News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by redm on Monday March 27, 2017 @10:18PM (#13973527)
We (MediaFire) were part of the Amici brief submitted to the Supreme Court regarding the eastern district of Texas. [1]

It is a serious issue. Being a Texas company, we have been sued numerous times primarily because we are in Texas and it allows the other defendant's cases to be tried in the Eastern District of Texas.

The patents are always baseless, but it matters little. In almost all cases, the board of directors wants to settle the case quickly instead of fighting it out, even (in many cases) if the CEO or inside counsel wants to fight. It's cheap(ish) to settle and very expensive and time-consuming to fight; in short, it's a big distraction, one that can be solved with money. Since most of the plaintiffs are shell companies run by lawyers, there is little cost to them even if they loose and no value to the defendant if they win.

The exception to all this being Lee Chang at NewEgg who always fights. That works if you have a CEO and board who is willing to spend the time and money to establish a reputation but that is seemingly rare. Newegg also signed onto this Amici. [2]

This problem has been going on for a long time (8 years for us), and while we keep hoping for some reform, Congress is yet to act in a meaningful way.

On a side note, our former patent defense attorney, who clerked for the patent judge in Marshall, TX, left defense a few years ago and became a plaintiff's attorney. His reasoning? Much more profitable.

[1] http://www.scotusblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/16-341-...

[2] https://blog.newegg.com/lee-cheng-holds-reddit-ama-explains-...

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by amunster on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @01:00AM (#13974206)
Minor nitpick: Lee Cheng left Newegg in late 2016 to be COO of Gibson Brands (the guitar company). He will not be "fighting" in his new role. [1]

[1]http://www.law.com/sites/almstaff/2016/10/03/outspoken-paten...

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by 6stringmerc on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:58AM (#13976586)
He's traded fighting Weaponized Patents for fighting Counterfeit Goods in that respect, re: Chibsons.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by redm on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:33AM (#13976394)
I hadn't heard that; NewEgg carry's the fight on, though.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by cookiecaper on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:44AM (#13975060)
Congress is no longer an organ capable of representing the people. The only interests capable of being heard in Congress are those represented by lobbyists. Every time I hear someone who is directly involved discuss a grossly unfair legal issue like this, the answer always seems to be "We gave up on Congress a long time ago". These aren't necessarily interests with no money, they're just not interests with the most money.

The only hope for fixing laws that aren't upsetting publicly-listed companies is that the case will get an activist judge who will take an extremely broad reading of the statute and establish that interpretation as precedent. From a strictly legal perspective, in many such cases, it's quite clear that the law forbids the activity, which is what leads to a lot of unsatisfactory rulings.

I like the Constitution as much as the next guy, but we have to be honest with ourselves here and admit that the legislative arm is really not functioning anymore; they cannot fix the major problems that threaten innovation and small business. That whole branch needs to be rethought.

Maybe it is just a matter of dividing into 300 states so that there can be more local representation (fewer constituents per rep).

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by phkahler on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @08:27AM (#13975964)
The reason lobbyists are so effective is that they can influence a large number of representatives all in one place. An actual constituent can call his congressman, but that's a lot smaller influence.

IMHO one solution to this is to keep them all in their home states and vote on issues remotely. Keep all communication public, and exclude influence from anyone outside their home state. This would force them to get their input from the people who elected them.

On another note, every state should ban election advertising from anyone outside the state. There is little reason to allow outsiders to influence state elections. Hey, if you're going to get upset that maybe the russians influenced a US election, why not be upset when some national organization (including political parties) tries to influence a state election?

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by eyeinthepyramid on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:29AM (#13976367)
> On another note, every state should ban election advertising from anyone outside the state

How is this not a first amendment violation?

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by phkahler on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:48AM (#13976506)
>> How is this not a first amendment violation?

That is a key question. But how is it not outside interference in an election? OTOH, what if a candidate did some bad things in another state and someone just wanted to let you know? But the main thing is to eliminate corporate interference, and the notion of first amendment rights being applicable to corporations is long story. If we revoke the notion of corporate personhood that would help quite a bit.

I agree with your concern, but I hope you can see the value in trying to find a workable solution along these lines.

EDIT: changed "reasonable solution" to "workable solution" because we don't want politics involved finding "compromise".

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by cookiecaper on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @10:50AM (#13977011)
Corporate personhood is deeply entrenched in legal tradition. It's not a simple matter to reverse or extract that. See the Dictionary Act, Section 1 of the U.S. Code, which clearly defines incorporated entities as persons for legal purposes. [0] [Disclaimer: IANAL and surely do not fully understand the implications and background here]

I don't think artificial restrictions on political involvement are the right way to go about a resolution. That ultimately just forces participants underground.

Instead, we need an updated electoral process that allows full engagement from all interested parties and still has a desirable outcome for the everyman, small innovators and entrepreneurs.

IMO the biggest problem over the last century has been the consolidation of credible information sources into a handful of media conglomerates. The internet is helping reverse that, at least partially, though it's at risk too with Facebook and Google controlling the vast majority of the traffic.

[0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/1/1

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by phkahler on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @01:36PM (#13978697)
>> I don't think artificial restrictions on political involvement are the right way to go about a resolution. That ultimately just forces participants underground.

I don't see any justification for someone in Florida funding a campaign for a senator in Michigan or California.

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by LordKano on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @10:30AM (#13976822)
Even if it is interference, why should that be banned?

If I live in a reliably blue or red state, it doesn't much matter what I do at election time. I'll go and play my role and cast my vote but as an individual, I can't change the outcome of my state. I can pool my money with others to buy campaign advertising in a swing state that might legitimately change the outcome. If the Senators and Representatives are going to the nation's capital and passing laws that effect everyone, in every state, we should have a way to influence results outside of our own state of residence.

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by phkahler on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @01:32PM (#13978665)
>> I can pool my money with others to buy campaign advertising in a swing state that might legitimately change the outcome.

Oh. I'm not talking about presidential elections. That is a different story. But I'd say it is wrong for you to contribute to a group buying campaign advertising in another state for their congresspersons or senators. And that includes influence from national party organizations. Only people who live in a state should be doing that stuff (if any).

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by dragonwriter on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @01:36PM (#13978703)
> But I'd say it is wrong for you to contribute to a group buying campaign advertising in another state for their congresspersons or senators.

Eh, maybe there's a decent argument for that when it comes to their state reps or governors. But the federal government is a national government, and elections for the Senate or House are no less national than those to elect members of the Electoral College.

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by LordKano on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:19PM (#13980279)
If I live in Ohio but the junior Senator from New York has been talking about introducing federal legislation that will have an effect on me, I have a legitimate reason for wanting to influence the decision of the people in the state of New York.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by redm on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:40AM (#13976447)
The House of Represantitves did pass reform; it was blocked by Harry Reid in the Senate. [1] [2]

[1] https://www.congress.gov/bill/114th-congress/house-bill/9

[2] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/05/how-the-patent-t...

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by maaaats on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @06:06AM (#13975349)
> Since most of the plaintiffs are shell companies run by lawyers, there is little cost to them even if they loose and no value to the defendant if they win.

Would having to deposit some kind of money up front before the case is accepted be a solution to this? Then you cannot spam-sue everybody, and if you lose you cannot just claim bankruptcy to escape having to repay the defendants' costs.

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by marcosdumay on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @07:34AM (#13975712)
That officially closes justice to the common people.

If you are going to assume it's an extortion, just don't accept the case, or ask for evidence before calling the defendant in.

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by coredog64 on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @11:18AM (#13977304)
Other countries have loser pays and they've managed to do it without closing off justice for little people.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by marcosdumay on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @11:34AM (#13977475)
I don't know of any democracy that requires deposing money before you get access to a tribunal. That's not loser pays.

Raising the bar into requiring evidence before the court accepts the case solves the problem. No need to invent an access to court tariff.

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by redm on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:37AM (#13976436)
The problem is really Non-Practicing Entities (NPE) who are doing the trolling. I think you have to change the laws to eliminate the ability for an NPE to buy up patents for the sole purpose of suing. It would help greatly if Judges were a bit more decerning about the cases they accept too.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by TenOhms on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @10:02AM (#13976625)
I've been looking to build a new HTPC. Most parts I want are cheaper through Amazon (with prime) compared to Newegg and in the end I could save about $50 getting all the cheaper parts through Amazon. I'll happily give Newegg an extra $50 when I do pull the plug. Now if Amazon would join the troll battle...
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by devoply on Monday March 27, 2017 @11:53PM (#13973911)
words to the wise: don't invite lawsuits.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by DiabloD3 on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @12:59AM (#13974204)
So, don't have a corporation inside of the US. Okay.

Hey MediaFire, go reincorporate in Ireland, seems to work wonders for everyone else.

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by cookiecaper on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @04:34AM (#13975022)
You jest, but after my company was put out of business by a legal threat from a Fortune 100, I really do wish I had taken advantage of the ability to run it anonymously (collecting payment via something like bitcoin). Doing it above board didn't really get me anything valuable, and it made it easy for my enemies to locate and shut me down.

These threats are regularly frivolous and unfair, but big companies have a habit of bullying smaller players with legal force. There is no way to win; either you spend millions on something with no value (a legal defense), or you comply/settle and get the aggressor to agree to back off. If you try to fight, you end up doing both when you go bankrupt 5 years into the proceedings.

I only caught snippets of Judge Gorsuch's confirmation hearing, but it was awesome to hear him decry the evils of law school and the "ethics rules" that lawyers have installed for themselves, which he explicitly calls out as a money-making scheme responsible for over $10B+ in excess legal spending each year (somewhere around the 2.5 hour mark on the second day).

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by ThrustVectoring on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:31AM (#13975226)
Don't underestimate how valuable the right to be sued is. If other people have no recourse if dealing with you goes badly, they'll naturally be reluctant to trust you.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by rfrey on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @05:40AM (#13975259)
That might be true if your market is other businesses. The courts are largely closed to normal consumers though, because of cost and the perception that justice is for sale. I doubt many mainstream consumers consider "can I sue this company if things go south" when making a purchase.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by vertex-four on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @07:21AM (#13975653)
Personally, being in a UK, I consider "do I have enforceable consumer protection rights" when buying products online. That broadly amounts to "do they have a business address in the UK, contact info, are they active in promoting their business, perhaps do they have a physical shop", etc etc. I'd seriously avoid shopping where I couldn't contact the owners, unless I was doing something illegal (and therefore where I couldn't rely on my consumer rights) in the first place.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by cookiecaper on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @12:49PM (#13978234)
That's part of the tradeoff that you accept when you operate anonymously. Of course it will turn some people off, and as a consumer, that's a perfectly reasonable position to take. But as a business owner, until you have enough money sitting around to tolerate a lawsuit ($5M-$10M), if you're in a market that is willing to tolerate it, it could be a very reasonable tradeoff.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by vertex-four on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @08:04PM (#13982085)
I really doubt that many businesses would make it to $5M sitting in the bank without ever allowing anyone to know who they are - or slipping up and getting caught. I can't think of who would spend money with such a business if there were any alternative, in countries with well-developed consumer protection systems.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by olau on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @07:31AM (#13975701)
Except that if it comes to a lawsuit, almost everyone loses one way or another.

Sensible people and companies build up trust gradually.

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by twoodfin on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @08:21AM (#13975929)
"Decry the evils of law school"? I'm not sure what view you're ascribing to Judge Gorsuch. Surely he doesn't think law schools are evil.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by talmand on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:57AM (#13976580)
Decrying the evils of law school is not necessarily saying that law schools are evil.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by cookiecaper on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:35AM (#13976410)
Heh, clearly not the best description, gotta stop HNing at 4am. ;)

His main point was that legal costs are out of control. One of the mentioned factors was that in the U.S., law school is 3 years, unlike most international law schools which are 2, and how it's sad that most law school graduates are unable to afford their own services. He discusses how the attorneys' self-imposed ethical rules contribute to the expense and prevent things that would improve the accessibility of legal services.

I'll post a transcript of his answer when I get back to my workstation. On phone now.

EDIT:

Video link from the hearing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gWRzx3gZK7M&start=14409

Here's the transcript of his entire response to the question posed by Senator Cornyn according to C-SPAN's closed captioning (which is the only place I could find it recorded; lines and capitalization quickly corrected, please excuse any errors):

    > I really appreciate this opportunity to be talking about
    > these things.  Because I -- these I care about and can talk
    > about as a judge. I wrote that article in conjunction with
    > some input from a lot of wonderful people, so I can't take
    > total credit for it. And I thanked them. My point there was
    > three fold.  Starting with the fact that too few people can
    > get to court with legitimate grievances today.  That's a
    > fact. Too few people can get lawyers to help them with their
    > problem. I teach young folks law, who leave law school
    > unable to afford their own services.  Think about that.
    > think about that. And hundreds of thousands of dollars in
    > debt.  How do they go be "Main Street" lawyers?  How do they
    > help people who need legal services?  And I pointed to three
    > potential sources of problems where we lawyers maybe should
    > look internally rather than blame others for the problem.
    > there is plenty of blame to go around.  I'm not a big blame
    > guy. I am a look inside guy. What do I see in my profession.
    > three thing I pointed to, first, our own ethical rules. It
    > is a very unusual profession where we're allowed to regulate
    > ourselves.  It is quite an extraordinary privilegefvilege
    > privilege, usually the legislature.  Lawyers regulate
    > themselves.  And do all of our rules help clients or do some
    > of them help us more than they help our clients?  And i
    > point to some that for instance in regarding the
    > unauthorized practice of law, why is it you have to be a
    > lawyer to help parents with disabled children and
    > administrative proceedings to seek relief under idea? Was it
    > an example I pointed to. Why is it that every time certain
    > companies that provide online legal services for basic
    > things get sued every time they move into a new state?  Why
    > is it I can go to walmart and get my hair, teeth, eyes,
    > taken care of, but I can't get a landlord tenant contract
    > drawn up.  Those are all results of our ethical rules. I'm
    > not sure whether they're worth the price that we pay for
    > them. It is estimated I heard I can't verify it that our
    > ethical rules result in $10 billion a year surplus to
    > lawyers and clients every year. That was one.  Number two
    > was our own rules and procedure which yield cases like the
    > one we talked about, took 25 years to resolve.  That's
    > wrong.  That's wrong.  Should be able to resolve cases in
    > less time than it takes from my law clerks to be born,
    > raised and get through law school.  And the third thing i
    > pointed to was our legal educational system.  Where we have
    > three years of post graduate education for everybody who
    > wants to -- who have anything to do with lawyering.  The
    > best lawyer in the country in this history came from your
    > state, senator durbin, he didn't ever go to law school.  And
    > he always said the best way to become a lawyer, read the
    > books.  Still true. And other countries around the world
    > don't have three years of post graduate legal education.
    > this is where justice scalia and I -- a disagreement, he
    > thought three years was necessary for everybody.  I'm not
    > convinced.  In england where I studied, you could become a
    > lawyer through three years of an undergraduate degree or one
    > year as a post graduate degree followed by a lot of on the
    > job practical training.  I wonder whether all that debt is
    > worth it.  Whether it induces people to pick jobs they have
    > to pick to pay their debt ranger than serve the people they
    > like to serve.  Those are the problems I talk about in that
    > article.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by ubernostrum on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @11:20AM (#13977318)
This comment is completely unreadable on mobile. Please do not use this style to do fake-blockquote formatting.
Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by cookiecaper on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @11:39AM (#13977513)
How does it look on mobile? On my device, it goes into an something like an iframe with its own horizontal scrolling. [0] Does it stretch the page on some devices?

Unfortunately, it seems like the edit window on that comment has expired. If it's obnoxious, I can ping dang and see if he can fix it.

[0] https://i.imgur.com/zt9S1M5.jpg

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by sobani on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @03:51AM (#13984212)
And you consider that screenshot readable?

> horizontal scrolling

That part didn't give it away to yourself?

Re:Supreme Court Considers Why Patent Trolls Favor Texas Courts by devoply on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @01:33AM (#13974350)
not what i meant. i meant don't post your company's name claiming you always settle online.