News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by dguido on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @12:48AM (#13983487)
Before anyone races in with a suggestion to use a VPN service, I STRONGLY suggest that you consider running your own self-hosted server instead. There is a great set of Ansible scripts to do just that right here:

https://github.com/trailofbits/algo

Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by ransom1538 on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:02AM (#13983551)
VPN question. If you take out a credit card and pay for a cloud solution (aws,etc) and run this software, isn't your identity clearly tracked back to you via your one exit ip? It seems if you want to use VPN services you would want to be in a pool of users with many exit nodes - and have deniability?
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by Perceptes on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:08AM (#13983582)
Algo's stated goal is explicitly not to provide anonymity. It is to secure connections made on untrusted networks, e.g. while traveling. It will work for the use case being discussed w/r/t ISPs collecting and selling your usage info, too, because it's not about hiding who you are, it's about preventing your ISP from seeing the final destination of your requests.
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by Gnewt on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:08AM (#13983578)
It depends on your threat model. If you want anonymity, you'll have to take further steps. Self-hosting on a VPS that's linked to you protects you only from your ISP, which is enough if you're concerned about your ISP selling your traffic data. Of course, you'll need to trust your VPS' outbound ISP... but I think it's fairly reasonable to assume that consumer ISPs are more likely to sell your data than larger providers.
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by daurnimator on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:16AM (#13983619)
> I think it's fairly reasonable to assume that consumer ISPs are more likely to sell your data than larger providers.

Why? Most consumer ISPs are larger than data centre ISPs, if they're not the same company in a given region.

Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by WalterSear on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:27AM (#13983682)
Because, in aggregate, random server traffic data is going to be less valuable/monetizabe than home use traffic, that can be linked to a specific person or household..
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by Wingman4l7 on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:00PM (#13988279)
There are VPN services that let you pay in a way that can be anonymized -- like Bitcoin. You can take it one step further by using a VPN provider that does not reside in a country that is a member of Five Eyes (a spy alliance comprising of Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the UK, and the US).
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by cocochanel on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @12:53AM (#13983518)
So now it's at the point where we need to be running our own self-hosted servers? As a European I find it weird that America land of Silicon Valley does not fight for important issues like this. Can anyone explain?
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by newsat13 on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:12AM (#13983602)
I think you misunderstand how modern Silicon valley works. The new wave of companies is not about technology. It's about what makes money and effective marketing. Even Google which supposedly the tech lord of our generation.. is really about ads. Take away ads and Google isn't google anymore doing cool things as they will have no money for it.
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by cookiecaper on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:29AM (#13983690)
Yeah, I think this is being underestimated. These hip tech companies WANT to get as much data on you as possible, so they're not raising complaints. If they can get a contract with your ISP for access to all of your requests, they can see anything you do on the net, not just what you do from Chrome and/or Android!
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by javiani on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:08AM (#13983585)
I think it's called corruption. Most working folks trusted that rational people were in charge and a duty to the greater good would be more powerful than self-interest. I gather this sort of thing has happened before: http://www.rome.info/history/empire/fall/
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by rebuilder on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:22AM (#13983657)
Why would Silicon Valley companies fight for tighter government regulation of what and how user data can be used for? Wouldn't you expect the opposite?
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by stephenr on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:30AM (#13983695)
Because not all SV companies are data whores/pimps?

I know the hot new thing is to get zillions in VC funds to provide some half-assed free service, based on the idea that one day you'll have a heap of users who you can somehow milk for a profit, but once upon a time, tech companies made money by providing useful products and services that people were willing to pay for.

Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by mastazi on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @03:10AM (#13984063)
> Because not all SV companies are data whores/pimps?

True, but the biggest ones among them definitely are (depending on your definition of "data whores/pimps", Apple might or might not be included here).

Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by TylerH on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:23AM (#13983659)
The companies doing this are not Silicon Valley companies. They're old phone companies, more or less, that became internet companies because they owned all the cable that was already laid.

And of course the politicians passing this don't give a shit about the Silicon Valley culture or ideals; Republicans care about profits for corporations because that means more fat donations to them.

Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by CaptainZapp on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:41AM (#13983737)
Silicon Valley culture of ideals ?

No offense, but that's the most ludicrous statement I read in a long time.

Silicon Valley is about money and power. Ideals, apart from "ideals" packed into cheesy marketing slogans, just don't play into that.

Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by mastazi on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @03:08AM (#13984055)
To be fair, those old phone companies just wanted to be able to do the same thing that Google, Facebook and other SV companies are already doing. So much for the "Silicon Valley culture or ideals".
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by Endy on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:01AM (#13983546)
Sure, I can explain it in one word: Republicans.
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by cookiecaper on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:27AM (#13983683)
The idealistic conservative's perspective is that the government should regulate the minimum amount of conduct necessary to have a successful and functioning market. In accordance with free market principles, this regulation is being repealed on the belief that it does not serve a necessary function.

Before you scoff, please realize that legal restrictions are immensely heavy-handed, and very frequently abused or misappropriated. Regulations frequently accidentally overshoot their target, and they stay on the books for years. Discarding unnecessary regulations is not only good hygiene, but it may be critical to the development of some improvement or technology that the lawmakers had not conceived when the law was made.

It'd be nice if Congress was fast enough on its feet to recognize this as it was occurring and make the necessary adjustments, but it simply does not work that way; once something is law, it's very likely going to stay that way, untouched for decades or even centuries. Remember all the articles about the FBI attempting to invoke a statute from 1798 (yes, seventeen-ninety-eight, numbers not transposed) to compel the decryption of an iPhone?

For example, the CFAA passed long before the World Wide Web was a thing, but it's had an immense effect on the internet's development and continues to be misappropriated by large companies to harass small players and break their products before they get large enough to pose a threat. Another example is the Copyright Act, which, under current interpretation, considers RAM copies of copyrighted works as distinct copies eligible for protection. This means that you're potentially violating someone's copyright just by downloading their web site!

Combine these two statutes written for bygone times but very much in full effect today, and if you make the wrong person mad, you're looking at not only going bankrupt trying to figure out how to pay your legal bills, but also becoming a felon. Such was the case with Aaron Swartz, who was facing prosecution under these outdated regulations for downloading publicly-funded research papers from a paywalled database.

It should also be clarified that this repeal only removes one set of regulations, a set imposed by the FCC and that has only existed for the last couple of years. I'm not a lawyer, but somehow I doubt the issue is so simplistic that Comcast is going to open up "BuyYourNeighborsBrowsingHistory.com" any time soon. There are a variety of other laws that may apply to the legality of reselling such data, and surely these would require evaluation before the concept was greenlit. Furthermore, if Congress can be convinced that this is a bad idea, they need only to pass a new bill.

The core issue is that telecommunications services, including ISPs, are not what most people would consider a functioning free market, because 90%+ of the U.S. can not obtain comparable service from anyone besides the main telecommunication provider in their area. If they could, moving to an ISP that respected privacy without being compelled to do so by legal force would be a perfectly reasonable position to take.

The focus must be on getting our reps to solve the constrained telco market. Interestingly enough, that may also involve liberations to and/or removals of the FCC regulations around radio broadcasting, licensing, etc.

One humorous note: if we believe the most dramatic prophecies about the meaning of this repeal, the last season of South Park may be closer to real life than we think. A foreign company develops technology to uncover the complete internet history of every human and the real-world identity behind every anonymous or pseudonymous post and threatens to publicize these. Complete social breakdown ensues.

Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by republican17 on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @04:28AM (#13984352)
Actually, the Republican position is that the FTC (Federal Trade Commission), not the FCC, has the statutory mandate to regulate "online privacy."

In order to justify their legal authority to issue this rule, the FCC used a reinterpretation of legal terms defined in a 1934 law.

Often times in DC, the fight is not really about the end goal, it's about the path that is taken to achieve that goal. Usually, when you see literally unbelievable claims and hyped-up rhetoric, it's a sign that the situation is probably a bit more complicated than those who are making those claims are letting on. (e.g., "Republicans want to sell your, and their own, incognito browsing history because all they care about is making more money for big corporations!"). As everyone knows by now (see: TRUMP, Donald. 2016.), it's much easier to sell scary straw men than nuanced policy details. It's also a convenient way to hide what is really going on behind the scenes:

Nearly every Republican Member and Senator believes that consumers should have these exact same privacy protections!

That's right: they agree with the goals of this regulation! Broadly, these lawmakers disagree with this federal agency taking liberty with the law, especially in the Eleventh Hour of an administration. (Can you really blame them? The FCC is justifying their authority to regulate online privacy by using a law written 55 years before the World Wide Web was even invented!)

For decades, the U.S. government agency responsible for protecting consumers (ISP users) through the regulation and enforcement of online privacy rules has been the Federal Trade Commission (FTC). (see Privacy Policies, Safe Harbor, etc.). This is within both their historical role and their statutory mandate. They are the "nation's consumer protection agency."

Nancy Pelosi had two options: she could call it the "GOP Measure to Eliminate Internet Privacy" and score some (admittedly really, really, really easy) political points – or, she could try to get into a nuanced inside-baseball debate over the roles and mandates of specific regulatory regimes, and no one would bat an eye.

Easy pick for her. But that doesn't make it the truth.

Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by cookiecaper on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @10:50AM (#13986749)
There's tons of back and forth on this, but what I've heard is the reason these rules were set up by the FCC was that the new classification status of ISPs as common carriers took them out from under FTC regulatory authority.

I don't know the motives for the votes on this and afaik most members haven't commented to explain themselves. There are some particularly libertarian-leaning Congresspeople, like Rand Paul, who would clearly support it out of principle. We assume that others also support it out of ideological sympathy, and that everyone else is trying to play nice with the party leaders by going along with it.

You are 100% correct that a great deal of these legal modifications are technicalities that are touted as disasters for political convenience.

Let's not forget that the Republicans did the same thing when they pretended that the sky was falling over net neutrality going into effect, claiming that Obama was trying to "take over" the internet. Whether one agrees or disagrees with net neutrality as a policy matter, those claims are absurd.

Political parties, and especially the parties not presently in power, are always going to be trudging this type of muck up. It's very tiring, from both sides.

Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by pseudalopex on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @08:10PM (#13991821)
You're doing exactly what you accuse Pelosi of.

* The Communications Act of 1934 was substantially updated in 1996. Even if it hadn't been, age alone doesn't make a law outdated.

* The FCC classified ISPs as "telecommunications services", same as now, until the mid-2000s.

* The Supreme Court ruled in 2005 that the FCC had the authority to classify ISPs as either "telecommunications services" or "information services".[1]

* By 2010, ISPs had begun to violate the consumer protection guidelines the FCC laid out in 2005. The FCC responded with regulations, but ISPs challenged even the most basic provision: no outright blocking of lawful content.

* The DC Circuit ruled the FCC couldn't regulate "information services" that way but suggested the FCC could undo the reclassification.[2] So it did.

* ISPs sued over that too, but the DC Circuit upheld it.[3]

Is that the FCC reinterpreting a 1934 law or a court applying a 2005 precedent?

After that was settled, the Ninth Circuit ruled that the FTC had no authority to regulate common carriers.[4] The FCC published the regulations Congress just overturned two months after that.

I'll believe Republicans want the FTC to enforce these exact same privacy protections when they pass a bill giving it that authority.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Cable_%26_Telecommuni...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verizon_Communications_Inc._v....

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Telecom_Ass'n_v....

[4] https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2016/08/29/1...

Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by lxjw on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:07AM (#13983570)
What is the benefit of this over using a provider like PIA? PIA claims to store no logs, and this claim is supported with evidence that government entities could not force them to turn over any logs. But if you use a provider like Digital Ocean and run your own VPN, then Digital Ocean can and will log all connections and traffic to and from the VPN, and if a government entity of any sort ever approached them for any reason (such as if self-hosting VPNs became commonplace with DO, and the NSA wanted to suck all that data up), they'd hand it all over immediately.
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by Gnewt on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:09AM (#13983587)
You place full trust in the provider of your VPN. If you'd like to use PIA, you have to trust them -- and you can make your own decisions about that. I think it's fairly reasonable to trust them based on available evidence, but it really depends on your threat model.
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by toufka on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:09AM (#13983591)
The threat in this model is not the government, but rather from a private isp selling usage data attached to your name.

As you are a paying customer it is not in Digital Ocean's interest to sell usage stats attached to real identities. This somehow is not the case for Comcast.

Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by fulafel on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:21AM (#13983643)
What makes you think DO logs all traffic?
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by lxjw on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:40AM (#13983731)
They don't advertise themselves as a company particularly concerned with preserving the absolute privacy of their customers like PIA does. I admit I haven't read their privacy policy, but I'm assuming they would have no problems handing over logs, and I'm assuming they indeed keep logs (or at least are entirely willing to do so if asked to).
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by skynode on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @02:44AM (#13983959)
And here I am with the VPN solution :)

https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/pages/privacy-from-int...

Disclosure: I'm a customer but thankfully not a US-based customer (there are more and more reasons to NOT live in the US these days).

Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by mirimir on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @03:10AM (#13984065)
Are you an affiliate for them?
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by skynode on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @04:19AM (#13984315)
No I'm not.
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by mirimir on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @05:32PM (#13990778)
Sorry, that was a bitchy question. I like PIA too, but their affiliates are notorious for spamming VPN review sites.
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by jorblumesea on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:10AM (#13983598)
I don't think this is good advice unless you are a security professional or engineer and isn't a good solution for the vast majority of the country. The amount of things you can misconfigure, screw up or fail to understand is enormous if you aren't well versed. Imo, vpn service is like crypto: far better to leave it up to the pros. Rolling your own may leave you open to far worse things. The real solution is a vpn service people can actually trust.
Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by nuggien on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:22AM (#13983648)
You should read the mission statement of something like https://github.com/trailofbits/algo (linked to by parent post) before making this statement. Would you rather trust your own locked own server which does one thing very well, or a vpn service which has to provide everything under the sun in order to cater to as many customers as possible?

Edit: also https://blog.trailofbits.com/2016/12/12/meet-algo-the-vpn-th...

Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by jameslk on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @03:42AM (#13984183)
> Something to know about Algo: the VPN box operator, or whoever pwns it, can MitM all your TLS (!!) connections

https://twitter.com/FiloSottile/status/808355117011521537

Worth noting. I guess no solution is flawless.

Re:Anger as US internet privacy law scrapped by tensor on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @02:20AM (#13983875)
Isn't one of the benefits of a VPN service that many people use its exit nodes, thus the chance of identifying you is greatly lessened?