More WTF, they listed some members in their advisory boards (including Noam Chomsky), who didn't even know that they were members of wikileaks advisory board. [1]
There are quite a few things about wiki-leaks that doesn't make sense or add up, and perhaps the nature of their work creates some discrepancies in information about their work, but that shouldn't take away anything from some of the valuable leaks that came from wikileaks.
Two rules I try to apply in my life.
1) Be skeptical of anyone and everyone. Everyone is biased and everyone has a motive. "Who watches the watchmen"?
2) Don't put anyone in unrealistic moral standard. Avoid "herofication" of individuals or an organization. Humans are fallible.
[1] http://motherjones.com/politics/2010/04/wikileaks-julian-ass...
Do you have another example, from long time ago? That last one was widely panned, but prior to that, their editorialism wasn't criticized very much (though I seem to recall there was some; I just wasn't paying attention).