I think the risks vary from platform to platform, market to market, and even possibly from executive making the decision to executive making the decision.
What are the risks of Apple competing with or even rejecting iDeco, an iPhone application for estimating decompression diving profiles? Minimal. Does that weaken the argument that building on a proprietary platform places you at Apple's mercy? I don't think so.
It's true that with iDeco they could reject it whereas with VPlanner desktop software they can only give away free decompression software. But this is like arguing the difference between living with a school principal who can expel you vs. a bully who can beat you up at recess.
If school looks good to you, go and enjoy yourself. The fundamental situation remains that when you build on a proprietary platform you expose yourself to risk of harm from the vendor. Manage that risk wisely and keep your eyes open.
Depends on the primary source of your visitors/customers. If that's Google (as is the case with many web companies) then they could introduce a service much like yours and direct people there instead.
In fact, I'd say that almost 5 minutes after the meeting Steve and I knew in our hearts that it wasn't time — that we didn't want to join Apple (yet). We maybe went through the motions of "deciding" on the flight back home, but I think we knew the truth. And the truth went something like this:
"This is our only chance to do Panic. We don't have kids, we're not married, we don't have huge obligations. We didn't invest our life savings into it, just a few hundred dollars. We don't even have life savings. We probably won't get this opportunity again in our lifetime — the full chance to take a complete risk, to experiment, quit our day jobs, start a business that certainly may fail, put our hearts into the soul of it, and try to make it fly — making the best possible Macintosh software we can without the threat of mortgages or the cost of braces or kids wondering why we're never home. And while there may be a time in our life where we crave some stability, or there may be a time in our life when things don't work out with Panic and we return to be a player in a larger, awesome team like Apple, that time is certainly not now. Panic's time is."
We can agree that Panic did consider a sale to AOL and Apple without taking anything away from the fact that a content-neutral proprietary platform still carries the risk that you will wake up one morning to discover that the vendor is giving away competition.
For example, Ventrilo was free to raise their rates because their success and profits really weren't dependent on the profits of the end users. They could jack their prices all over the place and most of their customers would have to pay if they wanted to keep their business going. They had lock in and they used it. They really don't care about how your company does, just that they extract maximum profit from you.
On the other hand, a company like Google has its success and profits dependent on your website being awesome. The more people who use the web and the more time they spend on it the more money Google will make. Google wants your site to succeed because it makes them money in the long run. They won't be as interested in jerking you around because they're not making money directly from you.
This is the right question to ask. If A depends on B, but B doesn't depend on A, then B might shaft A. But if A and B are mutually dependent, both can assume it's unlikely the other with shaft them.
Now Apple/Twitter/Facebook is going crazy and nobody does nothing...
That said, there are many difference between the Windows platform and the iPhone. When the DOJ started investigating Microsoft in 1991 they did have a monopoly on PC operating systems, and (as the DOJ investigation found) was using this power to unfairly give Internet Explorer an edge.
The iPhone platform may command the lion's share of the attention in the smartphone market, it is nowhere near a monopoly [3, 4]. The same cannot be said about the iTunes Music Store [5]. It seems, however, that the investigation into Apple's practices are moving beyond music [6], so we'll see in 7 years time about "does nothing".
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft [2] http://topnews.us/content/221070-apple-under-doj-investigati... [3] http://mashable.com/2010/02/09/android-iphone-market-share/ [4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smartphone [5] http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2008/04/03itunes.html [6] http://newsblog.thecmuwebsite.com/post/DOJs-Apple-investigat...
[Hope this wasn't too citation heavy, I tend to get a bit verbose when I am tired.]
If a single vendor gains control of the "market" for web browsers, as Microsoft did for a while, you are at their mercy. If there are multiple, competing web browsers and control of the APIs (e.g. HTML, CSS, JS) is decentralized, you are at the mercy of the whims of the marketplace, but no one person can wake up in the morning and decide to shut you out.
The concerns raised in this post are isomorphic to Apple's concerns about Flash. They don't mind developers using web standards to develop apps because no one vendor controls HTML, CSS, and JS. If developers write their apps in HTML, JS, and CSS, Adobe cannot flip a switch overnight and break every app on iPhone because their proprietary tools no longer emit a flavour of JS that runs on iPhone without errors.
So...
Proprietary Platforms are for Suckers.