so it goes.
For the interested: https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Rent-seeking
https://arstechnica.com/business/2014/04/one-big-reason-we-l...
https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/the-fcc-cant-help...
https://consumerist.com/2015/05/26/why-your-cable-company-do...
Government regulation contributes much to the cost of investing in infrastructure and starting an ISP business in most areas. I think it would be interesting to see what would happen if that cost could be brought down.
VPNs are a strategy for mitigating an individual's exposure—leaving the monopoly of the ISP intact.
Monopolies don't last in a free market. Someone hungrier will eventually come in and undercut the incumbent.
Anti-cartel ones do the latter. Many properly made regulations are not easier to adhere to by big vs small agents.
Regulation is a tool, and it does more or less what the tool user intends it to.